---

%PDF-1.3 %���� 2 0 obj << /Length 5179 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 20.6626 0 0 20.6626 193.8 605.34 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(Con)40.7(v)17.4(entional)-255.5(implicatures,)]TJ -1.3067 -1.2022 TD [(a)-255.5(distinguished)-249.7(class)-255.5(of)-249.7(meanings)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 443.28 587.9401 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -13.1156 -3.0196 TD [(Christopher)-234.2(Potts)]TJ -0.4851 -1.9573 TD [(No)16.7(v)16.7(ember)-250.9(25,)-242.6(2005)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 446.82 Tm [(1)-996.8(A)-244(fr)20.9(esh)-244(look)-244(at)-250.9(an)-244(old)-244(de)]TJ /TT5 1 Tf 11.892 0 TD (�)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (nition)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 419.94 Tm [(The)-230.9(history)-220.8(of)-230.9(con)40.2(v)10(entional)-220.8(implicatures)-210.8(is)-230.9(rock)10(y)60.2(,)-220.8(their)-230.9(current)-240.9(status)-220.8(uncertain.)-301.1(It)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(seems)-250.9(wise)-261(to)-261(return)-261(to)-261(their)-261(source)-261(and)-261(start)-261(fresh,)-261(with)-261(an)-261(open-minded)-250.9(reading)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(of)-190.7(the)-200.8(original)-180.7(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.681 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-190.7(\(Grice,)-200.8(1975\))-190.7(and)-200.8(an)-190.7(e)10(y)0(e)-200.7(open)-190.7(for)-200.7(no)10(v)10(e)0(l)-180.7(support.)-281(Suppose)]TJ -7.2372 -1.2045 TD [(the)-301.1(te)10(xtbook)-301.1(e)10(xamples)-291.1(\()]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.7038 0 TD [(ther)40.1(efor)40.2(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.5852 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5812 0 TD [(e)10(ven)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 1.8215 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5712 0 TD -0.0201 Tc [(bu)-20.1(t)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 1.579 0 TD 0 Tc [(and)-311.2(synon)10(yms\))-281(disappeared.)-491.8(Where)]TJ -17.842 -1.2145 TD [(w)10(ould)-261(con)40.1(v)10(entional)-250.9(implicatures)-250.9(be)-271(then?)-361.3(This)-261(paper)-271(ar)20.1(gues)-271(that)-261(the)10(y)-261(w)10(ould)-261(still)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(be)-271(widely)-271(attested,)-271(and)-271(moreo)10(v)10(e)0(r)-261(that)-271(if)-281.1(we)-271(mo)10(v)10(e)-261(a)-271(f)0(e)20.1(w)-281(years)-271(forw)10(ard)-281.1(from)-271(their)]TJ T* [(genesis,)-271(we)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.9119 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nd)-271(in)-271(Karttunen)-271(and)-271(Peters�)-281.1(\(1979\))-271(multidimensional)-240.9(semantics)-261(the)]TJ -5.4681 -1.2145 TD [(basis)-240.9(for)-250.9(an)-250.9(ideal)-250.9(description)-230.9(logic.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Con)40.1(v)10(entional)-311.2(implicatures)-311.2(were)-331.2(born)-321.2(into)-311.2(ne)10(glect.)-532(Early)-321.2(in)-321.2(�Logic)-321.2(and)-331.2(con-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(v)10(ersation�,)-401.5(Grice)-391.5(adv)20.1(ances)-381.4(the)-381.4(term)-381.4(and)-381.4(a)-381.4(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 18.6895 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition,)-411.5(b)20.1(u)0(t)-371.4(primarily)-371.4(to)-381.4(set)-381.4(such)]TJ -19.2457 -1.2145 TD [(meanings)-291.1(aside.)-471.8(The)-311.2(pragmatic)-301.1(theory)-301.1(of)-301.1(Grice)-311.2(1975)-301.1(tak)10(es)-301.1(the)-301.1(form)-301.1(of)-311.2(an)-301.1(o)10(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(arching)-281(cooperati)20.1(v)10(e)-261(principle)-271(and)-281(a)-291.1(set)-271(of)-281.1(maxims.)-391.5(T)80.3(ogether)40.1(,)-281.1(these)-281(help)-271(to)-281.1(shape)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(both)-321.2(linguistic)-321.2(and)-331.2(nonlinguistic)-311.2(social)-331.2(interactions.)-552.1(The)-331.2(theory)-331.2(is)-331.2(thus)-321.2(tailored)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(to)-301.1(describing)-311.2(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-291.1(implicatures,)-311.2(a)-321.2(class)-301.1(of)-311.2(nonle)10(xical)-301.1(meanings)-301.1(whose)]TJ T* [(presence)-250.9(and)-240.9(nature)-250.9(are)-250.9(conte)10(xtually)-230.9(determined)-240.9(and)-250.9(ne)10(gotiable.)-291.1(In)-250.9(contrast,)-240.9(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(v)10(entional)-331.2(implicatures)-331.2(trace)-351.3(back)-351.3(to)-341.3(indi)20.1(vidual)-321.2(le)10(xical)-341.3(items)-331.2(and)-341.3(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-351.3(the)-341.3(force)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(of)-341.3(entailments.)-592.2(General)-351.3(principles)-341.3(of)-341.3(cooperati)20.1(v)10(e)-341.3(social)-341.3(interaction)-341.3(are)-351.3(of)-351.3(little)]TJ ET q 155.52 0 0 -0.48 110.868 178.968 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /F1 1 Tf 7.3723 0 0 7.3723 124.56 171.18 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 128.76 167.46 Tm [(My)-289.1(thanks)-277(to)-301.1(Ash)-289.1(Asudeh,)-289.1(James)-289.1(Isaacs,)-301.1(Bill)-301.1(Ladusa)12(w)60.2(,)-289.1(Line)-289.1(Mikk)12(elsen,)-277(Geof)24.1(f)-289.1(Pullum,)-289.1(and)]TJ -1.7947 -1.1925 TD [(Gillian)-277(Ramchand)-252.9(for)-265(v)24.1(aluable)-252.9(advice)-265(on)-265(earlier)-265(drafts.)-385.4(The)-265(w)12(ork)-265(bene)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 28.5161 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ted)-252.9(also)-277(from)-265(discussion)]TJ -29.0723 -1.2045 TD [(with)-301.1(L)60.2(y)0(n)-301.1(Frazier)36.1(,)-301.1(James)-313.2(Higginbotham,)-277(Angelika)-289.1(Kratzer)36.1(,)-301.1(Helen)-301.1(Maje)24.1(wski,)-313.2(�ystein)-301.1(Nilsen,)-325.2(Uli)]TJ 0 -1.1925 TD [(Sauerland,)-265(Barry)-277(Schein,)-277(Y)96.4(ael)-289.1(Sharvit,)-277(and)-265(Y)108.4(ouri)-277(Zabal,)-277(as)-289.1(well)-289.1(as)-289.1(audiences)-265(at)-289.1(UMass)-289.1(Amherst)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(and)-228.9(USC.)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 302.16 89.82 Tm (1)Tj ET endstream endobj 3 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT5 7 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 14 0 obj << /Length 7214 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(help)-250.9(with)-261(them.)-331.2(So)-271(it)-250.9(is)-261(no)-250.9(surprise)-261(that)-250.9(Grice)-271(closes)-250.9(his)-261(passage)-261(on)-250.9(con)40.1(v)10(entional)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(implicatures)-261(abruptly:)-361.3(�I)-281(wish)-271(to)-281(represent)-281.1(a)-281(certain)-281(subclass)-271(of)-281(noncon)40.1(v)10(entional)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(implicatures,)-230.9(which)-250.9(I)-250.9(shall)-240.9(call)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 12.5163 0 TD [(con)40.1(ver)10(sational)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 6.1341 0 TD [(implicatures)-230.9([)]TJ 5.5067 0 TD 0.1506 Tc [(...])150.6(�)-160.6(\()150.6(p)150.6(.)]TJ 3.6236 0 TD 0 Tc (45\).)Tj -26.3153 -1.2045 TD [(Despite)-351.3(its)-351.3(bre)20.1(vity)60.2(,)-361.3(the)-351.3(passage)-361.4(clearly)-351.3(identi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 18.4588 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(es)-351.3(a)-361.3(class)-351.3(of)-351.3(e)10(xpressions)-341.3(that)]TJ -20.4804 -1.2045 TD [(permit)-291.1(speak)10(ers)-291.1(to)-301.1(comment)-281(upon)-291.1(their)-301.1(assertions,)-291.1(to)-301.1(editorialize)-291.1(in)-291.1(the)-291.1(midst)-291.1(of)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(asking)-200.7(questions)-200.8(and)-210.8(imposing)-190.7(demands.)-291.1(Such)-210.8(e)10(xpressions)-200.7(are)-220.8(bound)-200.7(to)-210.8(be)-220.8(signif-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(icant,)-291.1(both)-281(for)-281.1(what)-291.1(the)10(y)-271(can)-291.1(tell)-281(us)-281(about)-281(ho)20.1(w)-281.1(natural)-281.1(language)-281(semantic)-281(theory)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(should)-271(look)-281(and)-281.1(for)-291.1(what)-281(the)10(y)-271(can)-291.1(tell)-281(us)-281.1(about)-281.1(ho)20.1(w)-281(speak)10(ers)-281(use)-281.1(language.)-421.6(Un-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(fortunately)60.2(,)-381.4(Grice�)50.2(s)-361.3(\(1975\))-361.4(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 12.1837 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-351.3(is)-361.4(entwined)-361.3(with)-351.3(his)-361.4(e)10(xample,)-381.4(the)-361.3(adv)10(erb)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf -12.7398 -1.2045 TD [(ther)40.1(efor)40.2(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.5852 0 TD [(.)-351.3(Bach)-271(\(1999\))-261(counters)-261(that)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 11.2632 0 TD [(ther)40.1(efor)40.1(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.8562 0 TD [(�is)-261(not)-261(the)-261(most)-250.9(con)40.1(vincing)-250.9(e)10(xam-)]TJ -18.7046 -1.2145 TD [(ple,)-230.9(for)-240.9(it)-230.9(seems)-230.9(that)-230.9(the)-230.9(truth)-230.9(of)-230.9(the)-240.9(utterance)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 18.2945 0 TD (does)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.0739 0 TD [(require)-230.9(the)-240.9(second)-230.9(proposition)]TJ -20.3684 -1.2045 TD [(to)-351.3(be)-351.3(a)-351.3(consequence)-361.4(of)-351.3(the)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 11.4465 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst�)-361.4(\(p.)-351.3(330\).)-612.3(Bach�)50.2(s)-361.4(assessment)-341.3(seems)-351.3(sound.)-612.3(It)]TJ -12.0027 -1.2145 TD [(naturally)-261(leads)-281.1(one)-271(to)-271(w)10(onder)-271(whether)-281(Grice)-271(has)-281(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 20.726 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-271(�what)-281.1(is)-271(said)-271(\(in)-271(the)-271(f)10(a)0(-)]TJ -21.2821 -1.2045 TD [(v)20.1(ored)-291.1(sense\)�)-291.1(too)-281(narro)20.1(wly)60.2(,)-291.1(o)0(r)-291.1(arbitrarily)60.2(.)-421.6(These)-291.1(concerns)-301.1(ha)20.1(v)10(e)0(,)-291.1(I)-291.1(think,)-291.1(resulted)]TJ T* [(in)-240.9(misplaced)-240.9(sk)10(epticism)-230.9(about)-240.9(the)-250.9(usefulness)-240.9(of)-250.9(Grice�)50.2(s)-250.9(concept.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Subsequent)-361.3(research)-381.4(added)-371.4(some)20.1(what)-361.4(to)-361.3(the)-371.4(stock)-361.4(of)-371.4(e)10(xamples)-361.3(\(see)-381.4(Le)20.1(vin-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(son)-331.2(1983)-341.3(for)-341.3(an)-351.3(accounting)-331.2(of)-341.3(them\),)-361.4(b)20.1(u)0(t)-341.3(w)0(e)-341.3(can,)-371.4(and)-341.3(should,)-351.3(do)-341.3(without)-331.2(such)]TJ T* [(te)10(xtbook)-291.1(cases.)-491.8(In)-311.2(\(1\))-311.2(I)-311.2(e)10(xtract)-301.1(from)-311.2(Grice)-311.2(1975:44�45)-291.1(the)-301.1(central)-311.2(properties)-311.2(of)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(con)40.1(v)10(entional)-230.9(implicatures)-230.9(\(henceforth)-250.9(CIs\).)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(1\))-1897.1(a.)-1455.4(CIs)-261(are)-250.9(part)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(con)40.1(v)10(entional)-240.9(\(le)10(xical\))-240.9(meaning)-240.9(of)-250.9(w)10(ords.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.6261 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(CIs)-261(are)-250.9(commitments,)-220.8(and)-250.9(thus)-240.9(gi)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(rise)-240.9(to)-250.9(entailments.)]TJ T* [(c.)-1455.4(These)-351.3(commitments)-331.2(are)-361.4(made)-351.3(by)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 16.1136 0 TD [(the)-351.3(speak)10(er)-351.3(of)-351.3(the)-351.3(utter)10(ance)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.8339 0 TD (�by)Tj -25.7994 -1.2045 TD [(virtue)-250.9(of)-240.9(the)-250.9(meaning)-240.9(of)-50.2(�)-261(the)-240.9(w)10(ords)-250.9(he)-250.9(chooses.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD [(d.)-1395.2(CIs)-321.2(are)-321.2(logically)-301.1(and)-321.2(compositionally)-281(independent)-311.2(of)-311.2(what)-311.2(is)-311.2(�)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 27.7071 0 TD (said)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -25.5591 -1.2145 TD [(\(in)-250.9(the)-240.9(f)10(a)20.1(v)20.1(ored)-261(sense\)�,)-250.9(i.e.,)-240.9(the)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 12.7179 0 TD [(at-issue)-240.9(entailments)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.9621 0 TD (.)Tj -25.8894 -2.0376 TD [(Throughout,)-240.9(I)-261(use)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.3905 0 TD [(at-issue)-240.9(entailment)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.8339 0 TD [(as)-261(a)-261(c)0(o)10(v)10(erterm)-240.9(for)-261(re)10(gular)-250.9(asserti)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(content)]TJ -15.2244 -1.2045 TD [(\(�what)-230.9(is)-240.9(said�\).)-301.1(This)-230.9(term)-230.9(sets)-230.9(up)-230.9(a)-240.9(useful)-230.9(contrast)-230.9(with)-230.9(CIs,)-240.9(which)-230.9(are)-250.9(secondary)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(entailments)-250.9(that)-250.9(cooperati)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(speak)10(ers)-271(rarely)-261(use)-271(to)-250.9(e)10(xpress)-261(contro)10(v)10(ersial)-250.9(proposi-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(tions)-230.9(or)-250.9(carry)-261(the)-250.9(main)-240.9(themes)-240.9(of)-250.9(a)-250.9(discourse.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(It�)50.2(s)-301.1(the)-301.1(w)10(ork)-301.1(of)-301.1(section)-301.1(3)-301.1(t)0(o)-301.1(e)10(xplore)-291.1(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 15.8243 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-291.1(\(1\).)-481.8(F)10(o)0(r)-301.1(n)0(o)20.1(w)60.2(,)-301.1(suf)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 9.5977 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD [(ce)-301.1(it)-301.1(to)-301.1(say)]TJ -27.9998 -1.2045 TD [(that)-271(\(1\))-271(picks)-271(out)-271(a)-281(class)-271(of)-271(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented)-281(entailments)-261(that)-271(are,)-281.1(by)-271(clause)-281.1(\(1d\),)]TJ T* [(independent)-331.2(of)-351.3(the)-341.3(at-issue)-341.3(entailments.)-582.2(This)-331.2(conjunction)-331.2(of)-351.3(properties)-341.3(charac-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(terizes)-291.1(no)-301.1(other)-291.1(class)-291.1(of)-301.1(meanings)-291.1(\(presuppositions,)-281(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-281(implicatures,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(intonational)-200.7(meanings,)-210.8(at-issue)-210.8(entailments\).)-281(The)-220.8(pressing)-210.8(question)-200.7(is)-220.8(whether)-210.8(\(1\))]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(picks)-240.9(out)-250.9(an)10(ything)-230.9(in)-250.9(natural)-250.9(language.)-311.2(The)-261(answer)-250.9(is)-250.9(a)-250.9(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 23.2827 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(niti)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(yes;)-250.9(Potts)-240.9(2005)]TJ -7.839 -3.202 TD (2)Tj ET endstream endobj 15 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 17 0 obj << /Length 7112 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(unco)10(v)10(ers)-281(a)-291.1(wide)-291.1(range)-301.1(of)-291.1(constructions)-271(that)-291.1(meet)-291.1(\(1\),)-301.1(and)-301.1(others)-281(are)-301.1(sure)-291.1(to)-291.1(turn)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(up)-240.9(in)-250.9(future)-250.9(in)40.2(v)10(estigations.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(The)-331.2(properties)-331.2(in)-321.2(\(1\))-331.2(come)-331.2(right)-321.2(to)-331.2(the)-331.2(fore)-331.2(when)-331.2(one)-331.2(studies)-321.2(the)-331.2(semantics)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(of)-381.4(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-361.4(e)10(xpressions,)-391.5(the)-381.4(f)10(actual)-391.5(basis)-371.4(for)-381.4(this)-381.4(paper)50.2(.)-702.6(I)-381.4(focus)-381.4(on)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 29.1697 0 TD (nominal)Tj -29.1697 -1.2045 TD (appositives)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.7806 0 TD [(\(N)30.1(As\))-301.1(lik)10(e)-301.1(those)-301.1(italicized)-291.1(in)-301.1(\(2\))-311.2(\(Barwise)-311.2(and)-301.1(Perry)-311.2(1983:156�158;)]TJ -4.7806 -1.2145 TD [(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-401.5(1998:�13e;)-471.8(Aoun)-401.5(and)-411.5(Choueiri)-401.5(2000;)-481.8(Aoun)-401.5(et)-411.5(al.)-411.5(2001;)-471.8(Elbourne)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(2001:268�269\).)-281(Potts)-240.9(2005)-240.9(e)10(xtends)-230.9(the)-240.9(analysis)-240.9(to)-240.9(a)-250.9(wider)-240.9(range)-250.9(of)-240.9(supplemental)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(e)10(xpressions.)]TJ 0 -1.7766 TD [(\(2\))-1897.1(a.)-1455.4(The)-341.3(agenc)10(y)-341.3(intervie)20.1(wed)-331.2(Chuck)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.9133 0 TD [(,)-371.4(a)-341.3(con)]TJ /TT9 1 Tf 2.9065 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD [(rmed)-331.2(psyc)10(hopath,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.5324 0 TD [(just)-331.2(after)]TJ -23.6428 -1.2145 TD [(his)-240.9(release)-261(from)-240.9(prison.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5357 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Y)100.4(e)20.1(wberry)-351.3(jelly)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.1515 0 TD [(,)-361.3(toxic)-341.3(in)-341.3(the)-351.3(e)20.1(xtr)40.1(eme)10(,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.3038 0 TD [(will)-341.3(gi)20.1(v)10(e)-331.2(you)-341.3(an)-351.3(a)10(wful)-341.3(stom-)]TJ -15.3072 -1.2045 TD (achache.)Tj -2.148 -1.5458 TD [(c.)-1455.4(Ed)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 3.2601 0 TD [(,)-250.9(i)0(n)-240.9(t)0(r)40.1(ouble)-230.9(with)-250.9(the)-250.9(law)-240.9(once)-250.9(a)10(gain,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 14.6283 0 TD [(has)-250.9(altered)-250.9(his)-240.9(identity)60.2(.)]TJ -20.9499 -1.7766 TD [(I)-271(refer)-281.1(to)-261(the)-271(intonationally-isolated)-230.9(phrase)-271(�)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 18.6841 0 TD [(a)-271(con)]TJ /TT9 1 Tf 2.2149 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD [(rmed)-261(psyc)10(hopath)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.1117 0 TD [(in)-271(\(2a\))-271(�)]TJ -28.5107 -1.2145 TD [(as)-291.1(the)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 2.6369 0 TD (appositive)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.1104 0 TD [(.)-411.5(The)-291.1(nominal)-281.1(that)-291.1(is)-281(obligatorily)-271(left-adjacent)-291.1(to)-281(the)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ -6.7472 -1.2045 TD [(is)-321.2(the)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 2.5411 0 TD [(anc)10(hor)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.823 0 TD [(.)-542(�Nominal)-321.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(�)-301.1(seems)-331.2(a)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 13.2103 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(tting)-321.2(label)-331.2(because)-331.2(the)-331.2(anchor)-331.2(in)]TJ -19.1305 -1.2145 TD [(this)-210.8(construction)-220.8(is)-220.8(al)10(w)10(ays)-220.8(a)-230.9(nominal)-210.8(with)-220.8(the)-230.9(semantics)-210.8(of)-230.9(a)-230.9(referring)-230.9(e)10(xpression.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(The)-230.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(tak)10(es)-230.9(the)-240.9(anchor�)50.2(s)-220.8(meaning)-230.9(as)-230.9(an)-240.9(ar)20.1(gument)-230.9(to)-230.9(return)-230.9(a)-240.9(proposition.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(The)-230.9(e)10(xamples)-220.8(in)-220.8(\(2\))-230.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(conjuncti)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(paraphrases;)-230.9(\(2a\))-240.9(e)10(xpresses)-220.8(the)-230.9(proposi-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(tion)-220.8(that)-230.9(Chuck)-240.9(is)-230.9(a)-230.9(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 9.375 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rmed)-240.9(psychopath)-220.8(and)-230.9(that)-230.9(the)-230.9(agenc)10(y)-230.9(intervie)20.1(wed)-230.9(Chuck)]TJ -9.9312 -1.2045 TD [(just)-200.8(after)-220.8(his)-210.8(release)-220.8(from)-210.8(prison.)-291.1(When)-210.8(N)30.1(A)0(s)-210.8(appear)-220.8(in)-210.8(embedded)-210.8(clauses,)-220.8(though,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(their)-240.9(distinctness)-230.9(from)-250.9(simple)-230.9(coordination)-240.9(is)-240.9(apparent:)]TJ 0 -1.7766 TD [(\(3\))-1897.1(a.)-1455.4(Sheila)-321.2(says)-311.2(that)-311.2(Chuck)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 14.4879 0 TD [(,)-341.3(a)-311.2(con)]TJ /TT9 1 Tf 2.8463 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD [(rmed)-311.2(psyc)10(hopath,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.4822 0 TD (is)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 0.9782 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-321.2(t)0(o)-311.2(w)10(atch)-321.2(the)]TJ -21.6413 -1.2145 TD (kids.)Tj -2.148 -1.5357 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Ali)-240.9(promises)-240.9(that)-240.9(ye)20.1(wberry)-250.9(jelly)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 15.0402 0 TD [(,)-240.9(toxic)-250.9(in)-240.9(the)-250.9(e)20.1(xtr)40.1(eme)10(,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.7718 0 TD [(is)-240.9(delicious.)]TJ -23.812 -1.5357 TD [(c.)-1455.4(The)-250.9(FBI)-271(reports)-240.9(that)-250.9(Ed)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 11.6611 0 TD [(,)-250.9(i)0(n)-240.9(t)0(r)40.2(ouble)-240.9(with)-250.9(the)-250.9(law)-250.9(once)-250.9(a)10(gain,)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 14.6484 0 TD (has)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.5839 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (ed)Tj -26.3016 -1.2145 TD [(to)-250.9(Florida.)]TJ -5.2095 -1.7766 TD [(W)80.3(e)-301.1(e)10(xpect)-281(indirect)-291.1(quotations)-281(�)-291.1(embedded,)-301.1(nonquotati)20.1(v)10(e)-261(clauses)-301.1(introduced)-281(by)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(v)10(erbs)-230.9(lik)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 4.1172 0 TD (say)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5739 0 TD [(�)-240.9(t)0(o)-240.9(b)0(e)-240.9(attrib)20.1(uted)-230.9(to)-240.9(the)-240.9(grammatical)-230.9(subject)-230.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(v)10(erb)-230.9(of)-250.9(saying.)]TJ -5.6911 -1.2045 TD [(Y)100.4(e)0(t)-341.3(i)0(f)-351.3(Sheila)-351.3(said)-341.3(merely)-341.3(�Chuck)-361.4(is)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.9918 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-351.3(t)0(o)-341.3(w)10(atch)-341.3(the)-351.3(kids�,)-361.3(we)-351.3(consider)-341.3(\(3a\))-361.3(an)]TJ -15.5479 -1.2145 TD [(accurate)-230.9(and)-230.9(complete)-210.8(report)-230.9(of)-220.8(this)-220.8(utterance.)-301.1(The)-220.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 24.7212 0 TD [(Chuc)20.1(k,)-240.9(a)-220.8(con)]TJ /TT9 1 Tf 5.1902 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (rmed)Tj -30.4114 -1.2045 TD [(psyc)10(hopath)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.7655 0 TD [(contrib)20.1(utes)-230.9(the)-240.9(proposition)-220.8(that)-230.9(Chuck)-240.9(is)-240.9(a)-240.9(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 18.5118 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rmed)-240.9(psychopath,)-230.9(b)20.1(u)0(t)]TJ -23.8334 -1.2045 TD [(\(3a\))-271(does)-271(not)-261(commit)-250.9(Sheila)-271(to)-271(this.)-361.4(\(3a\))-271(contrasts)-261(in)-271(this)-250.9(respect)-281.1(with)-261(\(4\),)-271(which)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(asserts)-321.2(that)-321.2(Sheila)-321.2(said)-321.2(roughly)-321.2(�Chuck)-331.2(is)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.3668 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-321.2(t)0(o)-321.2(w)10(atch)-331.2(the)-321.2(kids)-321.2(and)-321.2(a)-331.2(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 11.922 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (rmed)Tj -30.4012 -1.2045 TD (psychopath�.)Tj 15.9998 -2.4993 TD (3)Tj ET endstream endobj 18 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT9 19 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 21 0 obj << /Length 8548 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(\(4\))-1897.1(Sheila)-341.3(says)-331.2(that)-341.3(Chuck)-341.3(is)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 13.7484 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-341.3(t)0(o)-341.3(w)10(atch)-341.3(the)-331.2(kids)-341.3(and)-331.2(that)-341.3(Chuck)-341.3(is)-331.2(a)-351.3(con-)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf -11.2431 -1.2045 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rmed)-250.9(psychopath.)]TJ -3.6176 -2.0476 TD [(The)-331.2(contrast)-331.2(tak)10(es)-331.2(us)-331.2(back)-341.3(to)-331.2(the)-331.2(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.8138 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-331.2(in)-331.2(\(1\).)-562.1(In)-341.3(\(3a\),)-361.4(the)-331.2(proposition)-311.2(that)]TJ -15.3699 -1.2045 TD [(Chuck)-321.2(is)-321.2(a)-331.2(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.1392 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rmed)-321.2(psychopath)-321.2(is)-311.2(a)-331.2(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented)-321.2(contrib)20.1(ution;)-341.3(in)-321.2(\(4\),)-351.3(this)]TJ -6.6953 -1.2045 TD [(proposition)-250.9(is)-271(part)-271(of)-271(the)-281(indirect)-261(quotation,)-271(hence)-271(attrib)20.1(uted)-261(to)-271(Sheila.)-391.5(The)-271(links)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(with)-230.9(Grice�)50.2(s)-240.9(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.0861 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-230.9(of)-230.9(CIs)-250.9(do)-230.9(not)-240.9(end)-240.9(here;)-240.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-230.9(display)-230.9(the)-240.9(conjunction)-220.8(of)-240.9(the)]TJ -6.6423 -1.2045 TD [(properties)-240.9(in)-240.9(\(1\).)-301.1(Though)-240.9(Grice)-250.9(does)-240.9(not)-230.9(mention)-230.9(these)-250.9(e)10(xpressions)-220.8(as)-250.9(moti)20.1(v)20.1(ation)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(for)-250.9(CIs,)-250.9(his)-240.9(description)-240.9(picks)-240.9(them)-240.9(out)-240.9(unambiguously)60.2(.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Section)-321.2(3)-321.2(further)-331.2(supports)-311.2(the)-321.2(claim)-311.2(that)-321.2(\(1\))-321.2(is)-321.2(suitable)-311.2(for)-331.2(no)-321.2(other)-321.2(class)-321.2(of)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(meanings.)-552.1(Most)-331.2(of)-331.2(the)-331.2(e)10(xamples)-331.2(are)-341.3(dra)10(wn)-331.2(from)-331.2(the)-331.2(realm)-331.2(of)-341.3(N)30.1(As,)-341.3(so)-341.3(that)-321.2(we)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(arri)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(at)-250.9(a)-250.9(detailed)-240.9(picture)-250.9(of)-250.9(them)-240.9(as)-250.9(well.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Section)-271(4)-261(contains)-261(a)-271(multidimensional)-240.9(semantics)-250.9(for)-271(CIs.)-371.4(I)-271(locate)-271(the)-271(distinc-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(tion)-261(between)-281(at-issue)-261(and)-281(CI)-281(content)-271(in)-261(the)-281.1(meaning)-261(language,)-281.1(after)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 27.4641 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD [(rst)-271(heading)]TJ -28.0203 -1.2045 TD [(of)20.1(f)-220.8(a)-220.8(model-theoretic)-210.8(di)20.1(vision.)-271(Thus,)-220.8(CIs)-220.8(yield)-220.8(e)20.1(vidence)-210.8(that)-220.8(semantic)-210.8(translations)]TJ T* [(are)-321.2(a)-311.2(nondispensable)-291.1(part)-311.2(of)-311.2(semantic)-311.2(theory)60.2(.)-481.8(I)0(f)-311.2(w)0(e)-321.2(were)-311.2(to)-311.2(mo)10(v)10(e)-301.1(directly)-301.1(from)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(natural)-321.2(language)-331.2(e)10(xpressions)-311.2(to)-331.2(model-theoretic)-321.2(denotations,)-331.2(we)-331.2(w)10(ould)-321.2(lose)-331.2(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(important)-261(distinction)-250.9(between)-281(at-issue)-271(and)-271(CI)-281(content.)-391.5(The)-271(only)-271(remaining)-261(alter)20.1(-)]TJ T* [(nati)20.1(v)10(e)-341.3(w)10(ould)-351.3(be)-361.4(to)-351.3(locate)-361.4(the)-351.3(dif)20.1(ferences)-361.3(in)-351.3(the)-361.3(syntax,)-371.4(an)-361.4(approach)-361.4(I)-361.4(reject)-361.4(in)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(section)-321.2(2.)-542(On)-331.2(the)-321.2(type-theoretic)-321.2(conception)-321.2(adv)20.1(ocated)-331.2(here,)-351.3(the)-321.2(syntax)-321.2(remains)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(surf)10(ace-true)-250.9(and)-250.9(unremarkable,)-250.9(as)-250.9(e)10(x)10(empli)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 16.9932 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed)-230.9(in)-240.9(\(5\).)]TJ -17.5493 -2.2986 TD [(\(5\))-4776.2(DP)]TJ /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 189.48 335.34 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.4095 TD (
