VOOZH about

URL: https://forum.wordreference.com/threads/attributive.1256147/

⇱ attributive | WordReference Forums

Menu
Install the app
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

attributive

I have no one ____ me, for I am a new comer here.
A、help
B、helping
C、to help
D、to have helped
Key C

I always feel confused in deciding which form (of v-ing and v-to do) to use as an attributive.
1. He is the man helping me. (...who is helping me.)
2. He is the man to help me. (... who will help me.)
These two I think I know them well.

3. I have no one helping me.
4. I have no one to help me.
Why 3 is wrong?

Please help me with it and many thanks in advance.
ing forms of verbs are used to express the action in continuous form. You cannot use helping in the sentence:I have no one ____ me, for I am a new comer here as it will not make any sense logically.
3. I have no one helping me.
4. I have no one to help me.
Both of these sentences are grammatical, but they mean different things.

I have no one helping me.This doesn't work in your sample sentence, but it would work in another context.
At this moment, no one is helping you. Perhaps you are working in a store and suddenly there are too many customers for you to handle. You phone a manager and say "There are a lot of customers now, and I have no one helping me."
​
I have no one to help me.
This means that there is no one who could help you. Perhaps you need to paint your house and you live by yourself. You might say "It's going to take a long time. I have to paint it by myself. I have no one to help me."
​
I would have picked C, but not because B is wrong, but because I know enough to know that the test makers think that B is wrong. It would not be incorrect to say "There is no one helping me", it just isn't as likely as "There is no one to help me". Also, it should be "newcomer", rather than "new comer".
Back
Top Bottom