VOOZH about

URL: https://thenewstack.io/the-engineers-guide-to-automation-maturity/

⇱ The Engineer’s Guide to Automation Maturity - The New Stack


TNS
SUBSCRIBE
Join our community of software engineering leaders and aspirational developers. Always stay in-the-know by getting the most important news and exclusive content delivered fresh to your inbox to learn more about at-scale software development.
REQUIRED
It seems that you've previously unsubscribed from our newsletter in the past. Click the button below to open the re-subscribe form in a new tab. When you're done, simply close that tab and continue with this form to complete your subscription.
The New Stack does not sell your information or share it with unaffiliated third parties. By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Welcome and thank you for joining The New Stack community!
Please answer a few simple questions to help us deliver the news and resources you are interested in.
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
Great to meet you!
Tell us a bit about your job so we can cover the topics you find most relevant.
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
REQUIRED
Welcome!

We’re so glad you’re here. You can expect all the best TNS content to arrive Monday through Friday to keep you on top of the news and at the top of your game.

What’s next?

Check your inbox for a confirmation email where you can adjust your preferences and even join additional groups.

Follow TNS on your favorite social media networks.

Become a TNS follower on LinkedIn.

Check out the latest featured and trending stories while you wait for your first TNS newsletter.

PREV
1 of 2
NEXT
VOXPOP
As a JavaScript developer, what non-React tools do you use most often?
Angular
0%
Astro
0%
Svelte
0%
Vue.js
0%
Other
0%
I only use React
0%
I don't use JavaScript
0%
Thanks for your opinion! Subscribe below to get the final results, published exclusively in our TNS Update newsletter:
NEW! Try Stackie AI
From clobbered drafts to real-time sync
Apr 14th 2026 10:00am, by David Moore
TypeScript 6.0 RC arrives as a bridge to a faster future
Mar 14th 2026 9:00am, by Darryl K. Taft
Mastra empowers web devs to build AI agents in TypeScript
Jan 28th 2026 11:00am, by Loraine Lawson
2025-10-06 06:00:55
The Engineer’s Guide to Automation Maturity
sponsor-pagerduty,sponsored-post-contributed,
DevOps / Operations

The Engineer’s Guide to Automation Maturity

Where you are on this maturity spectrum directly determines whether automation becomes a competitive advantage or just another source of technical debt.
Oct 6th, 2025 6:00am by Madeline Zemer
👁 Featued image for: The Engineer’s Guide to Automation Maturity
Image from WinWin artlab on Shutterstock.
PagerDuty sponsored this post.

Automation is business-critical for speed, scalability and resilience — a mechanism for survival in today’s complex, digital landscape. Yet the uncomfortable truth is that many organizations are nowhere near where they need to be with their automation strategy.

While some teams are drowning in manual processes and tribal knowledge, others have cobbled together scripts without any cohesive vision. This patchwork approach creates operational drag, blown service-level agreements (SLAs), sluggish incident response and costs that keep climbing.

The result? Organizations are constantly playing catch-up instead of getting ahead of problems.

Automation maturity isn’t binary. It’s not about having automation versus not having it. It’s about how strategically and effectively an organization uses it. An organization’s position on this maturity spectrum directly determines whether automation becomes its competitive advantage or just another source of technical debt.

Why Measure Automation Maturity?

Automation maturity is a strategic indicator of how well an organization is using automation to drive meaningful business outcomes. When automation efforts lack strategy or consistency, the operational fallout is immediate and measurable. Teams burn cycles on repetitive work, critical processes bottleneck around a few experts and fragmented tooling creates dangerous visibility gaps.

The compound effect? Manual toil leads to burnout, dependency bottlenecks slow everything down, security risks multiply without proper governance and innovation stalls as engineers spend their time firefighting instead of building the future.

Progress is rarely straightforward. Without an overarching automation strategy, organizations can suffer from manual, repetitive work characterized by visibility gaps, disconnected islands of automation only available to experts, security risk and weak change controls. That’s why measuring maturity is so important.

Teams can’t improve what they don’t measure, so benchmarking automation maturity helps teams see not just where their processes stand, but how those gaps ripple out into everything else. Beyond the technical benefits, a maturity model reveals opportunities to strengthen culture and collaboration, areas that often make or break automation success.