)Tj 0.7588 -0.3011 TD (
)Tj -2.7583 0.7107 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.4095 TD ()Tj -0.7588 -0.3011 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 154.44 309.9 Tm (DP)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 161.868 306.888 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 147.48 283.02 Tm (Lance)Tj /F3 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 188.64 326.7 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.7265 -0.793 TD (NP)Tj 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 197.16 302.7 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj /F3 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 239.04 326.7 Tm 0 Tc ()Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 216.96 291.78 Tm ()Tj 0.8431 -0.5541 TD ()Tj -1.8429 0.5541 TD ()Tj -0.8431 -0.5541 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 194.28 275.46 Tm (D)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 202.92 279.9 Tm (0)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 198.348 272.568 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 195.96 248.58 Tm (a)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 227.76 275.46 Tm (NP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 235.32 264.54 Tm ()Tj 0.5661 -0.4457 TD ()Tj -1.5658 0.4457 TD ()Tj -0.5541 -0.4457 TD ()Tj ET q 31.08 0 0 -0.48 219.828 260.448 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 219.84 248.58 Tm [(c)10(yclist)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 369.72 342.3 Tm (lance)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.4425 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 410.16 346.62 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 389.4 327.78 Tm (�)Tj /TT4 1 Tf -5.2295 -1.2045 TD (comma)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.1099 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6555 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (lance)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2217 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6022 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4786 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 453.6 317.7 Tm (c)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 392.4 306.54 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.7468 -0.1927 TD ()Tj -4.7457 0.9395 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.7347 -0.1927 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 322.44 283.14 Tm (lance)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.4525 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 363 287.46 Tm (a)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 379.92 283.14 Tm (comma)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.1099 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6555 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 476.88 287.46 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 481.8 283.14 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 490.44 287.46 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 494.76 283.14 Tm ()Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 439.428 277.128 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 402.84 251.22 Tm (cyclist)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.8864 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 453.36 255.54 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 458.28 251.22 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 466.92 255.54 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 471.84 251.22 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -30.1928 -2.148 TD [(I)-281.1(represent)-281.1(natural)-271(language)-271(objects)-271(as)-281(pairs)-281.1(�)-271(a)-281(syntactic)-271(structure)-271(\(represented)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(graphically)-271(on)-271(the)-271(left\))-281.1(and)-271(a)-281(semantic)-271(parsetree)-281(\(on)-281.1(the)-271(right\).)-381.4(Since)-281(the)-281.1(b)20.1(ulk)-271(of)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-190.7(formal)-190.7(reconstruction)-180.7(of)-190.7(the)-190.7(at-issue/CI)-190.7(di)20.1(vide)-180.7(rests)-190.7(on)-190.7(the)-190.7(nature)-190.7(of)-200.7(the)-190.7(types,)-190.7(I)]TJ T* [(al)10(w)10(ays)-230.9(pro)10(vide)-230.9(e)10(xplicit)-230.9(typing)-220.8(information)-230.9(in)-230.9(the)-240.9(semantic)-230.9(parsetrees.)-311.2(The)-240.9(phrase)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 0 -1.2145 TD (lance)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.4827 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5288 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 152.16 172.02 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 161.04 167.7 Tm [(glosses)-301.1(as)-311.2(�the)-321.2(term)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 8.354 0 TD (lance)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.5429 0 TD [(is)-311.2(of)-311.2(the)-311.2(at-issue-entity)-301.1(type�,)-331.2(for)-321.2(e)10(xample.)]TJ -15.0926 -1.2045 TD [(Section)-210.8(4)-200.8(pro)10(vides)-200.7(a)-210.8(method)-200.8(for)-210.8(determining)-190.7(parsetrees)-220.8(with)-200.7(the)-200.8(desired)-210.8(shape)-210.8(and)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ensuring)-301.1(that)-301.1(the)-311.2(abo)10(v)10(e)-301.1(is)-301.1(interpreted)-311.2(as)-311.2(denoting)-291.1(both)-301.1(the)-311.2(indi)20.1(vidual)-281(Lance)-321.2(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-240.9(proposition)-230.9(that)-250.9(Lance)-250.9(is)-240.9(a)-250.9(c)10(yclist.)]TJ 15.9998 -2.8908 TD (4)Tj ET endstream endobj 22 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F3 24 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 28 0 obj << /Length 7242 >> stream BT /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(2)-996.8(A)0(n)-244(integrated)-237(syntax)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 627.42 Tm [(In)-271(\(5\),)-281(the)-271(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(is)-271(right-adjoined)-250.9(to)-271(the)-271(anchor)40.2(,)-281(s)0(o)-271(that)-271(the)-271(N)30.1(A)-261(forms)-271(a)-281(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(stituent.)-361.4(This)-261(places)-271(the)-271(b)20.1(urden)-271(of)-271(achie)20.1(ving)-261(speak)10(er)20.1(-orientation)-261(\(primary)-271(scope\))]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(on)-291.1(the)-301.1(semantics.)-461.7(T)80.3(o)-291.1(readers)-311.2(f)10(amiliar)-301.1(with)-291.1(the)-301.1(literature)-291.1(on)-301.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(es,)-291.1(it)-291.1(might)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(seem)-331.2(preferable)-351.3(to)-341.3(attach)-341.3(the)-331.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-321.2(to)-331.2(the)-341.3(root)-341.3(node,)-351.3(rather)-351.3(than)-331.2(to)-341.3(an)-341.3(em-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(bedded)-240.9(constituent.)-291.1(V)110.4(ersions)-240.9(of)-250.9(this)-240.9(analysis)-240.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(been)-250.9(of)20.1(fered)-250.9(man)10(y)-240.9(times)-240.9(in)-240.9(the)]TJ T* [(past,)-250.9(by)-250.9(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-250.9(\(1982,)-240.9(1987,)-250.9(1989,)-250.9(1998\),)-240.9(Emonds)-250.9(\(1976,)-240.9(1979\),)-250.9(Huddleston)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(and)-331.2(Pullum)-331.2(\(2002\),)-351.3(and)-341.3(Culico)10(v)10(e)0(r)-321.2(\(1992\).)-572.1(F)10(o)0(r)-331.2(the)-341.3(most)-321.2(part,)-361.4(the)10(y)-331.2(con)40.2(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(g)0(e)-331.2(o)0(n)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(surf)10(ace)-341.3(structures)-341.3(such)-331.2(as)-341.3(the)-341.3(one)-331.2(in)-341.3(\(6\).)-582.2(F)10(o)0(r)-341.3(the)-331.2(purposes)-331.2(of)-341.3(this)-331.2(discussion,)-341.3(I)]TJ T* [(assume)-271(that)-281.1(the)-281.1(dashed)-281(lines)-271(represent)-291.1(a)-281.1(designated)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 20.9537 0 TD [(supplement)-271(r)40.1(elation)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.9521 0 TD [(,)-281(disjoint)]TJ -28.9058 -1.2145 TD [(from)-240.9(dominance)-240.9(and)-250.9(precedence.)]TJ 0 -1.8168 TD [(\(6\))-1897.1(a.)-1455.4(The)-271(of)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 7.851 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cer)-281.1(arrested)-271(Clyde,)-271(the)-271(subject)-261(of)-271(a)-271(long)-261(manhunt,)-261(before)-281(he)]TJ -3.1977 -1.2045 TD [(could)-250.9(strik)10(e)-240.9(again.)]TJ -2.148 -2.7603 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj 11.0111 -2.419 TD 0 Tc (S)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 282.48 394.74 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.3252 -0.0602 TD ( )Tj -8.3231 1.2286 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.3373 -0.0602 TD (\012)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 191.76 371.58 Tm (DP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 199.44 364.62 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.6384 -0.2529 TD (
)Tj -2.6379 0.6504 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.6384 -0.2529 TD ()Tj ET q 52.56 0 0 -0.48 173.148 358.368 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.16 346.62 Tm [(The)-250.9(of)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 2.6186 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (cer)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 357.84 371.58 Tm (VP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 365.4 366.9 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 1.0118 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9636 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj -5.9743 0.8311 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9636 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 298.44 347.7 Tm (VP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 306 341.34 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj 0.1686 -0.0602 TD ()Tj -3.1678 0.7227 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj -0.1686 -0.0602 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 270.12 323.7 Tm (V)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 278.76 328.14 Tm (0)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -10.08 274.308 320.808 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 255.6 298.86 Tm (arrested)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 329.88 323.7 Tm (DP)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -10.08 337.308 320.808 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 323.28 298.86 Tm (Clyde)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 418.2 347.7 Tm (PP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 424.92 342.18 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj 0.3252 -0.0843 TD ()Tj -4.3242 0.8311 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj -0.3373 -0.0843 TD ()Tj ET q 86.4 0 0 -0.48 381.708 334.1281 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 387.72 322.74 Tm [(before)-250.9(he)-250.9(could)]TJ 0.9941 -1.2045 TD [(strik)10(e)-250.9(again)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 362.52 282.9 Tm (DP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 370.08 277.38 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.3373 -0.0843 TD ()Tj -4.3362 0.8311 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.3373 -0.0843 TD ()Tj ET q 86.4 0 0 -0.48 326.868 269.328 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 337.92 256.02 Tm [(the)-250.9(subject)-240.9(of)]TJ -0.2187 -1.2145 TD [(a)-250.9(long)-240.9(manhunt)]TJ ET 0 G 0 J 0 j 0.3 w 10 M [3.996 ]0 d 1 i 282.453 409.474 m 341.52 426.222 l 341.52 426.222 m 370.18 292.906 l S BT 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 220.86 Tm [(T)80.3(o)-281.1(ensure)-281(that)-281(the)-281.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-271(is)-271(al)10(w)10(ays)-291.1(gi)20.1(v)10(e)0(n)-261(semantically)-271(widest)-281(scope,)-291.1(one)-281(can)]TJ T* [(stipulate)-291.1(that)-301.1(e)20.1(v)10(ery)-301.1(ordered)-311.2(pair)-301.1(of)-311.2(nodes)-301.1(in)-301.1(the)-301.1(supplement)-291.1(relation)-301.1(is)-301.1(such)-301.1(that)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD (its)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.1857 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst)-261(member)-250.9(is)-240.9(the)-250.9(root.)-321.2(Alternati)20.1(v)10(ely)60.2(,)-230.9(the)-250.9(structures)-250.9(could)-240.9(in)40.1(v)20.1(olv)10(e)-240.9(only)-250.9(domi-)]TJ -1.7419 -1.2145 TD [(nance)-271(and)-281(precedence,)-291.1(with)-261(the)-271(relationship)-261(between)-271(them)-271(relax)10(ed)-271(so)-271(as)-271(to)-271(allo)20.1(w)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (manhunt)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.7911 0 TD [(to)-281(precede)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 4.4584 0 TD [(befor)40.1(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.7956 0 TD [(in)-281(\(6\))-291.1(\(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-271(1982;)-291.1(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-281(1998:40\).)-401.5(Either)]TJ -11.045 -1.2045 TD [(w)10(a)0(y)60.2(,)-240.9(adjustments)-230.9(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(usual)-240.9(axioms)-240.9(for)-250.9(trees)-250.9(must)-240.9(be)-250.9(made)-240.9(\(Potts,)-250.9(2005\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Is)-341.3(this)-321.2(an)-341.3(adequate)-341.3(basis)-331.2(for)-331.2(a)-341.3(theory)-331.2(of)-341.3(appositi)20.1(v)10(es?)-552.1(I)-341.3(feel)-341.3(that)-331.2(we)-331.2(can)-341.3(an-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD (swer)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 2.1993 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rmly)-311.2(in)-301.1(the)-311.2(ne)10(gati)20.1(v)10(e)0(.)-471.8(The)-311.2(syntactic)-301.1(e)20.1(vidence)-311.2(points)-301.1(unambiguously)-281(to)-311.2(an)]TJ 13.2443 -2.4993 TD (5)Tj ET endstream endobj 29 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F2 23 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 31 0 obj << /Length 6393 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(inte)10(grated)-311.2(syntax)-311.2(lik)10(e)-311.2(that)-311.2(of)-321.2(\(5\).)-521.9(F)10(o)0(r)-321.2(instance,)-331.2(N)30.1(As,)-321.2(lik)10(e)-311.2(man)10(y)-311.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(es,)-311.2(are)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(subject)-240.9(to)-240.9(a)-250.9(strict)-250.9(adjacenc)10(y)-240.9(requirement:)]TJ 0 -2.0476 TD [(\(7\))-1897.1(a.)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 619.6201 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 615.3 Tm [(W)80.3(e)-301.1(spok)10(e)-291.1(with)-291.1(Lance)-301.1(before)-301.1(the)-301.1(race,)-311.2(the)-301.1(f)10(amous)-291.1(c)10(yclist,)-291.1(about)-291.1(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(weather)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 585.78 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 581.46 Tm [(Jan)-291.1(w)10(a)0(s)-291.1(the)-291.1(f)10(astest)-291.1(on)-291.1(the)-291.1(course,)-301.1(the)-291.1(f)10(amous)-291.1(German)-291.1(sprinter)40.1(,)-301.1(yes-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(terday)60.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD (c.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 551.9401 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 547.6201 Tm [(Lance)-261(has,)-240.9(the)-250.9(f)10(amous)-240.9(c)10(yclist,)-230.9(tak)10(en)-250.9(the)-250.9(lead.)]TJ -5.2095 -2.0477 TD [(The)-351.3(structure)-351.3(in)-351.3(\(5\),)-371.4(which)-351.3(right-adjoins)-341.3(the)-351.3(N)30.1(A)-341.3(to)-351.3(its)-341.3(anchor)40.1(,)-381.4(pro)10(vides)-341.3(an)-351.3(im-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(mediate)-271(account)-271(of)-281(this)-271(when)-271(considered)-281(in)-271(the)-271(conte)10(xt)-271(of)-281(the)-271(logic)-271(de)20.1(v)10(eloped)-261(in)]TJ T* [(section)-301.1(4.)-471.8(Roughly)-301.1(speaking,)-311.2(mo)10(v)10(ement)-291.1(of)-301.1(a)-311.2(C)0(I)-311.2(phrase)-311.2(w)10(ould)-301.1(require)-301.1(a)-311.2(lambda)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(term)-250.9(that)-261(tak)10(es)-261(CI)-261(meanings)-250.9(to)-261(CI)-271(meanings.)-331.2(The)-261(logic)-250.9(lacks)-261(such)-250.9(terms,)-261(though,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(rendering)-240.9(e)10(xtraposition)-230.9(structures)-240.9(lik)10(e)-250.9(\(7\))-250.9(uninterpretable.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Strictly)-271(left-adjoining)-261(languages)-281(lik)10(e)-271(T)40.1(urkish)-261(pro)10(vide)-271(an)-281.1(indirect)-271(ar)20.1(gument)-271(in)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(f)10(a)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)-341.3(o)0(f)-341.3(right-adjunction)-311.2(of)-341.3(N)30.1(As.)-562.1(It)-341.3(seems)-331.2(that)-341.3(T)40.1(urkish)-321.2(lacks)-331.2(N)30.1(A)0(s)-331.2(i)0(n)-331.2(the)-341.3(sense)]TJ T* [(that)-261(those)-261(are)-271(construed)-261(here.)-361.4(The)-261(closest)-261(the)-261(language)-271(comes)-261(is)-261(\(8\),)-271(which)-261(more)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(closely)-250.9(resembles)-240.9(the)-261(English)-240.9(construction)-240.9(represented)-250.9(by)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 23.4067 0 TD [(the)-250.9(cyclist)-250.9(Lance)-261(Arm-)]TJ -23.4067 -1.2045 TD [(str)40.2(ong)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.516 0 TD [(.)-291.1(\(My)-240.9(thanks)-240.9(to)-250.9(Jor)20.1(ge)-250.9(Hankamer)-240.9(for)-250.9(data)-250.9(and)-250.9(discussion.\))]TJ -2.516 -2.0476 TD [(\(8\))-1897.1(Un-lU)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 3.0614 -1.2045 TD (fame-ous)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.9146 1.2045 TD (bisiklet-Ci)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (bicycle-ist)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.4667 1.2045 TD (Hasan-la)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (Hasan-with)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.9184 1.2045 TD (yarIS-tan)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD [(r)10(ace)10(.)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 330.7114 354.3 Tm 0.0502 Tc (ABL)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 354.24 368.7 Tm 0 Tc (Once)Tj /TT8 1 Tf T* [(befor)40.1(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.7704 1.2045 TD [(k)10(onuS-tu-k.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (speak.)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 417.809 354.3 Tm 0.0502 Tc [(P)87.8(AST)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 442.0363 354.3 Tm 0 Tc (-we)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -24.6384 -1.1242 TD [(�W)80.3(e)-250.9(spok)10(e)-240.9(with)-240.9(the)-250.9(f)10(amous)-240.9(bic)10(yclist)-230.9(Hasan)-250.9(before)-261(the)-240.9(race.)70.3(�)]TJ -3.0614 -2.0476 TD [(T)40.2(urkish)-210.8(seems)-230.9(not)-230.9(to)-220.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(syntactically)60.2(,)-220.8(morphologically)60.2(,)-200.8(o)0(r)-230.9(intonationally)-210.8(distin-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(guished)-321.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-311.2(relati)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-321.2(either)50.2(.)-572.1(Both)-331.2(gaps)-321.2(are)-351.3(e)10(xpected)-331.2(on)-331.2(the)-331.2(present)-331.2(vie)20.1(w)]TJ T* [(\(and)-271(that)-271(of)-271(Potts)-271(2002a\):)-351.3(if)-271(N)30.1(A)0(s)-271(and)-271(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(relati)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-250.9(i)0(n)40.1(v)20.1(ariably)-261(right-adjoin,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(then)-200.8(a)-200.8(language)-200.7(that)-200.8(forbids)-200.8(right-adjunction)-180.7(cannot)-200.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-200.8(them.)-281(On)-200.8(the)-200.8(vie)20.1(w)-200.7(based)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(on)-240.9(the)-250.9(supplement)-230.9(relation,)-240.9(the)-250.9(gaps)-240.9(seem)-250.9(accidental.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Perhaps)-281(the)-281(strongest)-271(e)20.1(vidence)-271(for)-281(an)-281(inte)10(grated)-271(N)30.1(A)-271(syntax)-271(comes)-281.1(from)-271(Ger)20.1(-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(man,)-210.8(which)-210.8(displays)-200.7(a)-220.8(case-matching)-200.8(requirement)-210.8(between)-220.8(anchor)-210.8(and)-210.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(.)]TJ T* [(Though)-230.9(e)10(xceptions)-220.8(are)-250.9(found,)-230.9(the)-240.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(generally)-240.9(shares)-240.9(the)-240.9(case)-240.9(assigned)-230.9(to)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-240.9(anchor)-250.9(by)-250.9(the)-250.9(predicate)-250.9(\(Durrell)-240.9(1995:�2.6\):)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(9\))-1897.1(Ich)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 3.0614 -1.2145 TD (I)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5257 1.2145 TD (sah)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2145 TD (saw)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.8067 1.2145 TD (meinen)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2145 TD [(my)50.2(.)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 203.8887 161.94 Tm 0.0125 Tc [(AC)-37.7(C)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 227.64 176.46 Tm 0 Tc (Freund,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf T* (friend,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.3325 1.2145 TD (den)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)10(.)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 285.1942 161.94 Tm 0.0125 Tc [(AC)-37.7(C)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 308.88 176.46 Tm 0 Tc [(Pf)10(arrer)50.2(.