VOOZH about

URL: https://forum.wordreference.com/threads/stork-article.3221086/

⇱ Stork (article) | WordReference Forums


Menu


Install the app
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

Stork (article)

Yukio English

New Member
Japanese - Japan
Hi

For my first post I'd like to ask the following question please.

My friend reports to me that on the way to school he saw a stork (bird). I would like to ask him:

'Where you did see stork?'
'Where you did see stork?'
'Where you did see stork?'

Is any of the above incorrect for the grammar and context of the situation I described?
I see:
. . . a stork -> some stork . . . maybe I can't believe there was a stork to be seen?
. . . the stork -> the stork that he mentioned
. . . that stork -> same as the, the one just mentioned

If a native speaker says any of the three above, would it be correct naturally?

Thank you very much in advance.
Hi, Yukio.

Is any of the above incorrect for the grammar and context of the situation I described?
I see:
. . . a stork -> some stork . . . maybe I can't believe there was a stork to be seen?
. . . the stork -> the stork that he mentioned
. . . that stork -> same as the, the one just mentioned
All three versions -- a stork, the stork, and that stork -- are possible. You seem to understand the meaning of "that" and the articles "a" and "the".

A native speaker could use any of those phrases. "The stork" is probably more likely than "a stork" or "that stork" in that question, but the others are certainly possible.
Hi, Yukio.

All three versions -- a stork, the stork, and that stork -- are possible. You seem to understand the meaning of "that" and the articles "a" and "the".

Thank you, it's very nice of you to say. I am very glad!
A native speaker could use any of those phrases. "The stork" is probably more likely than "a stork" or "that stork" in that question, but the others are certainly possible.

Thank you. I understand.
Back
Top Bottom