Five Stages of Maturity

The first step toward embracing, optimizing and scaling automation within ITOps and engineering is to understand where the organization currently stands. Consider the following maturity model and its five distinct stages:

1. Manual

Teams still rely heavily on manual, time-consuming and error-prone processes. Where it does exist, documentation can be found in wikis or runbooks, but demands a high degree of human intervention and is often confined to a few key experts. Over-relying on a small group of people using manual processes to complete tasks inevitably hurts productivity, increases operations costs and lengthens resolution times. Bottlenecks emerge and innovation is forced to take a back seat as engineering talent ends up being forced to solve the same old problems time and time again.

Even if automation exists, it’s likely at this stage to be accessible only to a limited few and to handle only the most basic tasks, such as server restarts. A lack of visibility into where bottlenecks are occurring makes breaking free of the cycle that much harder.

2. Siloed

Teams are starting to use basic automation, but it’s not fully integrated into daily workflows and is still confined to a few experts. They may use it to gather diagnostic data, provision infrastructure, make configuration changes or resolve common issues. However, there’s still an over-reliance on tickets and manual hand-offs.

The result is that, while the organization is likely to see some operational efficiency gains, bottlenecks persist, innovation remains slow and cost savings are minimal. To break the cycle, teams must embed automation into core operations so that it’s more widely accessible and replace isolated scripts with a more integrated approach.

3. Centralized

At this stage, everyone is empowered to use pre-approved automation on demand as a core part of operations, reducing time spent on manual toil and freeing it up for more strategic work. The organization may also have introduced frameworks for an automation Center of Excellence (CoE), which will help to standardize best practices across teams, supporting scalability and alignment with business goals.

Automation has been democratized so teams can do anything from restarting services and remediating issues to provisioning infrastructure and making configuration changes. The result is fewer interruptions for expert engineers so they can focus on high-value work.

4. Standardized

By this stage, teams have not only standardized but also centralized automation efforts. Rather than being confined to a few isolated scripts, automation is now integrated into critical workflows and, while centrally managed, is available via self-service within predefined guardrails.

The result is strategically impactful, organization-wide automation that reduces bottlenecks, accelerates incident resolution and supports business goals. It also means less human error and improved governance to support compliance efforts.

The stage is set for even more advanced and intelligent automation in the future.

5. Adaptive

The most mature stage in the journey is reached when automation runs autonomously and seamlessly in the background, dynamically responding to events in real time without human intervention. Users can tell AI agents in plain English what they need, and those agents will use automation to instantly execute the relevant tasks. AI can even help to build new automated processes in response to incidents or even planned work.

At this stage, organizations are often able to prevent operational issues before they even occur, reducing downtime and enhancing reliability and customer satisfaction. They can optimize resources, lower costs and improve employee efficiency to empower engineering talent to focus on strategic work. They take advantage of enterprise-wide governance to ensure automation scales without losing control.

Toward Continuous Progress

To begin moving through these stages, teams should consider which metrics will best help them to identify and address capability gaps.

In the early stages, it could be mean time to resolution (MTTR) and reduction in manual effort or task automation rates and time spent on innovation vs repetitive tasks. Later on, they may want to focus on governance and standardization, for example through automation adoption rates or the implementation of an automation COE. When approaching higher levels of maturity, it makes sense to consider scalability, agility and customer and business impact.

The end goal in tracking these metrics is to keep moving forward, refining and scaling their approach. Each small step brings the team and the organization closer to harnessing the true value of automation.

On this journey, technology is important. But it’s as much about changing the way teams work as the tools they use to do so.

PagerDuty is the global leader in AI-first operations management serving more than 35,000 organizations worldwide. The PagerDuty Operations Cloud is a comprehensive, multi-product operations cloud platform that sits at the center of the enterprise technology stack.
Learn More
The latest from PagerDuty
Hear more from our sponsor
TRENDING STORIES
Madeline Zemer is a manager of product marking focused on driving go-to-market activities for PagerDuty’s automation products. She has over 10 years of experience in high-tech and software industries.
Read more from Madeline Zemer
PagerDuty sponsored this post.
SHARE THIS STORY
TRENDING STORIES
SHARE THIS STORY
TRENDING STORIES
TNS DAILY NEWSLETTER Receive a free roundup of the most recent TNS articles in your inbox each day.
The New Stack does not sell your information or share it with unaffiliated third parties. By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.