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf T* [(par)10(son)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf -13.5004 -1.1242 TD [(�I)-250.9(sa)10(w)-240.9(m)0(y)-240.9(friend,)-250.9(the)-250.9(parson.)70.3(�)-10579.5(\(Durrell)-250.9(1995:37\))]TJ 12.9383 -4.9083 TD (6)Tj ET endstream endobj 32 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 34 0 obj << /Length 6925 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(If)-411.5(we)-421.6(assume)-401.5(structures)-411.5(lik)10(e)-401.5(the)-411.5(one)-411.5(in)-411.5(\(5\),)-451.7(then)-411.5(it)-411.5(is)-401.5(easy)-411.5(to)-411.5(state)-411.5(this)-401.5(case-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(matching)-331.2(requirement)-331.2(as)-341.3(sharing)-341.3(of)-341.3(features)-341.3(between)-341.3(the)-341.3(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-321.2(and)-341.3(its)-331.2(sis-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ter:)-331.2(if)-261(an)-261(NP)-261(with)-261(the)-261(feature)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 252.6395 625.26 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 295.6006 625.26 Tm 0 Tc [(is)-261(adjoined)-250.9(to)-250.9(a)-271(DP,)-261(then)-261(the)-261(case-marking)]TJ -15.4511 -1.2045 TD [(features)-250.9(of)-250.9(DP)-250.9(appear)-261(on)-240.9(NP.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(When)-271(one)-261(studies)-261(other)-261(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(and)-271(parenthetical)-261(e)10(xpressions,)-250.9(the)-261(case)-271(for)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(an)-331.2(inte)10(grated)-321.2(syntax)-321.2(gro)20.1(ws)-321.2(stronger)-331.2(\(Potts,)-321.2(2002a,b,)-321.2(2005\).)-552.1(It)-331.2(quickly)-321.2(becomes)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(clear)-220.8(that)-220.8(scope)-220.8(f)10(acts)-220.8(pro)10(vide)-210.8(the)-220.8(only)-210.8(e)20.1(vidence)-220.8(for)-220.8(root-le)20.1(v)10(e)0(l)-200.8(adjunction.)-291.1(Because)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(we)-250.9(can)-240.9(achie)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(the)-250.9(requisite)-230.9(widest)-240.9(scoping)-230.9(without)-230.9(complicating)-230.9(the)-250.9(natural)-240.9(lan-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(guage)-291.1(syntax)-291.1(or)-301.1(compromising)-271(our)-301.1(ability)-281(to)-291.1(state)-291.1(the)-301.1(necessary)-301.1(generalizations,)]TJ T* [(root-le)20.1(v)10(e)0(l)-230.9(adjunction)-240.9(seems)-240.9(an)-250.9(unneeded)-250.9(complication.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(It)-321.2(is)-321.2(w)10(orth)-311.2(pointing)-301.1(out)-321.2(also)-311.2(that)-321.2(structures)-311.2(lik)10(e)-321.2(\(6\))-321.2(implicitly)-301.1(call)-321.2(upon)-311.2(ne)20.1(w)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(semantic)-301.1(composition)-281(rules.)-481.8(W)80.3(e)-321.2(require)-311.2(a)-311.2(principle)-301.1(that)-301.1(places)-311.2(on)-301.1(the)-311.2(root)-301.1(node)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-321.2(result)-321.2(of)-321.2(applying)-311.2(the)-331.2(supplement-adjoined)-301.1(e)10(xpression)-311.2(to)-321.2(a)-321.2(phrase)-331.2(to)-321.2(its)-311.2(im-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(mediate)-291.1(left.)-471.8(The)-301.1(condition)-291.1(is)-301.1(of)-301.1(course)-301.1(within)-291.1(reach)-311.2(\(Potts,)-301.1(2005\),)-311.2(b)20.1(u)0(t)-291.1(i)0(t)-301.1(sho)20.1(ws)]TJ T* [(that)-261(we)-271(shouldn�)20.1(t)-250.9(f)10(a)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)-271(a)0(n)-271(analysis)-261(lik)10(e)-261(\(6\))-271(o)10(v)10(e)0(r)-261(the)-271(description)-250.9(of)20.1(fered)-271(belo)20.1(w)-261(o)0(n)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-301.1(assumption)-291.1(that)-301.1(\(6\))-311.2(permits)-301.1(us)-301.1(to)-301.1(do)-311.2(without)-291.1(ne)20.1(w)-301.1(semantic)-301.1(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 26.6214 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD [(nitions.)-481.8(This)]TJ -27.1776 -1.2045 TD [(assumption)-230.9(is)-240.9(f)10(alse.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 382.26 Tm [(3)-996.8(CIs)-244(vs.)-244(other)-244(meanings)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 355.5 Tm [(At)-311.2(this)-311.2(stage)-311.2(in)-311.2(the)-311.2(history)-311.2(of)-311.2(CIs,)-341.3(it)-311.2(w)10(ould)-311.2(be)-311.2(unwise)-311.2(of)-321.2(me)-311.2(to)-311.2(presuppose)-311.2(that)]TJ T* [(Grice�)50.2(s)-271(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.1075 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition,)-271(\(1\),)-271(deserv)10(es)-271(a)-281(place)-271(in)-271(linguistic)-250.9(theory)60.2(.)-371.4(The)-271(e)10(xistence)-271(of)-271(CIs)]TJ -4.6637 -1.2145 TD [(has)-190.7(been)-200.8(denied)-190.7(e)10(xplicitly)-170.6(\(Bach,)-200.8(1999\))-190.7(as)-200.8(well)-190.7(as)-190.7(implicitly)60.2(,)-180.7(i)0(n)-190.7(the)-190.7(use)-200.8(of)-190.7(�con)40.1(v)10(en-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(tional)-250.9(implicature�)-250.9(as)-261(a)-271(synon)10(ym)-240.9(for)-261(�presupposition�)-240.9(\(Cooper)-271(1983;)-250.9(Heim)-261(1983;)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-361.3(1997,)-341.3(2001;)-341.3(Krahmer)-351.3(1998;)-341.3(Dekk)10(er)-361.4(2002;)-391.5(Gamut)-341.3(1991:188\).)-612.3(Krahmer)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(\(1998:143\))-321.2(e)20.1(v)10(en)-321.2(goes)-321.2(so)-331.2(f)10(a)0(r)-341.3(a)0(s)-331.2(t)0(o)-321.2(say)-331.2(that)-321.2(�In)-341.3(this)-321.2(system,)-331.2([)]TJ 24.584 0 TD 0.1506 Tc [(...])-411.5(t)150.6(h)150.6(e)]TJ 3.6397 0 TD 0 Tc [(choice)-331.2(be-)]TJ -28.2237 -1.2045 TD (tween)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 2.6888 0 TD [(pr)40.1(esuppositions)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 6.5849 0 TD (and)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.745 0 TD [(con)40.1(ventional)-301.1(implicatur)40.2(es)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 10.6765 0 TD [(is)-301.1(just)-301.1(a)-311.2(matter)-301.1(of)-311.2(names�.)]TJ -21.6952 -1.2145 TD [(The)-331.2(statement)-311.2(is)-321.2(meant)-331.2(to)-321.2(con)40.1(v)10(e)10(y)-321.2(only)-321.2(that)-321.2(one)-331.2(can)-331.2(mo)10(v)10(e)-311.2(f)10(airly)-331.2(freely)-331.2(between)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(certain)-301.1(three-)-311.2(and)-301.1(four)20.1(-v)20.1(alued)-291.1(logics,)-301.1(a)-311.2(mathematical)-291.1(f)10(act)-301.1(that)-301.1(can)-301.1(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-301.1(no)-301.1(bear)20.1(-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ing)-250.9(on)-250.9(the)-250.9(question)-240.9(of)-261(whether)-250.9(presuppositions)-230.9(and)-250.9(con)40.1(v)10(entional)-240.9(implicatures)-240.9(are)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(distinguished)-250.9(in)-281(natural)-271(language.)-401.5(But)-281(its)-271(rhetorical)-281(ef)20.1(fect)-281.1(is)-281(to)-271(cast)-281(doubt)-271(on)-281.1(the)]TJ T* [(usefulness)-261(of)-281.1(separating)-261(the)-271(tw)10(o)-271(concepts.)-381.4(Thus,)-271(this)-261(section)-271(pursues)-271(tw)10(o)-271(related)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(goals:)-291.1(I)-230.9(seek)-230.9(to)-230.9(b)20.1(uild)-220.8(a)-230.9(case)-230.9(that)-230.9(\(1\))-230.9(is)-230.9(not)-220.8(merely)-230.9(a)-230.9(n)0(e)20.1(w)60.2(,)-230.9(perhaps)-230.9(partial,)-220.8(encoding)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(of)-250.9(a)-250.9(more)-240.9(accepted)-250.9(kind)-240.9(of)-250.9(meaning,)-240.9(and)-240.9(I)-250.9(seek)-250.9(to)-240.9(establish)-240.9(that)-240.9(it)-240.9(picks)-240.9(out)-240.9(some)]TJ T* [(natural)-240.9(language)-250.9(f)10(acts.)-311.2(I)-250.9(use)-250.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-240.9(t)0(o)-240.9(pursue)-250.9(the)-240.9(second)-250.9(end.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(The)-321.2(tree)-311.2(in)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.7846 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(gure)-321.2(1)-311.2(summarizes)-301.1(the)-321.2(vie)20.1(w)-301.1(o)0(f)-321.2(meanings)-301.1(described)-321.2(in)-311.2(this)-301.1(sec-)]TJ -6.8062 -1.2045 TD [(tion.)-281(The)-190.7(only)-190.7(entailments)-170.6(�)-200.8(non-ne)10(gotiable)-170.6(meanings)-180.7(�)-190.7(are)-200.8(at-issue)-190.7(entailments)]TJ 15.9998 -2.8908 TD (7)Tj ET endstream endobj 35 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 37 0 obj << /Length 3629 >> stream BT /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 355.92 655.98 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)]TJ 0.4216 -1.2045 TD [(implicatur)20.1(es)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 0.4417 -1.2045 TD [(not)-250.9(le)10(xical,)]TJ -1.9874 -1.2145 TD [(not)-240.9(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented,)]TJ 0.6123 -1.2045 TD [(not)-240.9(backgrounded)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf -11.7338 -2.2082 TD (nonentailments)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5759 -1.2145 TD (deniable)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 10.2684 1.2145 TD [(pr)20.1(esuppositions)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 1.9071 -1.2145 TD [(le)10(xical,)]TJ -2.7603 -1.2045 TD [(not)-250.9(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented,)]TJ 1.3751 -1.2045 TD (backgrounded)Tj /TT4 1 Tf -19.6233 -1.877 TD (meanings)Tj 8.1806 -2.2082 TD (entailments)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -0.1104 -1.2045 TD [(not)-250.9(deniable,)]TJ 1.1342 -1.2145 TD [(le)10(xical,)]TJ -2.148 -1.2045 TD [(not)-250.9(backgrounded)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.6548 3.6235 TD (CIs)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -1.2447 -1.2045 TD [(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariably)]TJ -1.4454 -1.2145 TD [(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented,)]TJ 0.4316 -1.2045 TD [(in)40.2(v)20.1(ariant)-230.9(under)]TJ 0.6223 -1.2145 TD [(holes,)-240.9(plugs)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 0.8933 -2.2083 TD (at-issue)Tj -0.8532 -1.2045 TD (entailments)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -0.2911 -1.2045 TD [(not)-240.9(in)40.2(v)20.1(ariably)]TJ -0.6826 -1.2145 TD [(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented,)]TJ 1.3049 -1.2045 TD [(v)20.1(ary)-240.9(under)]TJ -0.2509 -1.2145 TD [(holes,)-240.9(plugs)]TJ ET 0 G 0 J 0 j 0.3 w 10 M []0 d 1 i 173.382 509.01 m 207.522 569.694 l 173.382 509.01 m 218.562 489.958 l 290.113 575.906 m 353.922 660.026 l 290.113 575.906 m 349.122 574.77 l 281.828 483.746 m 371.442 399.506 l 281.828 483.78 m 380.322 483.78 l S BT 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 236.16 299.82 Tm [(Figure)-250.9(1:)-321.2(A)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 295.7458 299.82 Tm 0.0502 Tc [(MEANING)-363.8(TREE)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 265.38 Tm 0 Tc [(and)-291.1(CIs.)-431.6(Thus,)-301.1(when)-291.1(proposing)-271(that)-291.1(a)-291.1(certain)-291.1(construction)-281.1(manifests)-281(CI)-291.1(content,)]TJ T* [(the)-281.1(most)-271(threatening)-271(alternati)20.1(v)10(e)-271(appears)-281(to)-281(be)-281(an)-291.1(at-issue)-271(classi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 25.3491 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cation.)-401.5(The)-281(pre-)]TJ -25.9053 -1.2045 TD [(suppositional)-281(vie)20.1(wpoint,)-311.2(too,)-321.2(can)-311.2(be)-311.2(trick)10(y)-301.1(t)0(o)-311.2(dispel,)-311.2(since)-311.2(the)-311.2(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 26.463 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-301.1(of)-311.2(pre-)]TJ -27.0192 -1.2045 TD [(supposition)-250.9(is)-271(not)-271(a)-281(settled)-271(matter)40.1(,)-281.1(and)-271(man)10(y)-271(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-271(used)-281(the)-271(term)-271(interchangeably)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(with)-240.9(�con)40.1(v)10(entional)-240.9(implicature�.)-311.2(The)-250.9(ne)10(xt)-240.9(fe)20.1(w)-250.9(subsections)-240.9(seek)-250.9(to)-250.9(sho)20.1(w)-240.9(that)-250.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(pro)10(vide)-240.9(solid)-230.9(e)20.1(vidence)-250.9(for)-250.9(the)-240.9(linguistic)-230.9(reality)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(CI)-261(branch.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 157.74 Tm [(3.1)-995.4(CIs)-242.6(vs.)-242.6(con)41.8(v)8.4(ersational)-250.9(implicatur)16.7(es)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 135.18 Tm [(Grice)-220.8(seems)-210.8(to)-210.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(intended)-200.7(\(1\))-220.8(to)-210.8(be)-210.8(ob)10(viously)-190.7(disjoint)-200.8(from)-210.8(the)-210.8(class)-210.8(of)-220.8(con)40.1(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(-)]TJ T* [(sational)-250.9(implicatures.)-321.2(Clauses)-250.9(\(1b\))-261(and)-261(\(1c\))-261(achie)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(this)-250.9(split:)-311.2(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-240.9(im-)]TJ 15.9998 -2.5897 TD (8)Tj ET endstream endobj 38 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 40 0 obj << /Length 6742 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(plicatures)-250.9(are)-271(not)-250.9(entailments)-240.9(at)-261(all,)-261(as)-261(e)20.1(videnced)-261(by)-250.9(their)-261(absence)-261(in)-261(certain)-261(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(te)10(xts,)-271(and)-271(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-261(implicatures)-261(are)-281(not)-271(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariably)-261(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented)-281.1(\(Chier)20.1(-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(chia,)-250.9(2004\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(At)-371.4(the)-371.4(heart)-371.4(of)-371.4(the)-371.4(dif)20.1(ference)-371.4(between)-371.4(the)-371.4(tw)10(o)-361.3(classes)-371.4(of)-371.4(�implicature�)-361.3(lies)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(the)-311.2(notion)-301.1(of)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 5.5338 0 TD (deniability)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.2769 0 TD [(.)-481.8(The)-311.2(question,)-321.2(�Is)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.9941 0 TD (p)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.8212 0 TD [(deniable)-311.2(in)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 4.7271 0 TD (C)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6971 0 TD [(?�)-511.9(should)-301.1(be)-311.2(read)-321.2(as)]TJ -24.0502 -1.2145 TD [(a)-341.3(shorthand)-341.3(for)-341.3(the)-341.3(question,)-351.3(�Is)-351.3(it)-331.2(possible)-331.2(that)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.944 0 TD (p)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.8513 0 TD [(is)-341.3(a)-341.3(potential,)-351.3(b)20.1(u)0(t)-341.3(not)-341.3(an)-341.3(ac-)]TJ -20.7953 -1.2045 TD [(tual,)-250.9(contrib)20.1(ution)-240.9(to)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.0981 0 TD (C)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6971 0 TD [(?�)-331.2(Nonentailments)-240.9(are)-271(deniable:)-321.2(it)-250.9(is)-250.9(often)-261(the)-250.9(case)-271(that)-250.9(the)]TJ -8.7952 -1.2145 TD [(conte)10(xt)-271(conspires)-271(to)-281(alter)-281(or)-281(eliminate)-271(a)-291.1(potential)-261(nonentailment.)-391.5(In)-281.1(contrast,)-281.1(en-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(tailments)-240.9(are)-261(not)-250.9(deniable;)-250.9(there)-261(is)-250.9(no)-261(substanti)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(distinction)-230.9(in)-250.9(this)-250.9(area)-271(between)]TJ T* [(potential)-230.9(and)-250.9(actual)-250.9(meaning.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(It)-240.9(is)-230.9(w)10(orth)-240.9(re)20.1(vie)20.1(wing)-220.8(some)-240.9(e)10(xamples)-220.8(to)-240.9(sharpen)-240.9(the)-230.9(point.)-301.1(It)-230.9(is)-240.9(a)-240.9(\(generalized\))]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-230.9(implicature)-240.9(of)-250.9(\(10\))-250.9(that)-240.9(the)-250.9(speak)10(er)-250.9(wishes)-240.9(to)-240.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(the)-250.9(salt.)]TJ 0 -1.7064 TD [(\(10\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(�Can)-261(you)-240.9(pass)-250.9(me)-240.9(the)-250.9(salt?�)]TJ 3.0614 -1.5157 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-240.9(implicature:)-291.1(pass)-250.9(the)-240.9(salt)-240.9(to)-250.9(me)-250.9(if)-240.9(you)-250.9(can)]TJ -3.0614 -1.7064 TD [(But)-291.1(\(10b\))-301.1(arises)-291.1(only)-291.1(in)-291.1(conte)10(xts)-291.1(in)-291.1(which)-291.1(the)-301.1(literal)-291.1(answer)-291.1(to)-301.1(\(10a\))-301.1(is)-291.1(ob)10(vious.)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(In)-281.1(such)-281.1(situations,)-281(the)-281(literal)-281.1(answer)-291.1(f)10(ails)-281(to)-281(qualify)-281(as)-281(informati)20.1(v)10(e)0(,)-281(rele)20.1(v)20.1(ant,)-281.1(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD (suf)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.2021 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ciently)-210.8(brief.)-301.1(The)-220.8(hearer)-220.8(infers)-220.8(from)-220.8(this)-210.8(that)-220.8(the)-210.8(question)-210.8(is)-220.8(in)-210.8(f)10(act)-230.9(something)]TJ -1.7582 -1.2145 TD [(else,)-341.3(relying)-321.2(on)-331.2(general)-331.2(w)10(orld)-321.2(kno)20.1(wledge)-321.2(to)-321.2(hear)-331.2(it)-321.2(as)-331.2(a)-331.2(request)-331.2(that)-321.2(the)-321.2(salt)-331.2(be)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(passed)-301.1(to)-301.1(the)-311.2(speak)10(er)50.2(.)-481.8(But)-311.2(in)-301.1(other)-311.2(conte)10(xts,)-311.2(\(10b\))-301.1(could)-301.1(easily)-311.2(be)-301.1(absent.)-481.8(Sup-)]TJ T* [(pose)-271(that)-271(the)-271(addressee)-271(has)-271(recently)-281(brok)10(en)-271(both)-261(arms,)-281(or)-271(is)-271(li)20.1(ving)-250.9(in)-271(a)-281(society)-261(in)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(which)-281.1(people)-281.1(of)-291.1(his)-281(kind)-281.1(are)-301.1(rarely)-291.1(permitted)-271(to)-291.1(touch)-281(others�)-281(foodstuf)20.1(f.)-411.5(In)-291.1(such)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(conte)10(xts,)-230.9(a)-240.9(�yes�)-250.9(or)-240.9(�no�)-240.9(answer)-250.9(pro)10(vides)-230.9(ne)20.1(w)-240.9(information,)-220.8(and)-250.9(a)-240.9(request)-240.9(that)-240.9(the)]TJ T* [(speak)10(er)-200.7(be)-200.7(passed)-200.8(the)-200.7(salt)-190.7(is)-200.8(unreasonable.)-281(As)-200.8(a)-200.8(result,)-210.8(the)-190.7(potential)-190.7(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(implicature)-230.9(\(10b\))-250.9(f)10(ails)-250.9(to)-240.9(become)-250.9(actual)-250.9(\(perhaps\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(CIs)-381.4(are)-381.4(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.3166 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-381.4(to)-371.4(be)-381.4(re)10(gular)-371.4(logical)-371.4(entailments.)-672.5(W)80.3(e)-381.4(needn�)20.1(t)-381.4(w)10(orry)-371.4(about)]TJ -6.3382 -1.2145 TD [(sentence-e)10(xternal)-431.6(f)10(actors)-431.6(remo)10(ving)-421.6(content)-421.6(that)-431.6(is)-421.6(usually)-421.6(present)-431.6(in)-431.6(dif)20.1(ferent)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(conte)10(xts.)-562.1(In)-341.3(f)10(act,)-361.3(to)-341.3(tak)10(e)-331.2(such)-341.3(conte)10(xtual)-321.2(information)-331.2(into)-331.2(account)-331.2(w)10(ould)-331.2(be)-341.3(to)]TJ T* [(needlessly)-210.8(complicate)-220.8(the)-220.8(theory)-210.8(of)-230.9(CIs.)-301.1(N)30.1(A)0(s)-210.8(support)-210.8(this)-220.8(narro)20.1(wly)-210.8(semantic)-220.8(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ception:)-391.5(their)-291.1(content)-281(is)-291.1(not)-291.1(deniable,)-301.1(\(11a\),)-311.2(nor)-291.1(is)-291.1(it)-281.1(suspendible)-281(with)-291.1(epistemic)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(riders,)-240.9(\(11b,)-250.9(c\).)]TJ 0 -1.7064 TD [(\(11\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Edna,)-341.3(a)-321.2(fearless)-321.2(leader)40.1(,)-341.3(started)-321.2(the)-321.2(descent.)]TJ 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 389.4 203.58 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 394.32 199.26 Tm [(Edna)-321.2(is)-321.2(not)-311.2(a)-321.2(fearless)]TJ -18.4991 -1.2145 TD [(leader)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5056 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 171.06 Tm 0 Tc (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 166.74 Tm [(Lance)-351.3(Armstrong,)-361.4(the)-351.3(2002)-341.3(T)80.3(our)-341.3(winner)40.1(,)-371.4(i)0(s)-341.3(training,)-361.3(if)-351.3(Armstrong)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(did)-240.9(win)-250.9(the)-240.9(2002)-250.9(T)80.3(our)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5157 TD (c.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 138.42 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 134.1 Tm [(If)-210.8(Armstrong)-190.7(did)-190.7(win)-200.8(the)-190.7(2002)-200.8(T)80.3(our)40.2(,)-210.8(then)-190.7(Lance)-210.8(Armstrong,)-200.8(the)-190.7(2002)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(T)80.3(our)-250.9(winner)40.1(,)-240.9(i)0(s)-250.9(training.)]TJ 10.7903 -2.4993 TD (9)Tj ET endstream endobj 41 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 43 0 obj << /Length 7000 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(These)-210.8(f)10(acts)-210.8(also)-210.8(suggest)-200.8(that)-210.8(a)-210.8(presuppositional)-190.7(treatment)-210.8(is)-200.7(not)-210.8(feasible.)-291.1(Example)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(\(11c\))-311.2(is)-301.1(especially)-301.1(useful)-301.1(in)-311.2(this)-291.1(re)10(gard:)-421.6(if)-311.2(the)-301.1(proposition)-291.1(that)-301.1(Armstrong)-301.1(is)-301.1(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(2002)-210.8(T)80.3(our)-210.8(winner)-210.8(were)-220.8(a)-220.8(presupposition)-190.7(engendered)-220.8(by)-210.8(the)-210.8(N)30.1(A)-210.8(in)-210.8(the)-220.8(consequent,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(then)-321.2(the)-311.2(preposed)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.5068 0 TD (if)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7062 0 TD [(-clause)-321.2(w)10(ould)-311.2(w)10(ork)-321.2(to)-311.2(satisfy)-321.2(its)-311.2(requirements.)-521.9(That)-321.2(is,)-331.2(the)]TJ -8.213 -1.2045 TD [(e)10(xample)-321.2(w)10(ould)-321.2(w)10(ork)-331.2(in)-331.2(the)-331.2(same)-331.2(f)10(ashion)-331.2(as)-331.2(the)-331.2(classic)-331.2(e)10(xample)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 26.6112 0 TD [(If)-331.2(Eddie)-331.2(has)-331.2(a)]TJ -26.6112 -1.2145 TD [(do)10(g)10(,)-281.1(then)-271(his)-271(do)10(g)-271(i)0(s)-271(a)-281.1(fer)40.2(ocious)-261(man-eater)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 16.9741 0 TD [(,)-281(which)-271(does)-271(not)-271(itself)-271(presuppose)-271(that)]TJ -16.9741 -1.2045 TD [(Eddie)-291.1(has)-301.1(a)-311.2(dog.)-461.7(But)-301.1(\(11c\))-301.1(does)-301.1(assert)-301.1(that)-291.1(Armstrong)-291.1(is)-301.1(the)-301.1(2002)-291.1(T)80.3(our)-301.1(winner)40.1(,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(hence)-250.9(the)-250.9(oddness)-240.9(of)-240.9(placing)-250.9(this)-240.9(content)-240.9(inside)-240.9(the)-240.9(antecedent)-250.9(of)-250.9(a)-250.9(conditional.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(F)10(o)0(r)-190.7(Grice,)-210.8(clause)-190.7(\(1a\))-190.7(also)-190.7(counts)-180.7(as)-190.7(a)-200.8(point)-180.7(of)-190.7(contrast)-180.7(between)-200.8(the)-180.7(tw)10(o)-190.7(classes)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(of)-230.9(�implicature�.)-291.1(On)-230.9(Grice�)50.2(s)-220.8(\(1975\))-230.9(vie)20.1(w)60.2(,)-220.8(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-210.8(implicatures)-210.8(do)-230.9(not)-220.8(trace)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(back)-240.9(to)-230.9(le)10(xical)-220.8(items,)-230.9(or)-240.9(e)20.1(v)10(en)-220.8(to)-240.9(linguistic)-210.8(stuf)20.1(f.)-301.1(The)10(y)-220.8(result)-230.9(from)-240.9(relations)-220.8(among)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(propositions)-361.3(\(nonlinguistic)-361.4(objects\).)-722.7(Chierchia)-391.5(\(2004\))-381.4(challenges)-391.5(these)-381.4(points,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(and)-281(de)20.1(v)10(elops)-261(in)-271(its)-271(place)-291.1(a)-281(theory)-271(in)-281(which)-271(le)10(xical)-271(items)-271(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-261(im-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(plicature)-240.9(dimensions.)-281.1(F)10(o)0(r)-240.9(instance,)-240.9(the)-240.9(denotation)-230.9(of)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 21.2115 0 TD (or)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.1501 0 TD [(is)-240.9(that)-230.9(of)-250.9(classical)-230.9(logical)]TJ -22.3617 -1.2045 TD [(disjunction,)-301.1(b)20.1(u)0(t)-301.1(with)-291.1(a)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.3783 0 TD [(not)-301.1(and)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.4102 0 TD [(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-291.1(implicature)-301.1(dimension.)-461.7(Ho)20.1(we)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)]TJ -12.7885 -1.2145 TD [(this)-311.2(multidimensionality)-271(in)-321.2(no)-311.2(w)10(a)0(y)-321.2(threatens)-311.2(the)-321.2(autonomy)-301.1(of)-321.2(CIs.)-521.9(The)-321.2(issue)-311.2(is)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(again)-301.1(deniability)60.2(.)-481.8(Although)-301.1(Chierchia�)50.2(s)-311.2(\(2004\))-311.2(deri)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-301.1(the)-311.2(meanings)-311.2(in)-301.1(\(12b,)-311.2(c\))]TJ T* [(for)-281.1(\(12a\),)-301.1(conte)10(xtual)-271(f)10(actors)-291.1(might)-271(still)-271(conspire)-281.1(to)-281(pre)20.1(v)10(ent)-271(\(12c\))-291.1(from)-281.1(becoming)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD (actual.)Tj 0 -1.7666 TD [(\(12\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Mary)-250.9(will)-240.9(run)-250.9(the)-240.9(meeting)-240.9(or)-250.9(operate)-250.9(the)-250.9(projector)50.2(.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.5357 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(at-issue:)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 2.148 -1.616 TD (run)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.5662 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (the)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.343 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (meeting)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.3877 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (mary)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2668 0 TD (\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.532 0 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.803 0 TD (operate)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.2207 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (the)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.343 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(pr)20.1(ojector)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 3.9875 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (mary)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2668 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf -26.7794 -1.5357 TD [(c.)-1455.4(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-240.9(implicature:)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 2.148 -2.1681 TD (�)Tj /F3 1 Tf 0.7729 1.4052 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.4128 -0.793 TD (run)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.5662 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (the)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.343 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (meeting)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.3877 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (mary)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2668 0 TD (\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 1.2145 0 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf -13.994 -1.2145 TD (operate)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.2307 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (the)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.343 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(pr)20.1(ojector)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 3.9875 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (mary)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2668 0 TD (\))Tj /F3 1 Tf 2.2708 2.0075 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -22.1929 -3.6938 TD [(The)-311.2(utterance)-321.2(might)-311.2(be)-311.2(follo)20.1(wed)-311.2(by)-311.2(�He)10(y)60.2(,)-331.2(she�)10(ll)-311.2(do)-311.2(both!�.)-511.9(Or)-321.2(it)-311.2(might)-301.1(be)-321.2(pre-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(ceded)-210.8(by)-200.8(an)-200.7(agreement)-200.8(that)-200.7(if)-210.8(Mary)-200.8(does)-200.7(one,)-210.8(then)-200.7(she)-200.7(does)-200.7(the)-200.7(other)50.2(.)-291.1(The)-200.8(maxims)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(of)-271(quality)-250.9(and)-271(quantity)-261(then)-261(conspire)-261(to)-271(ensure)-271(that)-261(\(12c\))-271(disappears.)-371.4(In)-271(sum,)-261(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-341.3(implicature)-341.3(dimension)-331.2(is)-351.3(a)-351.3(n)0(e)10(gotiable)-341.3(part)-351.3(of)-351.3(denotations.)-602.3(Ev)10(en)]TJ T* [(after)-301.1(b)20.1(uilding)-291.1(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-281(implicatures)-291.1(into)-291.1(the)-301.1(le)10(xicon,)-301.1(we)-311.2(still)-281(call)-301.1(upon)-301.1(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(maxims)-230.9(to)-250.9(determine)-240.9(where)-250.9(the)10(y)-240.9(actually)-250.9(arise.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 156.66 Tm [(3.2)-995.4(CIs)-242.6(vs.)-242.6(pr)16.7(esuppositions)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 134.1 Tm [(Presuppositions)-351.3(and)-361.3(CIs)-381.4(share)-371.4(the)-371.4(important)-351.3(le)10(xicality)-351.3(property)-371.4(\(1a\).)-672.5(But)-371.4(the)10(y)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(di)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(g)0(e)-281.1(o)0(n)-301.1(almost)-281.1(all)-301.1(other)-291.1(substanti)20.1(v)10(e)-271(points.)-441.6(Presuppositions)-281(are)-301.1(f)10(amously)-281(de-)]TJ 15.7488 -2.4993 TD (10)Tj ET endstream endobj 44 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F3 24 0 R /F4 25 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 46 0 obj << /Length 7838 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(niable)-351.3(\(cancellable\);)-421.6(Green)-361.3(\(2000:461\))-351.3(identi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 18.5334 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(es)-361.3(this)-351.3(feature)-361.3(as)-361.4(one)-361.4(of)-361.4(the)-361.4(fe)20.1(w)]TJ -19.0896 -1.2045 TD [(things)-291.1(that)-311.2(all)-301.1(presupposition)-291.1(researchers)-321.2(agree)-311.2(upon.)-491.8(But)-311.2(presupposition)-281.1(denial)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(seems)-261(a)-281.1(dif)20.1(ferent)-261(af)20.1(f)10(air)-281.1(from)-271(con)40.1(v)10(ersational-implicature)-240.9(denial.)-371.4(One)-271(might)-261(ar)20.1(gue)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(that)-351.3(presuppositions)-341.3(are)-371.4(not)-351.3(cancelled)-371.4(due)-361.3(to)-351.3(speci)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 20.8265 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(c)-371.4(discourse)-351.3(f)10(actors)-361.4(broadly)]TJ -21.3826 -1.2045 TD [(speaking,)-321.2(b)20.1(u)0(t)-311.2(rather)-321.2(due)-311.2(to)-311.2(speci)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 13.2462 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(c)-321.2(structural)-311.2(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.2964 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(gurations)-301.1(\(being)-311.2(in)-321.2(the)-311.2(scope)]TJ -20.655 -1.2145 TD [(of)-250.9(a)-250.9(special)-240.9(kind)-240.9(of)-250.9(ne)10(gation,)-230.9(for)-250.9(e)10(xample\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Clause)-291.1(\(1d\),)-301.1(which)-281(speci)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 10.0095 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(es)-291.1(that)-291.1(CIs)-291.1(are)-301.1(independent)-281.1(of)-281(the)-291.1(at-issue)-281.1(content,)]TJ -12.0311 -1.2145 TD [(articulates)-291.1(why)-291.1(these)-291.1(classes)-291.1(of)-301.1(meaning)-291.1(require)-291.1(dif)20.1(ferent)-301.1(theoretical)-291.1(treatments.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(Almost)-190.7(all)-200.8(presupposition)-180.7(logics)-200.7(create)-210.8(a)-210.8(dependenc)10(y)-190.7(between)-210.8(the)-200.8(presuppositions)]TJ T* [(and)-291.1(the)-291.1(at-issue)-281(entailments.)-421.6(This)-281(is)-291.1(the)-291.1(guiding)-271(intuition)-271(behind)-291.1(the)-291.1(reconstruc-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(tion)-190.7(of)-190.7(presuppositions)-180.7(in)-190.7(terms)-190.7(of)-200.7(partial)-200.7(logics:)-271(if)-190.7(e)10(xpression)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 24.5949 0 TD (E)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6811 0 TD [(�)50.2(s)-190.7(presuppositions)]TJ -25.276 -1.2045 TD [(are)-351.3(not)-341.3(true,)-371.4(then)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.4302 0 TD (E)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0324 0 TD [(should)-331.2(lack)-351.3(a)-341.3(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.744 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-351.3(v)20.1(alue.)-592.2(\(Karttunen)-351.3(and)-341.3(Peters)-351.3(\(1979\))]TJ -15.7628 -1.2145 TD [(might)-281(dissent)-291.1(from)-301.1(this)-281.1(statement.)-451.7(It)-301.1(depends)-291.1(on)-301.1(whether)-301.1(the)10(y)-291.1(intend)-291.1(their)-291.1(logic)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(to)-240.9(model)-240.9(presuppositions)-230.9(in)-240.9(the)-250.9(usual)-240.9(sense.\))]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(The)-321.2(e)10(xciting)-311.2(report)-311.2(in)-321.2(\(13\))-321.2(nicely)-311.2(illustrates)-311.2(ho)20.1(w)-311.2(the)-321.2(at-issue)-311.2(and)-321.2(CI)-321.2(dimen-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(sions)-240.9(operate)-250.9(independently)60.2(.)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(13\))-1395.2(Lance)-250.9(Armstrong,)-230.9(an)-250.9(Arkansan,)-250.9(has)-250.9(w)10(o)0(n)-240.9(the)-250.9(2002)-240.9(T)80.3(our)-250.9(de)-240.9(France!)]TJ T* [(I)-230.9(kno)20.1(w)-230.9(that)-230.9(Armstrong)-220.8(is)-230.9(a)-230.9(T)70.3(e)10(xan;)-230.9(the)-230.9(CI)-250.9(is)-220.8(f)10(alse.)-311.2(But)-230.9(I)-240.9(can)-230.9(still)-220.8(reco)10(v)10(e)0(r)-240.9(from)-230.9(\(13\))]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-271(information)-261(that)-281.1(Lance)-281(w)10(o)0(n)-271(this)-271(year�)50.2(s)-271(T)80.3(our)50.2(.)-391.5(I)-281(need)-271(not)-281.1(accommodate)-271(the)-271(CI)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(proposition)-301.1(to)-321.2(do)-321.2(this.)-511.9(In)-331.2(a)-321.2(multidimensional)-291.1(semantics,)-331.2(the)-321.2(situation)-301.1(is)-321.2(easy)-321.2(to)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(describe)-271(in)-261(terms)-261(of)-271(truth)-261(v)20.1(alues.)-361.4(If)-281(we)-271(stick)-261(to)-261(sentences)-271(containing)-261(one)-261(at-issue)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(v)20.1(alue)-210.8(and)-220.8(one)-230.9(CI)-220.8(v)20.1(alue,)-220.8(we)-230.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(a)-220.8(four)20.1(-v)20.1(alued)-220.8(system)-210.8(akin)-210.8(to)-220.8(Herzber)20.1(ger�)50.2(s)-230.9(\(1973\))]TJ T* (logic:)Tj 0 -2.0477 TD (\(14\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 3.5531 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD 0.9963 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.7766 0 TD 0 Tc (0)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj -4.9508 -1.2045 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD 0.9963 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.7766 0 TD 0 Tc (0)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -8.5043 -2.0276 TD [(In)-291.1(our)-291.1(w)10(orld,)-291.1(the)-291.1(e)10(xtensional)-281(v)20.1(alue)-281(of)-291.1(\(13\))-291.1(is)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 18.416 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(.)-421.6(I)0(n)-291.1(w)10(orlds)-281.1(where)-301.1(Armstrong)]TJ -20.5904 -1.2045 TD [(is)-261(neither)-271(an)-271(Arkansan)-271(nor)-261(the)-271(2002)-261(T)80.3(our)-271(winner)40.2(,)-271(\(13\))-271(denotes)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 25.2959 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(.)-351.3(Both)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 2.8172 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (1)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -32.0703 -1.2045 TD (and)Tj /F1 1 Tf 1.6647 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD (,)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (0)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5922 0 TD [(are)-230.9(the)-210.8(bane)-220.8(of)-220.8(a)-220.8(multidimensional)-190.7(theory)-210.8(of)-220.8(presuppositions.)-271(The)10(y)-210.8(rep-)]TJ -4.0398 -1.2145 TD [(resent)-220.8(situations)-190.7(in)-220.8(which)-210.8(a)-220.8(presupposition)-190.7(is)-220.8(f)10(alse.)-301.1(One)-210.8(must)-210.8(either)-220.8(collapse)-210.8(these)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(v)20.1(alues)-291.1(to)-291.1(�unde)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.1715 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned�)-301.1(\(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-311.2(1997:956;)-301.1(Krahmer)-301.1(1998:143\),)-301.1(or)-301.1(else)-301.1(admit)-291.1(only)]TJ -6.7276 -1.2045 TD [(those)-341.3(v)20.1(aluations)-331.2(in)-351.3(which)-341.3(all)-351.3(presuppositions)-321.2(are)-361.3(true)-341.3(\(v)20.1(an)-351.3(der)-351.3(Sandt)-351.3(1988:21\).)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(One)-240.9(or)-240.9(the)-240.9(other)-230.9(mo)10(v)10(e)-230.9(is)-230.9(necessary)-250.9(to)-230.9(capture)-240.9(the)-240.9(intuition)-220.8(that)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 25.1918 0 TD [(Ali)-240.9(doesn�)30.1(t)-230.9(r)40.1(ealize)]TJ -25.1918 -1.2045 TD [(her)-230.9(coat)-220.8(is)-220.8(on)]TJ /TT9 1 Tf 5.6251 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD -0.0402 Tc (re)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0237 0 TD 0 Tc [(is)-220.8(unde)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 2.8317 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-230.9(if)-230.9(the)-230.9(presupposition)-200.8(that)-230.9(her)-230.9(coat)-230.9(is)-220.8(on)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.3115 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(re)-230.9(is)-230.9(f)10(alse.)]TJ -26.9388 -1.2145 TD [(The)-240.9(dependenc)10(y)-240.9(o)0(f)-240.9(at-issue)-230.9(meanings)-230.9(on)-240.9(their)-230.9(presuppositions)-220.8(is)-240.9(the)-230.9(most)-230.9(im-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD (portant)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 3.1136 0 TD [(theor)40.2(etical)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.583 0 TD [(di)20.1(vide)-281.1(between)-291.1(CIs)-301.1(and)-301.1(presuppositions.)-421.6(The)-291.1(most)-281(important)]TJ 8.0523 -2.8105 TD (11)Tj ET endstream endobj 47 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT9 19 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 51 0 obj << /Length 6680 >> stream BT /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(pr)40.1(etheor)40.2(etical)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 5.9561 0 TD [(di)20.1(vide)-371.4(is)-371.4(this:)-562.1(Grice)-391.5(\(1975\))-381.4(mak)10(es)-371.4(no)-381.4(pro)10(vision)-361.3(that)-381.4(CI)-381.4(content)]TJ -5.9561 -1.2045 TD [(should)-351.3(be)-371.4(backgrounded)-371.4(\(v)20.1(an)-361.4(der)-371.4(Sandt)-371.4(1988:74\),)-391.5(and,)-391.5(indeed,)-401.5(CI)-371.4(e)10(xpressions)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(usually)-331.2(of)20.1(fer)-341.3(information)-331.2(that)-341.3(is)-341.3(not)-341.3(part)-341.3(of)-341.3(the)-351.3(common)-331.2(ground)-331.2(when)-351.3(the)10(y)-331.2(are)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(uttered.)-301.1(Although)-230.9(it)-240.9(is)-240.9(possible)-240.9(for)-240.9(true)-250.9(presupposition)-220.8(triggers)-240.9(to)-240.9(introduce)-240.9(no)10(v)10(e)0(l)]TJ T* [(information,)-250.9(this)-250.9(is)-261(accompanied)-250.9(by)-261(a)-271(particular)-261(discourse)-250.9(ef)20.1(fect,)-271(viz.,)-261(accommo-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(dation.)-291.1(In)-240.9(order)-240.9(to)-230.9(understand)-230.9(the)-230.9(utterance,)-240.9(the)-230.9(hearer)-250.9(must)-220.8(adjust)-230.9(his)-230.9(kno)20.1(wledge)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(so)-341.3(that)-341.3(it)-341.3(entails)-341.3(whate)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-341.3(the)-341.3(speak)10(er)-351.3(has)-351.3(presupposed.)-592.2(Outside)-331.2(of)-351.3(specialized)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(discourse)-311.2(conditions,)-311.2(it)-311.2(is)-311.2(not)-311.2(possible)-301.1(to)-311.2(esche)20.1(w)-311.2(accommodation)-301.1(�)-311.2(the)-311.2(adjust-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(ment)-311.2(is)-311.2(thrust)-311.2(upon)-311.2(an)10(y)-311.2(listener)-311.2(who)-311.2(wishes)-311.2(to)-311.2(use)-321.2(information)-301.1(pro)10(vided)-311.2(by)-311.2(the)]TJ T* [(utterance.)-572.1(As)-341.3(Heim)-331.2(\(1992:215,)-341.3(fn.)-341.3(6\))-341.3(says,)-351.3(follo)20.1(wing)-321.2(Soames)-341.3(\(1989:578�579\),)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(�there)-261(is)-261(no)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 4.8823 0 TD [(de)-261(jur)40.1(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.0365 0 TD [(accommodation�)-250.9(of)-261(a)-261(proposition)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 13.6769 0 TD (p)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.8171 0 TD [(unless)-250.9(the)-261(conte)10(xt)-250.9(entails)]TJ -22.4128 -1.2045 TD [(the)-311.2(ne)10(gation)-291.1(of)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 6.4014 0 TD (p)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.8673 0 TD [(already)-311.2(\(and)-311.2(hence)-311.2(accommodation)-301.1(of)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 15.8163 0 TD (p)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.8673 0 TD [(w)10(ould)-301.1(�gi)20.1(v)10(e)-301.1(rise)-311.2(to)-301.1(a)]TJ -23.9523 -1.2145 TD [(communicati)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(impass�;)-240.9(Soames)-240.9(1989:579\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Nominal)-210.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-190.7(d)0(o)-210.8(not)-210.8(function)-210.8(in)-210.8(this)-210.8(w)10(ay;)-230.9(their)-210.8(primary)-210.8(discourse)-210.8(func-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(tion)-341.3(is)-351.3(to)-351.3(introduce)-351.3(ne)20.1(w)-341.3(b)20.1(ut)-351.3(deemphasized)-351.3(material.)-622.3(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-361.3(\(2001\))-351.3(mak)10(es)-351.3(this)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(observ)20.1(ation,)-230.9(and)-250.9(supports)-230.9(it)-250.9(with)-240.9(an)-250.9(e)10(xample)-230.9(so)-250.9(lo)10(v)10(ely)-230.9(it)-240.9(is)-250.9(w)10(orth)-240.9(repeating:)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(15\))-1395.2(�Sweden)-271(may)-261(e)10(xport)-250.9(synthetic)-261(w)10(olf)-261(urine)-261(�)-261(sprayed)-261(along)-261(roads)-271(to)-261(k)10(eep)]TJ 3.0614 -1.2045 TD [(elk)-240.9(a)10(w)10(a)0(y)-250.9(�)-240.9(to)-250.9(K)10(u)0(w)10(ait)-240.9(for)-250.9(use)-240.9(against)-240.9(camels.)70.3(�)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(\(Associated)-240.9(Press,)-250.9(January)-250.9(19,)-240.9(1995;)-240.9(cited)-250.9(in)-240.9(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-261(2001:20,)-230.9(\(E34\).\))]TJ -3.0614 -2.0376 TD [(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-261(observ)10(es)-261(that)-250.9(the)-261(proposition)-240.9(that)-250.9(w)10(olf)-261(urine)-261(is)-250.9(sprayed)-261(along)-261(the)-250.9(roads)-261(to)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(k)10(eep)-341.3(elk)-331.2(a)10(w)10(a)0(y)-331.2(i)0(s)-341.3(interpreted)-331.2(outside)-321.2(the)-341.3(scope)-331.2(of)-341.3(the)-331.2(modal,)-351.3(and)-341.3(that)-331.2(e)10(xamples)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(with)-271(this)-281(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-261(belo)20.1(w)-281.1(the)-281.1(other)-281.1(presupposition)-261(holes)-281.1(\(ne)10(gation,)-281(questioning,)]TJ T* [(conditionalization\))-271(re)20.1(v)10(eal)-291.1(the)-291.1(same)-301.1(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariance)-291.1(of)-291.1(this)-291.1(content.)-441.7(But)-291.1(the)-291.1(content)-291.1(is)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(of)20.1(fered)-220.8(as)-230.9(ne)20.1(w)-220.8(information)-200.8(�)-220.8(a)0(n)-230.9(aside,)-220.8(to)-220.8(be)-230.9(sure,)-220.8(b)20.1(ut,)-230.9(as)-220.8(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-230.9(says,)-220.8(�the)-230.9(writer)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(of)-261(the)-261(te)10(xt)-250.9(v)10(ery)-250.9(lik)10(ely)-250.9(does)-261(not)-250.9(e)10(xpect)-261(readers)-271(to)-250.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-261(an)10(y)-250.9(pre)20.1(vious)-250.9(kno)20.1(wledge)-250.9(of)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-250.9(subject�)-250.9(\(p.)-250.9(20\).)-321.2(Chierchia)-261(and)-250.9(McConnell-Ginet)-240.9(\(1990:351�352\))-240.9(of)20.1(fer)-250.9(much)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-240.9(same)-250.9(v)10(erdict)-240.9(for)-250.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(relati)20.1(v)10(es.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(The)-331.2(generalization)-321.2(is)-321.2(that)-321.2(N)30.1(A)-321.2(content)-321.2(does)-321.2(not)-321.2(e)10(xpress)-321.2(backgrounded)-321.2(infor)20.1(-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(mation.)-491.8(W)80.3(e)-311.2(can)-321.2(strengthen)-301.1(this)-301.1(claim)-311.2(to)-311.2(an)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.9356 0 TD [(anti-bac)20.1(kgr)40.2(ounding)-281(r)40.1(equir)40.1(ement)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 12.9917 0 TD 0.4316 Tc [(:i)431.6(n)]TJ -30.9273 -1.2045 TD 0 Tc [(cases)-261(where)-271(the)-271(content)-250.9(of)-271(a)-271(supplement)-240.9(is)-261(part)-271(of)-261(the)-261(initial)-261(conte)10(xt,)-250.9(the)-261(result)-261(is)]TJ T* [(infelicity)-230.9(due)-250.9(to)-250.9(redundanc)10(y)60.2(,)-230.9(as)-250.9(in)-250.9(\(16b\).)]TJ 0 -2.0477 TD [(\(16\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Lance)-261(Armstrong)-230.9(survi)20.1(v)10(e)0(d)-230.9(cancer)50.2(.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.6261 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 161.34 Tm 0 Tc (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 157.02 Tm [(When)-381.4(reporters)-371.4(intervie)20.1(w)-371.4(Lance,)-411.5(a)-381.4(cancer)-381.4(survi)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)40.1(,)-391.5(he)-381.4(often)-371.4(talks)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(about)-250.9(the)-240.9(disease.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD [(c.)-1455.4(And)-250.9(most)-230.9(riders)-250.9(kno)20.1(w)-240.9(that)-240.9(Lance)-261(Armstrong)-230.9(is)-240.9(a)-261(cancer)-250.9(survi)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)50.2(.)]TJ 12.6874 -2.7904 TD (12)Tj ET endstream endobj 52 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 54 0 obj << /Length 7360 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(W)40.2(ith)-291.1(\(16a\))-311.2(part)-301.1(of)-311.2(the)-301.1(conte)10(xt,)-301.1(the)-301.1(use)-301.1(of)-311.2(the)-301.1(f)10(acti)20.1(v)10(e)-291.1(predicate)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 25.449 0 TD (know)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.422 0 TD [(in)-291.1(\(16c\))-311.2(re-)]TJ -27.871 -1.2045 TD [(quires)-250.9(no)-240.9(accommodation)-240.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(content)-250.9(of)-250.9(its)-250.9(complement.)-301.1(But)-250.9(the)-250.9(same)-250.9(kind)-250.9(of)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(backgrounding)-261(renders)-271(the)-271(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(in)-271(\(16b\))-271(infelicitous.)-361.4(As)-271(with)-271(at-issue)-271(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(tent,)-351.3(we)-341.3(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-331.2(an)-341.3(anti-backgrounding)-311.2(ef)20.1(fect.)-582.2(In)-331.2(general,)-361.4(neither)-331.2(at-issue)-331.2(content)]TJ T* [(nor)-271(CI)-291.1(content)-271(should)-261(be)-281(presupposed.)-381.4(\(The)-281(e)10(xceptions)-261(to)-271(this)-271(e)10(xplored)-271(by)-271(Horn)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(\(1991\))-240.9(sho)20.1(w)-240.9(CIs)-250.9(and)-250.9(at-issue)-240.9(entailments)-240.9(patterning)-230.9(together)50.2(.\))]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(This)-220.8(suf)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 3.2008 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ces)-220.8(to)-230.9(establish)-210.8(that)-220.8(supplements)-210.8(do)-220.8(not)-220.8(meet)-230.9(the)-220.8(main)-220.8(pretheoretical)]TJ -5.2224 -1.2145 TD [(requirements)-331.2(for)-351.3(counting)-331.2(as)-351.3(presupposed.)-582.2(The)-351.3(technical)-341.3(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 24.7151 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-331.2(of)-351.3(�presup-)]TJ -25.2712 -1.2045 TD [(position�)-321.2(is)-341.3(much)-331.2(more)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 9.834 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(e)10(xible,)-361.4(though.)-572.1(Recent)-351.3(theories)-341.3(of)-341.3(presupposition)-321.2(\(or)40.1(,)]TJ -10.3902 -1.2045 TD [(at)-271(least,)-261(recent)-281(uses)-261(of)-271(the)-261(term\))-271(some)20.1(what)-250.9(weak)10(en)-271(the)-271(strength)-261(of)-261(this)-261(ar)20.1(gument.)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(Steedman)-291.1(\(2000:654\))-281(allo)20.1(ws)-281(that)-281.1(�the)-301.1(listener)-281.1(rapidly)-291.1(and)-291.1(unconsciously)-271(adjusts)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(his)-261(or)-261(her)-271(model)-250.9(of)-271(the)-261(domain)-250.9(of)-271(discourse)-261(to)-261(support)-250.9(the)-261(presuppositions)-240.9(of)-271(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(speak)10(er�.)-461.7(If)-311.2(this)-291.1(can)-301.1(happen,)-311.2(then)-301.1(the)-291.1(dif)20.1(ference)-311.2(between)-301.1(at-issue)-291.1(meanings)-291.1(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(presuppositions)-301.1(is)-321.2(outside)-321.2(the)-321.2(bounds)-321.2(of)-331.2(detection)-321.2(by)-321.2(the)-321.2(usual)-331.2(sorts)-311.2(of)-331.2(linguis-)]TJ T* [(tic)-351.3(ar)20.1(gument.)-642.4(If)-371.4(accommodation)-341.3(is)-351.3(unconscious)-351.3(and)-361.3(freely)-361.4(a)20.1(v)20.1(ailable,)-381.4(then)-361.4(it)-351.3(is)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(not)-311.2(distinguished)-291.1(from)-311.2(the)-311.2(sort)-311.2(of)-321.2(adjustments)-291.1(that)-311.2(speak)10(ers)-321.2(mak)10(e)-311.2(t)0(o)-311.2(their)-311.2(mod-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(els)-311.2(\(w)10(orld-vie)20.1(ws\))-301.1(when)-311.2(the)10(y)-301.1(accept)-311.2(ne)20.1(w)-311.2(information.)-481.8(This)-301.1(basically)-301.1(assimilates)]TJ T* [(presuppositions)-210.8(to)-230.9(at-issue)-230.9(meanings,)-230.9(a)-240.9(m)0(o)10(v)10(e)-220.8(that)-230.9(does)-230.9(not)-230.9(accord)-240.9(with)-230.9(colloquial)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(uses)-240.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(term)-240.9(�presupposition�.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Another)-331.2(compelling)-311.2(ar)20.1(gument)-331.2(against)-311.2(a)-341.3(treatment)-321.2(of)-331.2(N)30.1(A)0(s)-321.2(a)0(s)-331.2(presupposed)-321.2(is)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(that)-411.5(the)10(y)-411.5(are)-421.6(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariably)-401.5(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariant)-401.5(under)-421.6(the)-411.5(full)-411.5(range)-421.6(of)-411.5(presupposition)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 30.2763 0 TD (plugs)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -30.2763 -1.2045 TD [(\(v)10(erbs)-341.3(of)-351.3(saying)-341.3(and)-351.3(other)-351.3(performati)20.1(v)10(es\).)-592.2(Although)-341.3(Karttunen)-341.3(\(1973:177\))-341.3(ob-)]TJ T* [(serv)10(es)-190.7(that)-190.7(�all)-190.7(the)-200.7(plugs)-180.7(are)-210.8(leak)10(y�,)-200.8(in)-190.7(the)-190.7(sense)-200.8(that)-190.7(the)10(y)-190.7(sometimes)-170.6(allo)20.1(w)-190.7(presup-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(positions)-240.9(to)-250.9(escape)-261(them,)-261(it)-250.9(is)-250.9(in)-261(general)-261(the)-250.9(case)-271(that)-250.9(a)-261(plug)-250.9(stops)-250.9(presupposition)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(inheritance.)-331.2(F)10(o)0(r)-261(instance,)-261(in)-250.9(\(17\),)-261(the)-261(proposition)-240.9(that)-250.9(it)-261(is)-250.9(raining)-250.9(is)-261(presupposed)]TJ T* (by)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.2409 0 TD [(r)40.1(ealize)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.6815 0 TD [(,)-250.9(b)20.1(ut)-240.9(not)-240.9(by)-250.9(the)-240.9(whole)-250.9(sentence.)]TJ -3.9224 -1.8168 TD [(\(17\))-1395.2(Ed)-351.3(said)-351.3(that)-351.3(Sue)-361.3(realized)-361.3(that)-351.3(it)-351.3(w)10(a)0(s)-351.3(raining.)-622.3(\(Later)40.2(,)-391.5(w)0(e)-351.3(found)-351.3(out)-351.3(that)]TJ 3.0614 -1.2045 TD [(Ed�)50.2(s)-271(report)-281(w)10(a)0(s)-281.1(wrong.)-401.5(Sue)-291.1(can�)20.1(t)-281.1(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(realized)-281(it)-281(w)10(a)0(s)-281(raining,)-281(because)-281(it)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(w)10(asn�)20.1(t.\))]TJ -3.0614 -1.8068 TD [(Here)-301.1(again,)-301.1(we)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.4278 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nd)-291.1(that)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-271(beha)20.1(v)10(e)-291.1(dif)20.1(ferently)60.2(.)-441.7(Example)-281(\(3a\))-301.1(abo)10(v)10(e)-291.1(has)]TJ -6.9839 -1.2145 TD [(the)-250.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(inside)-250.9(the)-250.9(complement)-230.9(to)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 16.0884 0 TD (say)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.333 0 TD [(.)-311.2(But)-250.9(the)-250.9(only)-250.9(reading)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(sentence)]TJ -17.4214 -1.2045 TD [(is)-281.1(one)-301.1(in)-281.1(which)-291.1(the)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(�)50.2(s)-261(content)-291.1(escapes)-291.1(up)-291.1(through)-281(this)-281(plug.)-431.6(This)-281.1(intu-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ition)-281.1(is)-281(e)10(xpressed)-291.1(in)-291.1(all)-281(the)-291.1(w)10(ork)-291.1(on)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-271(kno)20.1(wn)-281(to)-281(me.)-441.7(\(On)-291.1(N)30.1(A)0(s)-281(and)-291.1(ap-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(positi)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(relati)20.1(v)10(es,)-240.9(see)-250.9(Thorne)-240.9(1972:553;)-230.9(Karttunen)-250.9(1976:367;)-230.9(Emonds)-230.9(1976:�II9;)]TJ T* [(Emonds)-240.9(1979)-250.9(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-250.9(1998:451;)-240.9(Aoun)-250.9(et)-261(al.)-250.9(2001;)-250.9(Potts)-250.9(2002a:83.\))-321.2(Bo)-60.2(�)]TJ 29.9385 0 TD [(er)-271(and)]TJ -29.9385 -1.2145 TD [(L)50.2(ycan)-220.8(\(1976\))-220.8(claim)-220.8(to)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 8.9967 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nd)-230.9(a)-220.8(small)-220.8(group)-220.8(of)-220.8(speak)10(ers)-230.9(for)-230.9(whom)-210.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-200.8(content)]TJ -9.5528 -1.2045 TD [(can)-331.2(end)-331.2(up)-321.2(in)-331.2(the)-331.2(scope)-321.2(of)-331.2(a)-331.2(cleft)-331.2(ne)10(gation)-311.2(lik)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.6874 0 TD [(it)-321.2(is)-331.2(false)-321.2(that)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 5.6406 0 TD [(.)-542(\()0(I)-331.2(refer)-341.3(to)-321.2(Potts)]TJ -9.5792 -2.4993 TD (13)Tj ET endstream endobj 55 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 57 0 obj << /Length 6540 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(2005)-311.2(for)-311.2(a)-321.2(reassessment)-311.2(of)-311.2(their)-311.2(data)-321.2(and)-311.2(claims,)-321.2(which)-311.2(partially)-311.2(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 28.1385 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD [(ate)-321.2(direct)]TJ -28.6946 -1.2045 TD [(and)-220.8(indirect)-220.8(quotation\).)-281(But)-230.9(the)10(y)-210.8(d)0(o)-220.8(not)-220.8(challenge)-220.8(the)-220.8(idea)-220.8(that)-220.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-200.8(a)0(l)10(w)10(ays)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(scope)-321.2(outside)-301.1(of)-321.2(propositional)-301.1(attitude)-311.2(predicates)-311.2(\(see)-331.2(Bo)-60.2(�)]TJ 23.305 0 TD [(er)-321.2(and)-321.2(L)50.2(ycan)-311.2(1976:21,)]TJ -23.305 -1.2045 TD (\(45\)\).)Tj 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(Ho)20.1(we)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)-210.8(I)-230.9(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(met)-220.8(speak)10(ers)-220.8(who)-220.8(claim)-210.8(to)-220.8(allo)20.1(w)-210.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-190.7(t)0(o)-220.8(b)0(e)-220.8(interpreted)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(inside)-331.2(propositional)-331.2(attitude)-331.2(conte)10(xts.)-592.2(In)-341.3(assessing)-341.3(such)-341.3(claims,)-361.3(one)-341.3(must)-341.3(k)10(eep)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(in)-291.1(mind)-281.1(that)-291.1(nothing)-281(about)-291.1(placing)-291.1(an)-291.1(N)30.1(A)-291.1(inside)-281(a)-301.1(propositional)-271(attitude)-291.1(conte)10(xt)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(entails)-361.4(that)-371.4(the)-371.4(subject)-371.4(of)-371.4(that)-371.4(propositional)-351.3(attitude)-361.4(v)10(erb)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 23.8421 0 TD [(disbelie)10(ves)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.7385 0 TD [(that)-371.4(N)30.1(A)110.4(�)50.2(s)]TJ -28.5806 -1.2045 TD [(content.)-371.4(In)-271(\(18\),)-281(we)-281.1(do)-271(not)-261(attrib)20.1(ute)-271(to)-261(Sheila)-281(the)-271(proposition)-250.9(that)-271(Chuck)-271(is)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 30.4147 0 TD (not)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5589 0 TD (a)Tj -31.9736 -1.2045 TD [(psychopath,)-240.9(nor)-250.9(do)-250.9(we)-261(e)20.1(v)10(en)-240.9(indicate)-250.9(that)-250.9(Sheila)-250.9(is)-250.9(agnostic)-250.9(about)-250.9(the)-250.9(truth)-240.9(of)-261(this)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD (proposition.)Tj 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(18\))-1395.2(Sheila)-250.9(belie)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-230.9(that)-240.9(Chuck,)-250.9(a)-250.9(psychopath,)-240.9(is)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 20.7892 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-250.9(t)0(o)-250.9(w)10(atch)-250.9(the)-240.9(kids.)]TJ -21.3454 -2.0476 TD [(What�)50.2(s)-250.9(more,)-261(propositional)-240.9(attitude)-240.9(predicates)-261(lik)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 20.4769 0 TD [(belie)10(ve)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.072 0 TD [(do)-261(not)-250.9(impose)-250.9(an)10(y)-250.9(e)10(x-)]TJ -23.5489 -1.2045 TD [(hausti)20.1(vity)-321.2(requirements,)-361.3(e)20.1(v)10(en)-341.3(as)-351.3(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-331.2(implicatures.)-592.2(In)-351.3(saying)-331.2(�Sheila)]TJ T* [(belie)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-281(that)-291.1(Chuck)-301.1(is)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 9.188 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-301.1(t)0(o)-291.1(w)10(atch)-301.1(the)-291.1(kids�)-291.1(one)-301.1(does)-291.1(not)-291.1(suggest)-291.1(that)-291.1(this)-291.1(is)-291.1(the)]TJ -9.7441 -1.2145 TD [(only)-261(thing)-261(Sheila)-281.1(belie)20.1(v)10(es.)-371.4(So)-271(one)-271(is)-271(unlik)10(ely)-261(to)-271(arri)20.1(v)10(e)-271(at)-271(the)-271(implicature)-261(that)-271(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(subject)-230.9(of)-250.9(a)-240.9(propositional)-220.8(attitude)-230.9(v)10(erb)-240.9(does)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.6418 0 TD (not)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5388 0 TD [(endorse)-240.9(the)-240.9(content)-230.9(of)-250.9(an)-240.9(embed-)]TJ -19.1806 -1.2045 TD [(ded)-200.7(N)30.1(A)0(.)-200.7(What)-210.8(one)-200.8(might)-190.7(do)-210.8(is)-200.8(dra)10(w)-200.7(the)-200.8(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-200.7(implicature)-190.7(that)-200.7(the)-200.8(subject)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(of)-220.8(the)-210.8(attitude)-210.8(predicate)-220.8(shares)-220.8(the)-220.8(speak)10(er�)50.2(s)-210.8(beliefs.)-301.1(This)-210.8(is)-210.8(the)-220.8(most)-210.8(lik)10(ely)-210.8(source)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(of)-250.9(apparently)-240.9(embedded)-240.9(readings.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(In)-210.8(light)-200.8(of)-210.8(this)-200.7(situation,)-200.7(I)-220.8(see)-210.8(just)-200.8(one)-210.8(w)10(a)0(y)-210.8(t)0(o)-210.8(test)-210.8(for)-210.8(cases)-210.8(of)-220.8(semantic)-200.7(embed-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(ding:)-291.1(follo)20.1(w)-240.9(the)-240.9(sentence)-250.9(in)-240.9(question)-230.9(with)-240.9(an)-250.9(e)10(xplicit)-230.9(dis)]TJ 22.5729 0 TD -0.0201 Tc [(avow)-10.1(a)-20.1(l)-20.1(,)-251(i)-20.1(n)-261(a)]TJ 5.0118 0 TD 0 Tc (main-clause)Tj -27.5848 -1.2045 TD [(utterance,)-351.3(of)-331.2(the)-331.2(content)-321.2(of)-331.2(the)-331.2(supplement.)-542(Such)-331.2(a)-331.2(continuation)-311.2(should)-321.2(reduce)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(possible)-361.3(readings)-381.4(of)-381.4(the)-371.4(supplement)-371.4(to)-371.4(embedded)-381.4(ones)-371.4(if)-381.4(such)-371.4(e)10(xist,)-401.5(since)-381.4(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(primary-scope)-240.9(reading)-250.9(is)-240.9(inconsistent.)-291.1(A)-250.9(rele)20.1(v)20.1(ant)-240.9(test)-240.9(case:)]TJ 0 -2.0476 TD [(\(19\))-1395.2(Sheila)-421.6(belie)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-401.5(that)-421.6(Chuck,)-461.7(a)-431.6(psychopath,)-451.7(should)-401.5(be)-431.6(lock)10(ed)-411.5(up.)]TJ 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 477.12 267.54 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 482.16 263.1 Tm (But)Tj -27.9946 -1.2045 TD [(Chuck)-250.9(isn�)20.1(t)-240.9(a)-250.9(psychopath.)]TJ -3.0614 -2.0376 TD [(I)-240.9(mark)10(ed)-240.9(this)-240.9(e)10(xample)-230.9(according)-240.9(to)-240.9(my)-240.9(intuitions,)-220.8(which)-240.9(are)-250.9(re)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 25.0002 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ected)-250.9(in)-240.9(the)-240.9(w)10(ork)]TJ -25.5564 -1.2145 TD [(cited)-240.9(abo)10(v)10(e)-230.9(by)-250.9(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-230.9(Emonds,)-230.9(and)-240.9(others,)-240.9(which,)-240.9(when)-240.9(tak)10(en)-250.9(together)40.1(,)-240.9(con-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(stitute)-230.9(compelling)-230.9(e)20.1(vidence)-250.9(that)-240.9(we)-250.9(do)-250.9(not)-240.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(genuinely)-230.9(embedded)-250.9(readings.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 160.02 Tm [(3.3)-995.4(CIs)-242.6(and)-259.3(intonational)-250.9(meanings)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 137.46 Tm [(An)10(y)-261(attempt)-261(to)-261(reduce)-271(CIs)-281(to)-261(intonational)-250.9(meaning)-261(w)10(ould)-261(commit)-250.9(a)-281(fundamental)]TJ T* [(mistak)10(e:)-532(intonational)-351.3(meaning)-361.4(is)-361.3(not)-361.3(a)-371.4(kind)-361.4(of)-371.4(meaning)-361.4(lik)10(e)-361.4(presupposition)-351.3(or)]TJ 15.7488 -2.7804 TD (14)Tj ET endstream endobj 58 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 60 0 obj << /Length 6915 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(con)40.1(v)10(ersational)-180.7(implicature,)-190.7(b)20.1(u)0(t)-190.7(rather)-200.8(a)-200.8(means)-190.7(for)-200.8(in)40.2(v)20.1(oking)-180.7(additional)-180.7(non-at-issue)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(content.)-582.2(Such)-351.3(content)-341.3(can)-341.3(yield)-341.3(con)40.2(v)10(ersational)-331.2(implicatures)-331.2(\(focus)-341.3(on)-341.3(a)-351.3(phrase)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(can)-261(suggest)-240.9(the)-261(f)10(alsity)-250.9(or)-250.9(irrele)20.1(v)20.1(ance)-250.9(of)-261(alternati)20.1(v)10(es\).)-321.2(It)-250.9(can)-261(yield)-250.9(presuppositions)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(\(perhaps)-271(in)-261(interactions)-261(with)-261(additi)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(modi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.2152 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ers)-261(lik)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 3.1875 0 TD (too)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.2778 0 TD [(;)-271(Heim)-261(1992\).)-371.4(And)-261(it)-261(can)]TJ -22.2367 -1.2045 TD [(lead)-190.7(to)-190.7(CIs.)-291.1(In)-200.8(the)-190.7(analysis)-180.7(de)20.1(v)10(eloped)-180.7(belo)20.1(w)60.2(,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.6677 0 TD [(comma)-190.7(intonation)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.3609 0 TD [(plays)-190.7(a)-190.7(central)-200.8(role)]TJ -25.0286 -1.2145 TD [(in)-311.2(the)-321.2(CI-based)-331.2(analysis)-311.2(of)-311.2(N)30.1(As.)-522(The)-311.2(initial)-311.2(sentences)-321.2(in)-311.2(\(20a\))-321.2(and)-321.2(\(20b\))-321.2(dif)20.1(fer)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD (super)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 2.166 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cially)-271(only)-271(with)-271(re)10(gard)-271(to)-281(comma)-271(intonation.)-371.4(The)-281.1(continuations)-261(sho)20.1(w)-261(that)]TJ -2.7222 -1.2145 TD [(the)10(y)-240.9(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(a)-250.9(contrasting)-240.9(semantics.)]TJ 0 -1.6863 TD [(\(20\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Armstrong,)-271(the)-281(c)10(yclist,)-271(is)-271(from)-281(T)70.3(e)10(xas.)]TJ 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 360 537.1801 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 365.04 532.86 Tm [(Armstrong,)-271(the)-271(astronaut,)-281(is)]TJ -16.05 -1.2045 TD [(from)-250.9(Ohio.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5056 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Armstrong)-190.7(the)-200.8(c)10(yclist)-200.8(is)-190.7(from)-200.8(T)70.3(e)10(xas.)-291.1(Armstrong)-190.7(the)-200.8(astronaut)-200.8(is)-200.7(from)]TJ 2.148 -1.2145 TD (Ohio.)Tj -5.2095 -1.6863 TD [(Speak)10(ers)-200.7(reliably)-180.7(indicate)-190.7(the)-190.7(comma)-190.7(intonation)-170.6(with)-190.7(dashes,)-200.7(parentheses,)-200.7(or)-190.7(com-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(mas.)-291.1(In)-230.9(speech,)-240.9(we)-230.9(get)-220.8(clear)-240.9(intonational-phrase)-210.8(boundary)-220.8(marks)-230.9(on)-220.8(either)-230.9(side)-230.9(of)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(the)-311.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(.)-471.8(This)-301.1(holds)-301.1(for)-311.2(a)-311.2(wide)-311.2(v)20.1(ariety)-311.2(of)-311.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(and)-311.2(parenthetical)-311.2(e)10(x)0(-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(pressions)-250.9(that)-261(are)-281(pro)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 8.5684 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(tably)-261(analyzed)-271(as)-261(CI)-281(contrib)20.1(utors.)-341.3(Huddleston)-250.9(and)-271(Pullum)]TJ -9.1245 -1.2145 TD [(\(2002:�16\))-240.9(use)-250.9(the)-250.9(term)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.8248 0 TD [(inte)40.2(gr)10(ated)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.3211 0 TD [(for)-250.9(constructions)-240.9(lik)10(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.7308 0 TD [(Armstr)40.1(ong)-230.9(the)-250.9(cyclist)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.7568 0 TD (in)Tj -31.6335 -1.2045 TD [(\(20b\).)-301.1(My)-230.9(proposal)-230.9(is)-230.9(that)-240.9(N)30.1(As,)-230.9(b)20.1(u)0(t)-230.9(not)-230.9(inte)10(grated)-230.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(es,)-210.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(a)-240.9(special)-240.9(fea-)]TJ T* (ture)Tj 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 132.2265 379.14 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 174.5876 379.14 Tm 0 Tc [(that)-210.8(can)-220.8(appear)-220.8(in)-210.8(syntactic)-210.8(structures.)-291.1(The)-210.8(semantics)-210.8(for)-220.8(this)-200.7(feature)]TJ -5.3289 -1.2145 TD [(shift)-240.9(at-issue)-240.9(content)-240.9(to)-250.9(CI)-250.9(content.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 330.06 Tm [(3.4)-995.4(CIs)-242.6(vs.)-242.6(at-issue)-242.6(meanings)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 307.5 Tm [(Clause)-281(\(1d\))-271(says,)-281(in)-271(no)-271(uncertain)-281(terms,)-271(that)-271(CIs)-281.1(are)-281(distinct)-261(from)-281(at-issue)-271(mean-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(ings)-371.4(\(Grice�)50.2(s)-371.4(�what)-381.4(is)-371.4(said)-371.4(\(in)-381.4(the)-371.4(f)10(a)20.1(v)20.1(ored)-381.4(sense\)�\).)-702.6(The)-371.4(abo)10(v)10(e)-371.4(sections)-371.4(sho)20.1(w)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(that)-261(that)-250.9(clause)-271(has)-261(bite:)-321.2(N)30.1(A)0(s)-261(are)-271(in)40.1(v)20.1(ariant)-250.9(under)-261(presupposition)-240.9(holes)-261(and)-261(plugs,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(whereas)-250.9(at-issue)-240.9(content)-250.9(is)-240.9(highly)-230.9(sensiti)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(to)-240.9(such)-250.9(operators.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Clause)-230.9(\(1c\))-240.9(entails)-220.8(an)-230.9(additional)-210.8(split.)-291.1(A)-230.9(rigid)-220.8(interpretation)-220.8(of)-230.9(this)-220.8(clause)-230.9(\(the)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(one)-271(I)-271(adopt\))-271(means)-271(that)-261(a)-281(C)0(I)-271(i)0(s)-271(n)0(e)20.1(v)10(er)-271(relati)20.1(vized)-261(to)-261(the)-271(beliefs)-271(of)-271(an)10(y)-271(entity)-261(other)]TJ T* [(than)-321.2(the)-331.2(speak)10(er)50.2(.)-542(But)-331.2(at-issue)-321.2(content)-321.2(certainly)-331.2(is;)-351.3(in)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 22.0323 0 TD [(Sue)-321.2(wr)40.1(ongly)-321.2(belie)10(ves)-331.2(that)]TJ -22.0323 -1.2145 TD [(it)-301.1(is)-311.2(r)10(aining)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.7697 0 TD [(,)-311.2(the)-301.1(at-issue)-311.2(proposition)-291.1(that)-311.2(it)-301.1(is)-311.2(raining)-301.1(is)-311.2(asserted)-311.2(to)-311.2(hold)-301.1(only)-301.1(in)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf -4.7697 -1.2045 TD [(Sue�)40.2(s)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.3668 0 TD [(belief)-240.9(w)10(orlds.)-301.1(Thus,)-230.9(this)-230.9(embedded)-240.9(proposition)-220.8(is)-240.9(not)-240.9(speak)10(er)20.1(-oriented,)-240.9(and)]TJ -2.3668 -1.2145 TD [(hence)-301.1(not)-291.1(classi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.4233 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(able)-301.1(as)-291.1(a)-301.1(C)0(I)-311.2(contrib)20.1(ution,)-291.1(by)-291.1(\(1c\).)-461.7(W)80.3(e)0(�)50.2(v)10(e)-301.1(already)-301.1(seen)-301.1(cases)-301.1(in)]TJ -6.9794 -1.2045 TD [(which)-230.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-220.8(are)-240.9(inside)-220.8(indirect)-230.9(quotations)-210.8(and)-230.9(yet)-230.9(interpreted)-230.9(relati)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(to)-230.9(the)-230.9(beliefs)]TJ T* [(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(speak)10(er)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(utterance.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(Ho)20.1(we)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)-250.9(CI)-271(and)-261(at-issue)-250.9(content)-250.9(are)-271(united)-250.9(in)-261(one)-250.9(fundamental)-261(respect:)-331.2(both)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(are)-250.9(species)-240.9(of)-240.9(entailment.)-291.1(Hence,)-250.9(it)-230.9(might)-230.9(seem)-240.9(initially)-220.8(desirable)-240.9(to)-240.9(treat)-240.9(them)-240.9(as)]TJ 15.7488 -2.4993 TD (15)Tj ET endstream endobj 61 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 63 0 obj << /Length 9594 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(one.)-381.4(In)-271(section)-271(2,)-271(I)-281(e)10(xplored)-261(and)-281(rejected)-271(a)-281(syntactic)-261(alternati)20.1(v)10(e)-261(that)-271(could)-271(f)10(acili-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(tate)-271(this)-271(reduction.)-391.5(In)-281(section)-271(6,)-281(I)-281(outline)-261(a)-281(scope-shifting)-261(approach)-281(that)-271(in)40.1(v)20.1(olv)10(es)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(only)-281.1(at-issue)-291.1(meanings.)-431.6(When)-301.1(fully)-281(articulated,)-301.1(such)-291.1(an)-301.1(approach)-291.1(duplicates)-291.1(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(main)-240.9(features)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(CI-based)-250.9(analysis)-240.9(re)20.1(vie)20.1(wed)-240.9(in)-250.9(the)-240.9(ne)10(xt)-240.9(tw)10(o)-250.9(sections.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 570.0601 Tm [(4)-996.8(A)-244(CI)-250.9(logic)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 543.3 Tm [(Most)-210.8(past)-230.9(proposals)-210.8(for)-230.9(CIs)-230.9(do)-230.9(not)-220.8(of)20.1(fer)-230.9(a)-220.8(formalism)-220.8(for)-230.9(talking)-210.8(about)-220.8(such)-230.9(mean-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ings.)-291.1(W)40.1(ith)-220.8(�con)40.1(v)10(entional)-210.8(implicature�)-220.8(often)-220.8(merely)-230.9(a)-230.9(label,)-220.8(it)-230.9(is)-220.8(not)-220.8(surprising)-210.8(that)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(man)10(y)-250.9(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(turned)-261(to)-250.9(more)-261(f)10(amiliar)-250.9(concepts)-261(in)-261(handling)-240.9(them.)-341.3(This)-250.9(section)-250.9(tak)10(es)]TJ T* [(the)-291.1(step)-291.1(of)-291.1(formulating)-281.1(a)-301.1(description)-281(logic)-281(for)-301.1(natural)-291.1(language)-291.1(e)10(xpressions)-281.1(with)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(CI)-351.3(dimensions.)-572.1(The)-341.3(approach)-351.3(is)-341.3(based)-341.3(on)-341.3(that)-341.3(of)-341.3(Karttunen)-341.3(and)-341.3(Peters)-351.3(\(1979\),)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(though)-230.9(I)-261(apply)-240.9(their)-240.9(proposal)-240.9(to)-250.9(a)-250.9(much)-240.9(dif)20.1(ferent)-250.9(f)10(actual)-250.9(domain.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(A)-281(major)-281.1(inno)10(v)20.1(ation)-261(of)-281.1(Karttunen)-281(and)-281(Peters)-291.1(\(1979\))-281(is)-281.1(that)-281(meaning)-271(language)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(terms)-361.4(are)-371.4(mark)10(ed)-361.4(as)-371.4(either)-361.4(at-issue)-361.3(or)-361.3(CI)-381.4(\(their)-361.4(�e)10(xtensional�)-351.3(and)-371.4(�implicature�)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(meanings,)-220.8(respecti)20.1(v)10(ely\).)-281(I)-230.9(implement)-210.8(the)-230.9(distinction)-200.7(via)-230.9(the)-230.9(set)-220.8(of)-230.9(types)-220.8(in)-220.8(\(21\).)-301.1(\(I)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(pro)10(vide)-240.9(intensional)-230.9(types)-240.9(b)20.1(u)0(t)-240.9(w)10(ork)-250.9(almost)-230.9(e)10(xclusi)20.1(v)10(ely)-230.9(with)-240.9(e)10(xtensional)-230.9(ones.\))]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(21\))-2529.5(i.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 5.2051 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 178.44 393.18 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 183.48 388.86 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4809 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 193.44 393.18 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 198.24 388.86 Tm [(,)-250.9(and)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 2.1957 0 TD (s)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 229.2 393.18 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 237.12 388.86 Tm [(are)-261(basic)-240.9(at-issue)-240.9(types.)]TJ -6.6448 -1.6261 TD (ii.)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.2875 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 178.44 373.74 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 183 369.42 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4809 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 192.96 373.74 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 197.28 369.42 Tm [(,)-250.9(and)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 2.1857 0 TD (s)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 228.12 373.74 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 235.56 369.42 Tm [(are)-261(basic)-250.9(CI)-250.9(types.)]TJ -6.7954 -1.6261 TD [(iii.)-481.8(If)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 183.9957 349.98 Tm <006f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 193.2036 349.98 Tm (and)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 213.4651 349.98 Tm <006d>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 224.9943 349.98 Tm [(are)-250.9(at-issue)-250.9(types,)-240.9(then)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 9.3416 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 341.3545 349.98 Tm <006f>Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 347.5624 349.98 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 352.2423 349.98 Tm <006d>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 360.7716 349.98 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6324 0 TD [(is)-240.9(an)-250.9(at-issue)-250.9(type.)]TJ -17.7506 -1.6261 TD -0.0201 Tc [(iv)40.1(.)-491.9(I)-20.1(f)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 184.0502 330.54 Tm 0 Tc <006f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 193.2581 330.54 Tm [(is)-250.9(an)-250.9(at-issue)-240.9(type)-240.9(and)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 301.6397 330.54 Tm <006d>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 313.169 330.54 Tm [(is)-240.9(a)-250.9(C)0(I)-261(type,)-240.9(then)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 7.0488 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 402.1191 330.54 Tm <006f>Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 408.327 330.54 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 413.007 330.54 Tm <006d>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 421.5363 330.54 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6324 0 TD [(is)-240.9(a)-250.9(C)0(I)-261(type.)]TJ -22.5824 -1.6261 TD [(v)60.2(.)-481.8(The)-250.9(full)-240.9(set)-250.9(of)-250.9(types)-240.9(is)-240.9(the)-250.9(union)-240.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(at-issue)-250.9(and)-240.9(CI)-261(types.)]TJ -4.0351 -2.0376 TD [(I)-210.8(assume)-200.8(that)-210.8(the)-210.8(types)-200.7(serv)10(e)-210.8(t)0(o)-200.8(o)0(r)20.1(ganize)-210.8(the)-210.8(terms)-200.7(of)-210.8(the)-210.8(meaning)-200.7(language.)-291.1(Thus,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(type)-271(distinctions)-250.9(need)-281(not)-271(re)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 11.3494 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ect)-281.1(model-theoretic)-271(distinctions.)-361.4(F)10(o)0(r)-271(this)-271(paper)40.1(,)-281(w)0(e)]TJ -11.9056 -1.2145 TD [(can)-271(assume)-271(that)-271(for)-281.1(an)10(y)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 227.8726 257.82 Tm <006f>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 236.9605 257.82 Tm 0.2367 Tc ({)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.4052 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4338 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3481 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (s)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3892 0 TD (})Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5019 0 TD [(,)-261(the)-271(types)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 335.3099 257.82 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 341.88 262.14 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 350.16 257.82 Tm (and)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 370.6614 257.82 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 376.92 262.14 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 384.72 257.82 Tm [(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-271(the)-271(same)-271(domains,)]TJ -22.9056 -1.2045 TD [(and)-311.2(that)-301.1(for)-321.2(an)10(y)-301.1(types)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 220.8652 243.42 Tm <006d>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 233.1145 243.42 Tm (and)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 254.0959 243.42 Tm <006c>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 261.6172 243.42 Tm 0.3212 Tc [(,i)321.2(f)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 1.4932 0 TD 0 Tc ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 284.1486 243.42 Tm <006d>Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 292.6779 243.42 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 297.3579 243.42 Tm <006c>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 304.8792 243.42 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6926 0 TD [(is)-311.2(a)-311.2(type,)-321.2(then)-311.2(the)-311.2(domain)-301.1(of)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 12.0365 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 461.7379 243.42 Tm <006d>Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 470.2672 243.42 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 474.9471 243.42 Tm <006c>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 482.4684 243.42 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6926 0 TD (is)Tj -31.7744 -1.2045 TD [(the)-351.3(class)-361.4(of)-361.4(functions)-351.3(from)-351.3(the)-361.4(domain)-351.3(of)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 320.9193 229.02 Tm <006d>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 333.6486 229.02 Tm [(to)-361.4(the)-351.3(domain)-351.3(of)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 420.4115 229.02 Tm <006c>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 427.9329 229.02 Tm [(.)-642.4(This)-351.3(syntac-)]TJ -26.5202 -1.2145 TD [(tic)-321.2(conception)-321.2(of)-321.2(types)-321.2(is)-321.2(rare)-341.3(in)-321.2(linguistics,)-321.2(where)-331.2(types)-321.2(more)-321.2(often)-321.2(serv)10(e)-331.2(only)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(to)-331.2(or)20.1(ganize)-331.2(the)-331.2(interpreted)-331.2(structure)-331.2(\(Montague,)-331.2(1970;)-321.2(Halv)20.1(orsen)-331.2(and)-331.2(Ladusa)10(w)60.2(,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(1979\).)-411.5(But)-291.1(the)-281.1(job)-281(that)-281.1(the)10(y)-271(perform)-291.1(in)-281(the)-281.1(present)-291.1(paper)-281.1(is)-281(f)10(amiliar)50.2(.)-411.5(The)10(y)-281.1(serv)10(e)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(roughly)-210.8(the)-220.8(same)-230.9(purpose)-220.8(as)-220.8(syntactic)-220.8(cate)10(gories)-220.8(lik)10(e)-210.8(N)-230.9(and)-220.8(V)130.5(,)-230.9(which)-220.8(or)20.1(ganize)-220.8(the)]TJ T* [(natural)-261(language)-271(le)10(xicon.)-351.3(And)-261(the)-261(relationship)-261(between)-261(the)-271(types)-261(and)-261(the)-271(models)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(resembles)-291.1(Montague�)50.2(s)-291.1(\(1973\))-291.1(decision)-291.1(to)-301.1(assign)-291.1(dif)20.1(ferent)-301.1(syntactic)-291.1(cate)10(gories)-291.1(to)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(common)-200.8(nouns)-200.7(\()]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 6.6031 0 TD (t)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3481 0 TD -0.1085 Tc (//)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.8933 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD [(\))-200.8(and)-210.8(intransiti)20.1(v)10(e)-190.7(v)10(erbs)-200.8(\()]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.5177 0 TD (t)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3481 0 TD (/)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5019 0 TD (e)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD [(\))-210.8(while)-200.8(gi)20.1(ving)-200.8(them)-200.8(the)-210.8(same)-210.8(type)]TJ -3.351 -3.1819 TD (16)Tj ET endstream endobj 64 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 67 0 obj << /Length 9143 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(of)-210.8(translation)-210.8(and)-210.8(models.)-291.1(In)-210.8(essence,)-230.9(I)-210.8(recruit)-220.8(the)-220.8(types)-200.8(to)-220.8(do)-210.8(w)10(ork)-210.8(often)-220.8(assigned)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(to)-240.9(a)-250.9(cate)10(gorial)-250.9(syntax.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(The)-391.5(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 2.89 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-371.4(is)-381.4(asymmetric)-381.4(in)-381.4(this)-371.4(important)-371.4(sense:)-582.2(we)-391.5(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-381.4(CI)-391.5(types)-381.4(in)]TJ -4.9116 -1.2045 TD [(which)-321.2(the)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.318 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst)-331.2(member)-331.2(is)-321.2(an)-331.2(at-issue)-331.2(type)-321.2(and)-331.2(the)-331.2(second)-331.2(is)-321.2(an)-331.2(CI)-341.3(type.)-552.1(These)]TJ -4.8741 -1.2045 TD [(correspond)-361.4(to)-361.3(the)-361.4(intuition)-351.3(that)-361.4(CIs)-371.4(are)-371.4(comments)-351.3(upon)-361.4(the)-361.3(at-issue)-361.4(core:)-542(in)-361.4(a)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(sense,)-261(the)10(y)-261(borro)20.1(w)-261(from)-261(the)-261(at-issue)-261(dimension.)-331.2(But)-271(we)-271(do)-261(not)-250.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-271(an)10(y)-250.9(types)-261(in)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(which)-250.9(the)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.1774 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst)-261(member)-250.9(is)-261(a)-261(C)0(I)-261(and)-261(the)-261(second)-250.9(an)-261(at-issue)-261(type.)-331.2(This)-250.9(w)10(ould)-250.9(result)]TJ -4.7336 -1.2145 TD [(in)-291.1(an)-301.1(at-issue)-301.1(composition)-281(that)-291.1(incorporated)-301.1(CI)-301.1(content,)-311.2(violating)-281.1(condition)-291.1(\(1d\))]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 3.4904 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-240.9(of)-250.9(CIs.)]TJ -2.581 -1.2045 TD [(The)-291.1(pair)-281.1(in)-291.1(\(22\))-281(helps)-291.1(indicate)-281.1(why)-281(the)-281(distinction)-271(we)-281(are)-301.1(after)-291.1(is)-281.1(not)-281.1(model-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD (theoretic.)Tj 0 -1.9473 TD [(\(22\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Lance,)-250.9(a)-261(c)10(yclist,)-230.9(is)-240.9(from)-250.9(T)70.3(e)10(xas.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.596 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Lance,)-250.9(a)-261(T)70.3(e)10(xan,)-240.9(is)-240.9(a)-250.9(c)10(yclist)]TJ -3.0614 -1.9473 TD [(In)-250.9(\(22a\),)-261(the)-250.9(proposition)-230.9(that)-250.9(Lance)-250.9(is)-250.9(a)-250.9(c)10(yclist)-240.9(is)-250.9(e)10(xpressed)-250.9(as)-250.9(a)-261(CI.)-250.9(In)-261(\(22b\),)-250.9(this)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(same)-291.1(proposition)-281(is)-301.1(e)10(xpressed)-291.1(as)-301.1(an)-301.1(at-issue)-291.1(entailment.)-451.7(It)-301.1(seems)-291.1(a)-301.1(confusion)-291.1(to)]TJ T* [(treat)-311.2(these)-311.2(propositions)-291.1(as)-311.2(model-theoretically)-291.1(distinct.)-481.8(F)10(o)0(r)-311.2(instance,)-331.2(CI)-311.2(content)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(is)-341.3(as)-351.3(capable)-341.3(as)-351.3(at-issue)-341.3(content)-341.3(of)-351.3(serving)-341.3(as)-341.3(the)-351.3(antecedent)-341.3(for)-351.3(intersentential)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(anaphoric)-271(dependencies)-281(lik)10(e)-271(v)10(erb-phrase)-281.1(ellipsis,)-271(v)10(erb-phrase)-271(and)-281.1(sentential)-271(pro-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(forms,)-371.4(and)-351.3(presuppositions)-331.2(\(which)-351.3(are)-361.4(anaphoric)-351.3(in)-351.3(the)-351.3(sense)-351.3(of)-351.3(v)20.1(a)0(n)-351.3(der)-361.4(Sandt)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(1992\).)-321.2(Similarly)60.2(,)-250.9(since)-250.9(no)-250.9(at-issue)-250.9(operators)-261(tak)10(e)-250.9(scope)-261(o)10(v)10(e)0(r)-250.9(them,)-250.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-250.9(are)-261(often)]TJ T* [(able)-311.2(to)-301.1(establish)-301.1(discourse)-301.1(referents.)-501.9(Once)-311.2(we)-311.2(get)-311.2(be)10(yond)-301.1(the)-301.1(internal)-311.2(composi-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(tion)-271(of)-291.1(sentences)-281.1(and)-281(consider)-281(only)-281.1(the)-281.1(conte)10(xt,)-281(the)-281.1(line)-281(between)-281.1(at-issue)-281(and)-281(CI)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(content)-240.9(disappears.)-301.1(This)-240.9(is)-250.9(e)10(xpected)-240.9(if)-250.9(the)10(y)-240.9(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(the)-250.9(same)-250.9(models.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(The)-371.4(adv)20.1(antage)-361.3(the)-361.3(types)-361.3(bring)-361.3(is)-371.4(that)-361.3(the)10(y)-361.3(r)0(e)10(gulate)-361.4(composition)-341.3(via)-361.4(the)-371.4(set)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(of)-311.2(well-formed)-301.1(lambda)-301.1(terms.)-481.8(The)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.4515 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst)-311.2(tree)-311.2(in)-311.2(\(23\))-311.2(is)-301.1(well)-311.2(formed,)-321.2(whereas)-311.2(the)]TJ -15.0076 -1.2045 TD [(second)-240.9(is)-250.9(not.)]TJ 0 -1.9473 TD [(\(23\))-1395.2(a.)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 229.5726 247.5 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 237.5739 247.5 Tm (x)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(belie)10(v)10(e)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 2.9233 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6655 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (lance)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2217 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6022 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 392.76 251.82 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 397.68 247.5 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 406.32 251.82 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 411.12 247.5 Tm ()Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 322.68 239.82 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.8311 -0.1445 TD ( )Tj -6.8295 0.9756 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.8311 -0.1445 TD (\012)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.16 215.58 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 182.0013 215.58 Tm (p)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 187.9789 215.58 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 195.9802 215.58 Tm (x)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(belie)10(v)10(e)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 2.9233 0 TD (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4617 0 TD (p)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 289.08 219.9 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 293.88 215.58 Tm (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 308.52 219.9 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 313.44 215.58 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 322.08 219.9 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 326.88 215.58 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.7766 0 TD 0 Tc (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6655 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (lance)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2217 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4685 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 428.4 219.9 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 147.48 190.02 Tm [(b)40.1(.)-11964.7(unde)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.6184 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (ned)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 322.56 182.46 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.8191 -0.1445 TD ( )Tj -6.8175 0.9756 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.8191 -0.1445 TD (\012)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.16 158.22 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 182.0013 158.22 Tm (p)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 187.9789 158.22 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 195.9802 158.22 Tm (x)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(belie)10(v)10(e)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 2.9233 0 TD (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4617 0 TD (p)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 289.08 162.54 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 293.88 158.22 Tm (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 308.52 162.54 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 313.44 158.22 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 322.08 162.54 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 326.88 158.22 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.7766 0 TD 0 Tc (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6655 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (lance)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.2217 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4685 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 428.4 162.54 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 134.1 Tm [(T)30.1(ree)-210.8(\(23b\))-220.8(suf)20.1(fers)-210.8(a)-210.8(type)-210.8(mismatch:)-281(the)-210.8(functor)-210.8(is)-210.8(of)-210.8(a)-220.8(type)-210.8(that)-210.8(requires)-210.8(a)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 29.1812 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 464.4 138.42 Tm (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 471.84 134.1 Tm (input.)Tj -30.1928 -1.2045 TD [(It)-250.9(is)-240.9(of)20.1(fered)-250.9(only)-240.9(a)-250.9(type)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.5533 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 229.44 124.02 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 236.76 119.7 Tm (input.)Tj 5.2195 -2.4993 TD (17)Tj ET endstream endobj 68 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 70 0 obj << /Length 7918 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 128.4 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(The)-431.6(type-mismatch)-401.5(in)-421.6(\(23b\))-421.6(represents)-431.6(a)-431.6(desirable)-421.6(gap)-421.6(in)-421.6(the)-421.6(type-logical)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(space)-351.3(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 3.5159 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-351.3(in)-341.3(\(21\).)-602.3(The)-351.3(functor)-341.3(is)-341.3(an)-351.3(appropriate)-351.3(e)10(xtensional)-331.2(meaning)-341.3(for)-341.3(a)]TJ -4.072 -1.2145 TD [(propositional)-321.2(attitude)-331.2(v)10(erb)40.1(.)-592.2(The)-351.3(CI)-351.3(proposition)-321.2(in)-341.3(its)-341.3(complement)-331.2(cannot)-341.3(serv)10(e)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(as)-291.1(its)-271(ar)20.1(gument.)-421.6(Moreo)10(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)-291.1(we)-291.1(cannot)-281(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(propositional)-271(attitude)-271(v)10(erb)-291.1(meanings)]TJ T* [(that)-291.1(tak)10(e)-301.1(C)0(I)-301.1(meanings)-281(as)-301.1(their)-291.1(ar)20.1(guments.)-451.7(Such)-291.1(a)-301.1(v)10(erb)-301.1(w)10(ould)-281.1(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-301.1(to)-291.1(be)-291.1(of)-301.1(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 0 -1.2145 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 119.52 586.26 Tm (c)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 123.84 581.9401 Tm (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 138.48 586.26 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 143.4 581.9401 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 152.04 586.26 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 156.84 581.9401 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc [(,)-291.1(that)-281(is,)-281(it)-281(w)10(ould)-281.1(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(to)-281.1(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-281.1(an)-291.1(initial)-271(member)-281.1(of)-281(CI)-291.1(type)-291.1(b)20.1(u)0(t)-271(itself)]TJ -4.6273 -1.2045 TD [(be)-281(of)-281.1(at-issue)-271(type.)-391.5(Such)-291.1(types)-271(are)-291.1(not)-271(in)-271(the)-281.1(set)-281.1(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 20.6487 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ned)-281.1(in)-271(\(21\).)-401.5(Analogous)-271(rea-)]TJ -21.2048 -1.2145 TD [(soning)-210.8(applies)-220.8(to)-220.8(ne)10(gation,)-210.8(conditionals,)-210.8(modals,)-220.8(and)-220.8(the)-220.8(lik)10(e.)-301.1(This)-210.8(is)-220.8(the)-230.9(basis)-210.8(for)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-311.2(e)10(xplanation)-291.1(for)-311.2(why)-301.1(CIs)-321.2(ne)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-301.1(form)-311.2(part)-311.2(of)-311.2(the)-311.2(ar)20.1(gument)-311.2(to)-301.1(these)-311.2(operators.)]TJ T* [(W)80.3(e)-230.9(also)-220.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(an)-230.9(e)10(xplanation)-210.8(for)-230.9(why)-220.8(CI)-230.9(operators)-230.9(ne)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)-220.8(tak)10(e)-220.8(C)0(I)-240.9(meanings)-210.8(as)-230.9(their)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(ar)20.1(guments.)-642.4(F)10(o)0(r)-361.4(instance,)-381.4(in)-361.3(\(24\),)-391.5(the)-361.3(a)20.1(v)20.1(ailable)-351.3(reading)-361.3(of)-371.4(the)]TJ 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 419.1221 509.7 Tm (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 433.3682 509.7 Tm (-parenthetical)Tj -26.9748 -1.2045 TD [(\(ar)20.1(gued)-250.9(in)-250.9(Potts)-240.9(2002b)-240.9(to)-240.9(be)-250.9(a)-250.9(C)0(I)-261(construction\))-230.9(ignores)-250.9(the)-240.9(content)-250.9(of)-240.9(the)-250.9(N)30.1(A)0(.)]TJ 0 -2.0476 TD [(\(24\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(As)-361.4(Sue)-361.4(said,)-381.4(Lance)-371.4(Armstrong,)-371.4(a)-361.4(cancer)-371.4(survi)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)40.2(,)-371.4(w)10(o)0(n)-361.4(this)-351.3(year�)50.2(s)]TJ 5.2095 -1.2045 TD [(T)80.3(our)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.1264 436.98 Tm 0 Tc (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 187.3725 436.98 Tm (-parenthetical)Tj /F4 1 Tf 5.8077 0 TD (=)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.1041 0 TD [(Sue)-321.2(said)-321.2(that)-311.2(Lance)-321.2(Armstrong)-311.2(w)10(o)0(n)-321.2(this)-311.2(year�)50.2(s)]TJ -8.1007 -1.2045 TD [(T)80.3(our)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD (c.)Tj 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.175 403.14 Tm (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 187.4212 403.14 Tm (-parenthetical)Tj /F1 1 Tf 5.8077 0 TD ()Tj /F4 1 Tf T* (=)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0941 0 TD [(Sue)-321.2(said)-311.2(that)-321.2(Lance)-321.2(Armstrong)-301.1(is)-311.2(a)-321.2(cancer)-331.2(sur)20.1(-)]TJ -8.0947 -1.2045 TD -0.0201 Tc [(v)-20.1(ivo)-20.1(r)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD 0 Tc (d.)Tj 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 173.1264 369.3 Tm (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 187.3725 369.3 Tm (-parenthetical)Tj /F1 1 Tf 5.8077 0 TD ()Tj /F4 1 Tf T* (=)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0941 0 TD [(Sue)-321.2(said)-311.2(that)-321.2(Lance)-321.2(Armstrong)-301.1(is)-311.2(a)-321.2(cancer)-331.2(sur)20.1(-)]TJ -8.0906 -1.2145 TD [(vi)20.1(v)20.1(o)0(r)-240.9(and)-250.9(that)-240.9(he)-250.9(w)10(o)0(n)-250.9(this)-230.9(year�)50.2(s)-250.9(T)80.3(our)50.2(.)]TJ -5.2095 -2.0376 TD [(Kratzer)-351.3(\(1999\))-351.3(mak)10(es)-341.3(similar)-331.2(observ)20.1(ations)-331.2(about)-341.3(the)-351.3(interaction)-341.3(of)-341.3(the)-351.3(German)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(discourse)-180.7(particle)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.1463 0 TD (ja)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7778 0 TD [(,)-200.8(which)-180.7(means)-190.7(something)-170.6(lik)10(e)-180.7(�as)-200.8(you)-180.7(probably)-180.7(kno)20.1(w�,)-200.7(and)-180.7(ep-)]TJ -7.9241 -1.2045 TD (ithets:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 2.7455 0 TD (ja)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0288 0 TD [(ignores)-240.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(epithets)-240.9(that)-250.9(appear)-261(to)-250.9(be)-250.9(in)-250.9(its)-240.9(scope.)-321.2(On)-250.9(the)-250.9(present)]TJ -3.7742 -1.2045 TD [(approach,)-281(this)-261(is)-261(the)-271(beha)20.1(vior)-271(we)-281.1(e)10(xpect.)-371.4(W)80.3(e)-271(do)-271(not)-271(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-271(an)10(y)-261(types)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 27.3428 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 442.4479 287.1 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 451.44 291.42 Tm (c)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 455.76 287.1 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 460.4399 287.1 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 466.68 291.42 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 471.12 287.1 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(,)-281(and)]TJ -30.524 -1.2145 TD [(hence)-250.9(no)-250.9(w)10(a)0(y)-240.9(t)0(o)-250.9(allo)20.1(w)-240.9(such)-240.9(combination)-230.9(schemes.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(The)-321.2(remaining)-301.1(logical)-311.2(issue)-311.2(I)-321.2(address)-311.2(here)-331.2(is)-311.2(the)-311.2(nature)-321.2(of)-311.2(semantic)-311.2(compo-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(sition.)-491.8(I)-321.2(state)-311.2(the)-311.2(composition)-291.1(principles)-311.2(as)-311.2(tree-admissibility)-291.1(conditions,)-311.2(which)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(place)-331.2(restrictions)-311.2(on)-331.2(singly-rooted)-311.2(trees)-321.2(with)-321.2(a)-331.2(branching)-321.2(f)10(actor)-331.2(of)-331.2(at)-331.2(most)-311.2(tw)10(o.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(These)-220.8(structures)-230.9(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(a)-230.9(dominance)-220.8(relation,)-220.8(b)20.1(u)0(t)-220.8(n)0(o)-230.9(linear)-220.8(precedence)-240.9(relation.)-291.1(W)80.3(e)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(can)-210.8(associate)-200.8(the)-200.7(semantic)-200.8(predictions)-190.7(of)-200.8(the)-200.8(theory)-210.8(with)-190.7(the)-200.7(set)-210.8(of)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 26.1881 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nite)-200.7(parsetrees)]TJ -26.7442 -1.2045 TD [(consisting)-230.9(only)-240.9(of)-250.9(subtrees)-240.9(licensed)-250.9(by)-240.9(the)-250.9(conditions)-230.9(in)-240.9(\(25\),)-250.9(\(26\),)-250.9(\(27\),)-250.9(and)-250.9(\(35\))]TJ T* [(belo)20.1(w)60.2(,)-301.1(along)-291.1(with)-301.1(a)-301.1(condition)-291.1(that)-291.1(says)-301.1(a)-311.2(single-node)-291.1(tree)-301.1(decorated)-311.2(only)-291.1(with)-291.1(a)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(le)10(xical)-240.9(meaning)-240.9(is)-240.9(well-formed.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(F)10(o)0(r)-341.3(at-issue)-341.3(composition,)-341.3(I)-341.3(adopt)-331.2(the)-341.3(rule)-341.3(in)-341.3(\(25\),)-361.3(which)-341.3(is)-331.2(a)-351.3(v)10(ersion)-331.2(of)-341.3(the)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(rule)-321.2(for)-321.2(functional)-301.1(application)-311.2(of)-321.2(sisters)-311.2(of)-321.2(Klein)-311.2(and)-321.2(Sag)-321.2(\(1985:171\))-311.2(and)-311.2(Heim)]TJ 15.7488 -3.202 TD (18)Tj ET endstream endobj 71 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 73 0 obj << /Length 10812 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(and)-220.8(Kratzer)-230.9(\(1998:44\),)-220.8(b)20.1(u)0(t)-210.8(here)-230.9(stated)-220.8(o)10(v)10(e)0(r)-210.8(semantic)-220.8(parsetrees)-230.9(and)-220.8(with)-210.8(the)-220.8(spec-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD (i)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 0.2778 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cation)-240.9(that)-250.9(we)-250.9(are)-250.9(dealing)-240.9(only)-240.9(with)-250.9(terms)-240.9(of)-250.9(at-issue)-240.9(\(superscript)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 26.3588 0 TD (a)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD [(\))-250.9(type.)]TJ -27.6928 -2.0075 TD (\(25\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD [(at-issue)-250.9(application)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 198.36 595.5 Tm <005f>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 206.862 595.5 Tm (\()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 211.5419 595.5 Tm <0060>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 219.5433 595.5 Tm (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 232.7047 595.5 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 239.04 599.8201 Tm (a)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 221.28 589.14 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0 0 TD ()Tj -3.999 0.9997 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj -1.0118 -0.3252 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 153.36 569.58 Tm <005f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 164.622 569.58 Tm (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 175.2635 569.58 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 183.84 573.9 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 188.76 569.58 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 193.4399 569.58 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 199.68 573.9 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 204.6 569.58 Tm ()Tj -2.1982 -1.2145 TD (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 168 540.66 Tm <0061>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 176.6352 540.66 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 182.4767 540.66 Tm <006c>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 190.08 544.98 Tm (c)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 246.12 569.58 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 256.7613 569.58 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 262.6028 569.58 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 271.2 573.9 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 258.12 555.0601 Tm (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 246.96 540.66 Tm <0062>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 257.0675 540.66 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 262.9091 540.66 Tm <0070>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 270.72 544.98 Tm (c)Tj ET 1 g 1 i 164.002 543.401 m 164.002 550.918 166 552.916 181.326 552.916 c 196.651 552.916 198.649 550.918 198.649 543.401 c 198.649 535.885 196.651 533.887 181.326 533.887 c 166 533.887 164.002 535.885 164.002 543.401 c 166.002 535.887 29.149 13.532 re f 0 G 0 J 0 j 0.3 w 10 M [0.999 ]0 d 164.002 543.401 m 164.002 550.918 166 552.916 181.326 552.916 c 196.651 552.916 198.649 550.918 198.649 543.401 c 198.649 535.885 196.651 533.887 181.326 533.887 c 166 533.887 164.002 535.885 164.002 543.401 c S 242.962 545.021 m 242.962 551.585 244.96 553.583 261.191 553.583 c 277.421 553.583 279.419 551.585 279.419 545.021 c 279.419 538.456 277.421 536.458 261.191 536.458 c 244.96 536.458 242.962 538.456 242.962 545.021 c 244.962 538.458 30.959 11.627 re f 242.962 545.021 m 242.962 551.585 244.96 553.583 261.191 553.583 c 277.421 553.583 279.419 551.585 279.419 545.021 c 279.419 538.456 277.421 536.458 261.191 536.458 c 244.96 536.458 242.962 538.456 242.962 545.021 c S BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 517.6201 Tm 0 g [(As)-341.3(noted)-341.3(abo)10(v)10(e)0(,)-361.3(the)-351.3(terminal)-341.3(elements)-331.2(are)-361.4(not)-341.3(ordered)-351.3(by)-341.3(an)10(y)-341.3(linear)-351.3(adjacenc)10(y)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(relation.)-361.4(Here)-271(and)-271(in)-271(the)-261(statement)-261(of)-271(the)-271(other)-261(rules,)-271(I)-271(indicate)-271(optional)-250.9(material)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(inside)-230.9(dotted)-230.9(lines.)-301.1(The)-240.9(moti)20.1(v)20.1(ation)-210.8(for)-240.9(the)-240.9(optional)-230.9(material)-230.9(is)-240.9(that)-240.9(we)-240.9(must)-230.9(allo)20.1(w)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(that)-271(there)-281.1(might)-271(be)-281(CI)-281(content)-271(hanging)-271(around.)-401.5(The)-271(rule)-281(for)-281(parsetree)-291.1(interpreta-)]TJ T* [(tion,)-200.8(\(28\))-210.8(belo)20.1(w)60.2(,)-190.7(ensures)-210.8(that)-200.8(such)-200.8(material)-200.8(forms)-200.8(part)-200.8(of)-210.8(the)-200.8(o)10(v)10(erall)-190.7(interpretation.)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(But)-210.8(it)-210.8(is)-210.8(not)-210.8(rele)20.1(v)20.1(ant)-200.8(to)-210.8(the)-210.8(local)-220.8(calculations)-200.7(that)-210.8(these)-210.8(rules)-210.8(determine.)-291.1(The)-220.8(b)20.1(ullet)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7227 0 TD [(is)-230.9(a)-230.9(metalogical)-210.8(symbol)-210.8(for)-230.9(graphically)-220.8(separating)-230.9(independent)-210.8(lambda)-220.8(terms.)-301.1(It)]TJ -0.7227 -1.2145 TD [(has)-240.9(no)-250.9(interpretation.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(W)80.3(e)-250.9(come)-250.9(no)20.1(w)-240.9(t)0(o)-240.9(the)-250.9(central)-250.9(tree-admissibility)-220.8(condition,)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 22.8679 0 TD [(CI)-240.9(application)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 6.131 0 TD (:)Tj -30.4644 -2.0075 TD (\(26\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD [(CI)-240.9(application)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 205.8 357.78 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 216.4413 357.78 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 222.4029 357.78 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 231 362.1 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 217.92 343.38 Tm (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 198.24 328.86 Tm <005f>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 206.742 328.86 Tm (\()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 211.4219 328.86 Tm <0060>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 219.4233 328.86 Tm (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 232.5847 328.86 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 238.92 333.18 Tm (c)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 220.8 321.18 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj -3.9989 0.9997 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj -0.9877 -0.3373 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 153.36 301.62 Tm <005f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 164.622 301.62 Tm (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 175.2635 301.62 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 183.84 305.94 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 188.76 301.62 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 193.4399 301.62 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 199.68 305.94 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 204.12 301.62 Tm ()Tj -2.1781 -1.2045 TD (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 167.76 272.7 Tm <0061>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 176.2752 272.7 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 182.2367 272.7 Tm <006c>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 189.84 277.02 Tm (c)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 245.52 301.62 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 256.1613 301.62 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 262.1229 301.62 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 270.72 305.94 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 257.64 287.22 Tm (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 246.48 272.7 Tm <0062>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 256.4675 272.7 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 262.429 272.7 Tm <0070>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 270.24 277.02 Tm (c)Tj ET 1 g 163.762 275.442 m 163.762 282.958 165.76 284.956 181.086 284.956 c 196.411 284.956 198.409 282.958 198.409 275.442 c 198.409 267.925 196.411 265.927 181.086 265.927 c 165.76 265.927 163.762 267.925 163.762 275.442 c 165.762 267.927 29.149 13.531 re f 163.762 275.442 m 163.762 282.958 165.76 284.956 181.086 284.956 c 196.411 284.956 198.409 282.958 198.409 275.442 c 198.409 267.925 196.411 265.927 181.086 265.927 c 165.76 265.927 163.762 267.925 163.762 275.442 c S 242.482 277.061 m 242.482 283.625 244.48 285.623 260.711 285.623 c 276.941 285.623 278.939 283.625 278.939 277.061 c 278.939 270.496 276.941 268.498 260.711 268.498 c 244.48 268.498 242.482 270.496 242.482 277.061 c 244.482 270.498 30.959 11.627 re f 242.482 277.061 m 242.482 283.625 244.48 285.623 260.711 285.623 c 276.941 285.623 278.939 283.625 278.939 277.061 c 278.939 270.496 276.941 268.498 260.711 268.498 c 244.48 268.498 242.482 270.496 242.482 277.061 c S BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 249.66 Tm 0 g [(The)-210.8(action)-200.8(of)-210.8(\(26\))-210.8(is)-210.8(easy)-210.8(to)-210.8(describe:)-281.1(if)-210.8(a)-210.8(functional)-200.8(CI)-220.8(term)-210.8(is)-200.7(sister)-210.8(to)-200.7(an)-210.8(at-issue)]TJ T* [(term)-240.9(in)-240.9(its)-240.9(domain,)-230.9(then)-240.9(we)-250.9(apply)-240.9(that)-240.9(CI)-250.9(term)-250.9(to)-240.9(the)-240.9(at-issue)-240.9(term)-240.9(to)-240.9(yield)-240.9(part)-250.9(of)]TJ T* [(the)-200.7(v)20.1(alue)-190.7(of)-200.8(their)-200.7(mother)50.2(.)-281(But)-200.8(we)-210.8(also)-200.7(pass)-190.7(on)-200.8(to)-200.7(their)-200.8(mother)-190.7(the)-200.7(unmodi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 28.5998 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD [(ed)-190.7(v)20.1(alue)]TJ -29.1559 -1.2145 TD [(of)-291.1(the)-291.1(at-issue)-291.1(term.)-441.6(In)-301.1(the)-291.1(parlance)-301.1(of)-291.1(resource-sensiti)20.1(v)10(e)-281(logics)-281.1(lik)10(e)-291.1(linear)-291.1(logic)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(and)-391.5(cate)10(gorial)-391.5(grammar)40.2(,)-421.6(w)0(e)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 11.9669 0 TD [(multiply)-381.4(consume)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.5493 0 TD [(the)-391.5(at-issue)-391.5(meaning.)-732.7(Multiple)]TJ -19.5162 -1.2145 TD [(consumption)-240.9(is)-261(permitted)-250.9(only)-250.9(in)-261(this)-261(speci)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.2464 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(c)-261(con)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 2.1487 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(guration;)-261(I)-271(claim)-250.9(that)-261(it)-261(lies)-261(at)]TJ -20.5074 -1.2045 TD [(the)-240.9(heart)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-250.9(w)10(a)0(y)-250.9(C)0(I)-250.9(meanings)-240.9(interact)-250.9(with)-240.9(the)-250.9(at-issue)-240.9(semantics.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(This)-261(rule)-271(functions)-261(to)-271(ensure)-271(that)-261(the)-271(at-issue)-261(dimension)-250.9(is)-271(al)10(w)10(ays)-261(insensiti)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(to)-281.1(the)-291.1(presence)-291.1(of)-291.1(adjoined)-291.1(CI)-291.1(operators.)-431.6(In)-291.1(other)-291.1(w)10(ords,)-291.1(for)-291.1(an)10(y)-281.1(tree)]TJ /F6 1 Tf 28.3291 0 TD (T)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0338 0 TD [(,)-301.1(the)-291.1(at-)]TJ -29.363 -1.2045 TD [(issue)-261(content)-271(of)]TJ /F6 1 Tf 6.5894 0 TD (T)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.3049 0 TD [(is)-271(the)-271(same)-281(as)-271(the)-271(at-issue)-271(content)-271(of)-271(the)-271(tree)]TJ /F6 1 Tf 18.2795 0 TD (T)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 436.68 124.02 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 442.92 119.7 Tm [(gotten)-271(from)]TJ -12.0249 -2.4993 TD (19)Tj ET endstream endobj 74 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /F6 75 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 77 0 obj << /Length 7771 >> stream BT /F6 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw (T)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.2848 0 TD [(by)-250.9(pruning)-240.9(all)-240.9(nodes)-250.9(dominating)-230.9(items)-240.9(with)-240.9(a)-250.9(C)0(I)-261(semantics)-240.9(\(i.e.,)-250.9(translating)-240.9(as)]TJ -1.2848 -1.2045 TD [(a)-250.9(term)-240.9(of)-250.9(type)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 180.5161 639.78 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 189.12 644.1 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 193.56 639.78 Tm (\).)Tj -5.4504 -1.2145 TD [(I)-250.9(posit)-230.9(a)-250.9(special)-250.9(rule,)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 8.5273 0 TD [(featur)20.1(e)-261(semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.4606 0 TD [(,)-250.9(for)-250.9(representing)-240.9(the)-240.9(semantic)-240.9(contri-)]TJ -17.4534 -1.2045 TD [(b)20.1(ution)-230.9(of)-250.9(certain)-250.9(syntactic)-240.9(features.)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD (\(27\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD [(featur)20.1(e)-261(semantics)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 147.6 565.98 Tm <0060>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 155.6013 565.98 Tm (\()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 160.2812 565.98 Tm <005f>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 168.7833 565.98 Tm (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6022 0 TD (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 181.9447 565.98 Tm <006f>Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 167.748 563.088 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 155.04 540.0601 Tm <005f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 166.302 540.0601 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 172.2635 540.0601 Tm <006d>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 165 525.66 Tm (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 153.36 511.26 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 164.1213 511.26 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 169.9629 511.26 Tm <0070>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 177.84 515.58 Tm (c)Tj ET 1 g 1 i 149.362 514.371 m 149.362 522.185 151.36 524.183 167.92 524.183 c 184.48 524.183 186.479 522.185 186.479 514.371 c 186.479 506.557 184.48 504.559 167.92 504.559 c 151.36 504.559 149.362 506.557 149.362 514.371 c 151.362 506.559 31.619 14.127 re f 0 G 0 J 0 j 0.3 w 10 M [0.999 ]0 d 149.362 514.371 m 149.362 522.185 151.36 524.183 167.92 524.183 c 184.48 524.183 186.479 522.185 186.479 514.371 c 186.479 506.557 184.48 504.559 167.92 504.559 c 151.36 504.559 149.362 506.557 149.362 514.371 c S BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 247.68 565.98 Tm 0 g (\(where)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 283.8661 565.98 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 294.8674 565.98 Tm [(is)-250.9(a)-250.9(designated)]TJ 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 368.1524 565.98 Tm [(feature)-250.9(term)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 430.0807 565.98 Tm [(of)-250.9(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 3.0566 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 471.3024 565.98 Tm <006d>Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 479.8317 565.98 Tm (,)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 484.5116 565.98 Tm <006f>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 490.7195 565.98 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (\))Tj -32.1634 -6.5445 TD [(This)-240.9(rule)-261(sees)-250.9(hea)20.1(vy)-261(use)-250.9(in)-250.9(the)-250.9(analysis)-250.9(of)-250.9(CIs;)-261(in)-250.9(the)-250.9(diagram)-250.9(in)-250.9(\(5\),)-261(it)-250.9(is)-250.9(the)-250.9(rule)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(that)-240.9(permits)-240.9(us)-240.9(to)-250.9(include)-240.9(the)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 11.7965 0 TD (comma)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.3508 0 TD [(in)-250.9(the)-240.9(semantics.)]TJ -13.6818 -1.2045 TD [(A)-261(single)-250.9(sentence)-261(might)-240.9(contain)-261(multiple)-240.9(CIs,)-261(as)-261(in)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 20.7117 0 TD [(Ed,)-250.9(a)-261(plumber)110.4(,)-250.9(i)0(s)-261(married)]TJ -22.1772 -1.2145 TD [(to)-250.9(Sue)10(,)-250.9(a)-250.9(physicist)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.214 0 TD [(.)-321.2(One)-250.9(can)-261(imagine)-240.9(a)-261(v)20.1(ariety)-250.9(of)-250.9(methods)-240.9(for)-261(ensuring)-240.9(the)-261(proper)]TJ -7.214 -1.2045 TD [(interpretation)-291.1(\(a)-311.2(heritage)-301.1(function,)-311.2(a)-311.2(C)0(I)-311.2(store\).)-471.8(The)-301.1(most)-301.1(direct)-301.1(method,)-311.2(the)-301.1(one)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(adopted)-240.9(here,)-250.9(simply)-240.9(gathers)-240.9(together)-240.9(the)-250.9(desired)-240.9(meanings:)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD (\(28\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD [(parsetr)20.1(ee)-261(inter)10(pr)20.1(etation)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 0.0002 -1.7064 TD (Let)Tj /F6 1 Tf 1.6236 0 TD (T)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.335 0 TD [(be)-301.1(a)-301.1(semantic)-281(parsetree)-311.2(with)-281(the)-301.1(at-issue)-291.1(term)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 407.5576 370.74 Tm <005f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 419.6596 370.74 Tm [(on)-291.1(its)-291.1(root)-291.1(node,)]TJ -22.7667 -1.2145 TD [(and)-261(distinct)-261(type)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 6.8727 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 234.12 360.66 Tm (c)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 241.8 356.22 Tm [(CI)-271(terms)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 286.7957 356.22 Tm <0066>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 290.76 354.42 Tm (1)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 295.68 356.22 Tm 0.1137 Tc [(,...)10.1(,)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 318.9597 356.22 Tm 0 Tc <0066>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 322.92 354.42 Tm (n)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 330.96 356.22 Tm [(on)-271(nodes)-261(in)-271(it.)-361.4(Then)-271(the)-271(interpreta-)]TJ -15.3473 -1.2045 TD [(tion)-240.9(of)]TJ /F6 1 Tf 2.8705 0 TD (T)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.2948 0 TD [(is)-240.9(the)-250.9(tuple)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 4.6075 -2.2083 TD ()Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD -0.1071 Tc ([[)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 262.4398 315.42 Tm 0 Tc <005f>Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 270.9418 315.42 Tm -0.1071 Tc (]])Tj /F6 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 276.36 320.34 Tm 0 Tc (M)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 287.76 315.42 Tm (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ({)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.5019 0 TD -0.1071 Tc ([[)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 303.8397 315.42 Tm 0 Tc <0066>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 307.8 313.5 Tm (1)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 312.6 315.42 Tm -0.1071 Tc (]])Tj /F6 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 318 320.34 Tm 0 Tc (M)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 329.52 315.42 Tm 0.1137 Tc [(,...)10.1(,)]TJ /F4 1 Tf 1.9473 0 TD -0.1071 Tc ([[)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 358.1996 315.42 Tm 0 Tc <0066>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 362.16 313.62 Tm (n)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 366.96 315.42 Tm -0.1071 Tc (]])Tj /F6 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 372.36 320.34 Tm 0 Tc (M)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 383.76 315.42 Tm 0.0019 Tc (})Tj /TT2 1 Tf -19.7638 -2.2083 TD 0 Tc (where)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6838 0 TD -0.1071 Tc ([[)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4517 0 TD 0 Tc (�)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.281 0 TD -0.1071 Tc (]])Tj /F6 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 193.68 293.34 Tm 0 Tc (M)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 207.84 289.02 Tm [(is)-240.9(the)-230.9(interpretation)-230.9(function,)-230.9(taking)-230.9(formulae)-230.9(of)-240.9(the)-240.9(meaning)]TJ -5.0489 -1.2045 TD [(language)-240.9(to)-250.9(the)-240.9(interpreted)-250.9(structure)]TJ /F6 1 Tf 14.6631 0 TD (M)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.2446 0 TD (.)Tj -17.5036 -2.0477 TD [(It�)50.2(s)-200.7(time)-190.7(no)20.1(w)-190.7(t)0(o)-200.7(look)-190.7(at)-210.8(the)-200.8(internal)-190.7(structures)-200.8(of)-200.8(N)30.1(As,)-200.8(to)-200.7(see)-200.8(ho)20.1(w)-200.7(t)0(o)-190.7(capture)-210.8(the)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(conditions)-230.9(on)-240.9(these)-250.9(constructions)-230.9(using)-240.9(the)-250.9(multidimensional)-210.8(logic)-240.9(just)-240.9(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 29.4681 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD (ned.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 194.94 Tm [(5)-996.8(A)-244(multidimensional)-223.1(analysis)-244(of)-244(N)20.9(A)0(s)]TJ 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 164.7 Tm [(5.1)-995.4(The)-250.9(anchor)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 142.14 Tm [(In)-250.9(general,)-250.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 7.0268 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed)-240.9(e)10(xpressions)-230.9(are)-261(not)-240.9(possible)-240.9(anchors)-240.9(in)-250.9(N)30.1(As:)]TJ 8.1659 -4.3764 TD (20)Tj ET endstream endobj 78 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /F6 75 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 80 0 obj << /Length 9179 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(\(29\))-1395.2(a.)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 658.5 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 654.1801 Tm [(Ev)10(ery)-291.1(climber)40.2(,)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 6.2339 0 TD ({)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5019 0 TD (an/the)Tj /F1 1 Tf 2.4434 0 TD (})Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.793 0 TD [(e)10(xperienced)-291.1(adv)10(enturer)40.1(,)-301.1(w)10(as)-291.1(found)-291.1(sipping)]TJ -9.9721 -1.2045 TD [(hot)-240.9(cocoa)-261(in)-240.9(the)-250.9(lodge.)]TJ -2.148 -1.6261 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 624.66 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 620.34 Tm [(No)-240.9(climber)40.1(,)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 4.968 0 TD ({)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5019 0 TD (an/the)Tj /F1 1 Tf 2.4434 0 TD (})Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7428 0 TD [(e)10(xperienced)-240.9(adv)10(enturer)40.2(,)-240.9(w)10(as)-250.9(found)-230.9(sipping)-230.9(hot)]TJ -8.656 -1.2145 TD [(cocoa)-250.9(in)-250.9(the)-250.9(lodge.)]TJ -5.2095 -2.0376 TD [(This)-240.9(is)-240.9(part)-250.9(of)-250.9(a)-250.9(broader)-250.9(generalization:)]TJ T* [(\(30\))-1395.2(Nonrestricti)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(modi)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 11.0379 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ers)-240.9(associate)-240.9(only)-240.9(with)-240.9(referring)-261(e)10(xpressions.)]TJ -8.5326 -1.2145 TD [(\(Thorne)-240.9(1972:553;)-230.9(Karttunen)-250.9(1976:367;)-230.9(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-240.9(1998:451;)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(Potts)-240.9(2002a:83;)-230.9(Huddleston)-240.9(and)-240.9(Pullum)-240.9(2002:1060;)-230.9(and)-250.9(others\))]TJ -3.0614 -2.2886 TD [(\(31\))-1395.2(a.)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 505.14 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 500.82 Tm [(Susan)-250.9(intervie)20.1(wed)-240.9(e)20.1(v)10(ery)-240.9(senator)40.1(,)-250.9(who)-240.9(is)-240.9(crook)10(ed.)]TJ 15.3273 -1.2145 TD [(\(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-240.9(1998:451,)-230.9(\(24b)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 488.52 490.62 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 491.4 486.3 Tm (\)\))Tj -28.7675 -1.6261 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 471.18 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 466.86 Tm [(No)-250.9(person,)-240.9(who)-250.9(kno)20.1(ws)-230.9(e)20.1(v)10(erything,)-230.9(is)-250.9(perfect.)]TJ 15.3775 -1.2045 TD [(\(McCa)10(wle)10(y)-240.9(1998:451,)-240.9(\(24c)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 488.52 456.78 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 491.4 452.46 Tm (\)\))Tj -28.7675 -1.6261 TD (c.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 437.34 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 433.02 Tm [(No)-250.9(candidate,)-240.9(who)-250.9(scored)-250.9(40%)-240.9(or)-250.9(more,)-250.9(e)20.1(v)10(er)-240.9(f)10(ailed.)]TJ 10.71 -1.2045 TD [(\(Huddleston)-230.9(and)-250.9(Pullum)-240.9(2002:1060,)-230.9(\(7i\)\))]TJ -14.454 -2.2986 TD [(The)-301.1(CI)-301.1(logic)-291.1(\(considered)-301.1(so)-291.1(as)-301.1(to)-301.1(include)-291.1(le)10(xical)-291.1(items\))-281.1(cannot)-301.1(deri)20.1(v)10(e)-291.1(mean-)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(ings)-240.9(for)-250.9(structures)-240.9(in)-250.9(which)-240.9(the)-250.9(anchor)-250.9(is)-240.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 19.0186 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed.)-301.1(I)-250.9(illustrate)-240.9(in)-240.9(\(32\).)]TJ -19.5748 -2.2986 TD [(\(32\))-5831.8(DP)]TJ /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 208.2 342.9 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj 0.3854 -0.1325 TD ()Tj -3.3846 0.795 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3252 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3373 TD ()Tj -0.3854 -0.1325 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 166.8 316.86 Tm (DP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 174.48 309.9 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.7227 -0.3011 TD (
)Tj -2.7222 0.6986 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.7107 -0.3011 TD ()Tj ET q 54.24 0 0 -0.48 147.468 303.2881 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 147.48 289.98 Tm [(No)-240.9(climber)]TJ /F3 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 213.48 333.66 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.7365 -0.793 TD (NP)Tj 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 222 309.78 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj /F3 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 264 333.66 Tm 0 Tc ()Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 241.92 298.74 Tm ()Tj 0.8793 -0.5902 TD ()Tj -1.879 0.5902 TD ()Tj -0.8913 -0.5902 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 218.76 282.54 Tm (D)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 227.4 286.86 Tm (0)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 222.948 279.528 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 220.44 255.54 Tm (a)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 252.96 282.54 Tm (NP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 260.64 271.98 Tm (\015)Tj 0.6384 -0.4698 TD (\015)Tj -1.6381 0.4698 TD ()Tj -0.6384 -0.4698 TD ()Tj ET q 32.64 0 0 -0.48 244.308 267.528 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 244.32 255.54 Tm (lunatic)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 364.44 349.26 Tm (unde)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.9438 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (ned)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 387.96 340.74 Tm ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj 0.0843 -0.0241 TD ()Tj -5.083 1.0238 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2409 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.2529 TD ()Tj -0.0843 -0.0241 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 303.84 317.34 Tm (no)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.0562 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (climber)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.2764 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf -4.8645 -1.2045 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 324.12 307.26 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 329.04 302.94 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 337.68 307.26 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 342.48 302.94 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 355.8 307.26 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 360.6 302.94 Tm ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 2.8607 1.2045 TD (comma)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.1099 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (lunatic)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.9448 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf -4.7498 -1.2045 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 432.36 307.26 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 437.28 302.94 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 445.92 307.26 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 450.24 302.94 Tm ()Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 438.348 298.608 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 400.2 272.7 Tm (lunatic)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.1657 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 453.96 277.02 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 459 272.7 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 467.64 277.02 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 472.44 272.7 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -30.243 -3.3626 TD [(The)-291.1(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.3453 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-291.1(cannot)-291.1(tak)10(e)-301.1(the)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-271(as)-291.1(its)-281.1(ar)20.1(gument,)-301.1(because)-301.1(the)-291.1(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ -4.9014 -1.2045 TD [(is)-321.2(of)-321.2(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 4.1953 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 171.12 222.42 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 176.04 218.1 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 184.68 222.42 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 189 218.1 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.7127 0 TD [(b)20.1(u)0(t)-321.2(the)-331.2(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 5.6314 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-321.2(tak)10(es)-321.2(only)-321.2(meanings)-321.2(of)-321.2(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 12.9238 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 436.44 222.42 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 441.36 218.1 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 450 222.42 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 454.8 218.1 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD 0.542 Tc [(.S)542(o)220.8(w)542(e)]TJ -29.1589 -1.2145 TD 0 Tc [(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-261(a)-261(type-mismatch.)-341.3(T)80.3(o)-261(ensure)-271(that)-250.9(this)-261(type-mismatch)-240.9(holds)-261(for)-261(all)-261(structures,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(we)-240.9(need)-240.9(to)-230.9(say)-230.9(that)-240.9(the)-230.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-210.8(cannot)-240.9(shift)-230.9(to)-230.9(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 21.4684 0 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 387.48 193.5 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 392.4 189.18 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 401.04 193.5 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 405.84 189.18 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 419.16 193.5 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 423.96 189.18 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 437.28 193.5 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 441.6 189.18 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(,)-230.9(taking)-230.9(the)]TJ -28.0548 -1.2145 TD (quanti)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 2.4995 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-220.8(meaning)-220.8(as)-220.8(its)-220.8(ar)20.1(gument.)-301.1(The)-220.8(meaning)-220.8(we)-230.9(w)10(ould)-210.8(deri)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(for)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 24.8122 0 TD [(No)-220.8(climber)110.4(,)]TJ -27.8679 -1.2045 TD [(a)-351.3(lunatic,)-361.4(survived)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.0091 0 TD [(w)10(ould)-341.3(be)-351.3(equi)20.1(v)20.1(alent)-341.3(to)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.7117 0 TD [(No)-361.4(climber)-341.3(is)-351.3(a)-351.3(lunatic;)-391.5(no)-351.3(climber)]TJ -17.7208 -1.2045 TD (survived)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.3877 0 TD (.)Tj 12.3611 -4.6875 TD (21)Tj ET endstream endobj 81 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F3 24 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 84 0 obj << /Length 8072 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 128.4 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(But)-220.8(such)-210.8(type-shifting)-200.8(is)-210.8(easy)-210.8(to)-210.8(pre)20.1(v)10(ent.)-291.1(T)80.3(ype-shifting)-200.7(functions)-200.8(are)-220.8(of)-220.8(course)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(terms)-250.9(of)-261(our)-261(logic.)-331.2(In)-261(order)-261(to)-250.9(tak)10(e)-261(a)-261(C)0(I)-271(term)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 328.5918 639.78 Tm <006f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 337.9196 639.78 Tm [(of)-261(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 3.0766 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 384.96 644.1 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 389.88 639.78 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 398.52 644.1 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 402.84 639.78 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6524 0 TD [(into)-250.9(a)-261(term)-250.9(of)-261(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf -25.0737 -1.2145 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 130.2 629.58 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 135 625.26 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 143.64 629.58 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 148.56 625.26 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 161.88 629.58 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 166.56 625.26 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 179.88 629.58 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 184.2 625.26 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD [(,)-250.9(w)0(e)-250.9(w)10(ould)-240.9(require)-250.9(a)-250.9(type-shifter)-240.9(with)-240.9(the)-250.9(type)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 4.5169 -2.2082 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 257.52 603.78 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 262.44 598.86 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 271.08 603.78 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 275.4 598.86 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 304.08 603.78 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 308.88 598.86 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 317.52 603.78 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 322.32 598.86 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 335.64 603.78 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 340.44 598.86 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 353.76 603.78 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 358.08 598.86 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -20.6773 -2.2083 TD 0 Tc [(Both)-250.9(immediate)-250.9(subtypes)-240.9(of)-261(this)-240.9(type)-250.9(are,)-271(of)-250.9(necessity)60.2(,)-250.9(C)0(I)-261(types.)-331.2(The)-250.9(type)-261(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 30.7777 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (ni-)Tj -31.3339 -1.2045 TD [(tion)-210.8(does)-230.9(not)-220.8(contain)-210.8(such)-230.9(types.)-291.1(The)-230.9(only)-210.8(remaining)-220.8(concern)-230.9(is)-220.8(that)-220.8(the)-220.8(type)-230.9(shift)]TJ T* [(might)-210.8(happen)-230.9(prior)-220.8(to)-220.8(the)-230.9(mo)10(v)10(e)-210.8(to)-230.9(CI)-230.9(types.)-291.1(T)80.3(o)-230.9(block)-220.8(such)-220.8(a)-240.9(composition)-200.7(scheme,)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(we)-311.2(just)-311.2(need)-311.2(to)-311.2(limit)-301.1(the)-311.2(range)-321.2(of)-321.2(types)-301.1(that)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 18.1629 0 TD (comma)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.4311 0 TD [(can)-311.2(ha)20.1(v)10(e)0(.)-501.9(F)10(or)-321.2(this)-301.1(paper)40.1(,)-331.2(I)]TJ -21.594 -1.2045 TD [(assume)-240.9(that)-240.9(the)-250.9(only)-240.9(possibility)-220.8(is)-250.9(\(40\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(So)-321.2(the)-321.2(logic)-321.2(itself)-311.2(handles)-321.2(a)-321.2(ban)-321.2(on)-321.2(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.2783 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed)-321.2(anchors)-321.2(quite)-311.2(nicely)60.2(.)-521.9(But)-321.2(the)]TJ -19.2999 -1.2045 TD [(underlying)-261(generalization)-281.1(is)-271(more)-281(complicated)-271(than)-281(this.)-391.5(An)-271(e)10(xample)-271(of)-281(a)-291.1(gram-)]TJ T* [(matical)-180.7(anchor)-200.8(that)-190.7(has)-190.7(the)-190.7(form)-190.7(of)-190.7(a)-200.8(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 16.9737 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-190.7(is)-190.7(\(33a\),)-200.8(which)-190.7(I)-200.8(o)20.1(we)-180.7(to)-190.7(L)50.2(y)0(n)-190.7(Frazier)]TJ -17.5299 -1.2145 TD [(\(p.c.,)-250.9(2/03\).)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(33\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Ev)10(ery)-250.9(climber)40.1(,)-240.9(all)-240.9(e)10(xperienced)-250.9(adv)10(enturers,)-240.9(made)-250.9(it)-240.9(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(summit.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.6261 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Ev)10(ery)-250.9(climber)40.1(,)-240.9(e)10(xperienced)-240.9(adv)10(enturers)-250.9(all,)-240.9(made)-250.9(it)-240.9(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(summit.)]TJ T* (c.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 397.98 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 393.66 Tm [(Ev)10(ery)-250.9(climber)40.1(,)-240.9(e)10(xperienced)-240.9(adv)10(enturers,)-250.9(made)-240.9(it)-250.9(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(summit.)]TJ -5.2095 -2.0376 TD [(Ho)20.1(w)-261(are)-281.1(these)-271(cases)-271(best)-271(handled?)-371.4(In)-281(locating)-261(an)-271(answer)40.1(,)-281(I)-271(think)-261(we)-281(should)-261(look)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(at)-250.9(e)10(xamples)-230.9(lik)10(e)-250.9(\(34\).)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(34\))-1395.2(The)-240.9(students,)-240.9(most)-240.9(of)-240.9(them)-250.9(linguists,)-220.8(missed)-240.9(the)-240.9(b)20.1(uss.)]TJ 0 -2.0476 TD [(In)-321.2(this)-311.2(e)10(xample,)-331.2(the)-321.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-301.1(is)-321.2(semantically)-311.2(complete.)-522(It)-321.2(is)-321.2(a)-321.2(small-clause)-321.2(of)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(some)-301.1(kind.)-481.8(It)-311.2(needn�)20.1(t)-311.2(apply)-311.2(to)-301.1(the)-311.2(meaning)-301.1(of)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.1665 0 TD [(the)-311.2(students)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.8107 0 TD [(,)-311.2(though)-291.1(this)-301.1(appears)]TJ -23.9772 -1.2045 TD [(to)-331.2(be)-331.2(its)-321.2(syntactic)-331.2(anchor)50.2(.)-552.1(The)-341.3(logic)-321.2(de)20.1(v)10(eloped)-321.2(in)-331.2(Potts)-321.2(2005)-331.2(includes)-321.2(the)-331.2(tree-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(admissibility)-311.2(condition)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 9.5767 0 TD [(isolated)-331.2(CIs)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 5.1096 0 TD [(,)-361.4(\(35\),)-361.3(which)-341.3(allo)20.1(ws)-321.2(this)-331.2(kind)-331.2(of)-341.3(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ -14.6863 -1.2045 TD [(into)-240.9(semantic)-240.9(parsetrees.)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD (\(35\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD [(Isolated)-240.9(CIs)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 175.08 203.34 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 185.7213 203.34 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 191.5629 203.34 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 197.88 207.66 Tm (a)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 189 196.38 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.8913 -0.3493 TD (
)Tj -2.8908 0.7468 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.8913 -0.3493 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 147.48 177.42 Tm <005f>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 158.622 177.42 Tm (:)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.4786 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 168.6 181.86 Tm (c)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 203.76 177.42 Tm <0060>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 214.4013 177.42 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 220.3629 177.42 Tm <006f>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 226.68 181.86 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 214.8 163.02 Tm (�)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 204.48 148.62 Tm <0061>Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 212.9952 148.62 Tm (:)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 218.9567 148.62 Tm <006c>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 226.56 152.94 Tm (c)Tj ET 1 g 1 i 200.482 151.362 m 200.482 158.878 202.48 160.876 217.806 160.876 c 233.131 160.876 235.129 158.878 235.129 151.362 c 235.129 143.845 233.131 141.847 217.806 141.847 c 202.48 141.847 200.482 143.845 200.482 151.362 c 202.482 143.847 29.149 13.532 re f 0 G 0 J 0 j 0.3 w 10 M [0.999 ]0 d 200.482 151.362 m 200.482 158.878 202.48 160.876 217.806 160.876 c 233.131 160.876 235.129 158.878 235.129 151.362 c 235.129 143.845 233.131 141.847 217.806 141.847 c 202.48 141.847 200.482 143.845 200.482 151.362 c S BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 299.16 89.82 Tm 0 g (22)Tj ET endstream endobj 85 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 87 0 obj << /Length 6710 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(This)-210.8(rule)-220.8(licenses)-210.8(structures)-210.8(in)-210.8(which)-220.8(the)-210.8(CI)-230.9(bears)-220.8(no)-210.8(semantic)-210.8(function�ar)20.1(gument)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(relation)-240.9(to)-240.9(its)-250.9(anchor)50.2(.)-301.1(I)0(f)-250.9(w)0(e)-250.9(analyze)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 14.3693 0 TD [(all)-250.9(e)20.1(xperienced)-250.9(adventur)40.1(er)10(s)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.3351 0 TD (as)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 138.24 614.34 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 146.2413 614.34 Tm (w)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5967 0 TD (.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ( )Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5521 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD ([)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.281 0 TD (climber)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 212.52 612.54 Tm (w)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 219 614.34 Tm (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (\012)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.2246 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (experienced)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 316.56 611.46 Tm (w)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 323.04 614.34 Tm (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.532 0 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.803 0 TD [(adv)10(entur)20.1(er)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 405.72 612.54 Tm (w)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 412.2 614.34 Tm (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD 0.0026 Tc (\)\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0037 0 TD 0 Tc (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (s)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 449.52 619.26 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 454.44 614.34 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 463.08 619.26 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 467.4 614.34 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -29.8214 -2.1179 TD [(then)-331.2(we)-341.3(can)-341.3(use)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 6.9534 0 TD [(isolated)-331.2(CIs)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 5.4408 0 TD [(and)-341.3(maintain)-321.2(the)-331.2(descripti)20.1(v)10(e)-321.2(generalization)-331.2(about)]TJ -12.3942 -1.2145 TD [(true)-250.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-240.9(and)-240.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 8.0342 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed)-250.9(anchors.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 539.34 Tm [(5.2)-995.4(The)-250.9(appositi)8.4(v)8.4(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 516.78 Tm [(In)-421.6(most)-421.6(cases,)-471.8(the)-431.6(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-401.5(is)-421.6(property-denoting;)-501.9(the)-421.6(result)-421.6(is)-421.6(that)-421.6(N)30.1(A)0(s)-421.6(are)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(strongly)-240.9(reminiscent)-250.9(of)-261(predicati)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(copular)-250.9(clauses)-261(with)-250.9(indi)20.1(vidual-denoting)-220.8(sub-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(jects.)-291.1(The)-210.8(syntax)-210.8(seems)-200.8(not)-210.8(to)-210.8(impose)-200.8(further)-210.8(limitations:)-261(nominal,)-210.8(adjecti)20.1(v)20.1(al,)-200.8(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(prepositional)-230.9(phrases)-250.9(are)-250.9(all)-250.9(possible,)-230.9(as)-250.9(seen)-250.9(in)-240.9(\(2\).)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(In)-210.8(general,)-210.8(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.9465 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ed)-200.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-180.7(are)-210.8(ungrammatical)-190.7(\(e)10(xcepting)-190.7(cases)-210.8(lik)10(e)-200.8(\(34\))]TJ -8.9681 -1.2045 TD [(and)-240.9(\(33\),)-250.9(discussed)-240.9(abo)10(v)10(e)-230.9(as)-250.9(in)40.1(v)20.1(olving)-230.9(propositional)-230.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(meanings\).)-301.1(Some)]TJ T* [(e)10(xamples:)]TJ 0 -1.9673 TD [(\(36\))-1395.2(a.)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 410.94 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 406.62 Tm [(W)80.3(e)-351.3(spok)10(e)-331.2(with)-331.2(T)80.3(a)0(n)10(ya,)-361.4(e)20.1(v)10(ery)-331.2(assistant)-331.2(in)-331.2(the)-341.3(department,)-361.4(about)-331.2(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(brok)10(en)-250.9(printer)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.596 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 377.34 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 373.02 Tm [(W)80.3(e)-250.9(approached)-261(T)80.3(a)0(n)10(ya,)-240.9(most)-240.9(support)-230.9(staf)20.1(f,)-250.9(about)-240.9(the)-250.9(brok)10(en)-240.9(printer)50.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.606 TD [(c.)-1455.4(Armin,)-381.4(Jaye,)-381.4(and)-361.3(Junk)10(o,)-381.4(\()]TJ /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 302.52 358.14 Tm (
)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 307.56 353.82 Tm [(all\))-351.3(the)-361.3(tenured)-361.3(phonologists)-331.2(at)-361.4(UCSC,)]TJ -11.242 -1.2045 TD [(got)-240.9(their)-250.9(doctorates)-240.9(from)-250.9(UMass.)]TJ -5.2095 -1.9674 TD [(Ho)20.1(we)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)-230.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.5551 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ers)-240.9(that)-240.9(can)-240.9(appear)-250.9(in)-240.9(predicati)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(positions)-220.8(are)-250.9(also)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 20.5088 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ne)-250.9(in)-240.9(N)30.1(As:)]TJ -28.1762 -1.9674 TD [(\(37\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(W)80.3(e)-250.9(spok)10(e)-250.9(with)-240.9(Hillary)60.2(,)-230.9(n)0(o)-250.9(amateur)-250.9(climber)40.1(,)-240.9(about)-240.9(the)-250.9(dangers.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.606 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(W)80.3(e)-240.9(spok)10(e)-240.9(with)-220.8(T)80.3(a)0(n)10(ya,)-240.9(e)20.1(v)10(erything)-220.8(to)-230.9(e)20.1(v)10(eryone)-230.9(around)-230.9(here,)-250.9(about)-230.9(the)]TJ 2.148 -1.2045 TD [(brok)10(en)-250.9(printer)50.2(.)]TJ -5.2095 -1.9674 TD [(The)-341.3(parallel)-341.3(between)-341.3(predicati)20.1(v)10(e)-321.2(copular)-341.3(constructions)-321.2(and)-341.3(N)30.1(A)0(s)-331.2(i)0(s)-341.3(grounded)-331.2(in)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-250.9(logic)-250.9(itself.)-331.2(In)-261(general,)-261(theories)-261(of)-250.9(predicati)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(copular)-261(constructions)-240.9(con)40.2(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(g)0(e)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(on)-250.9(a)-250.9(function�ar)20.1(gument)-240.9(structure)-250.9(in)-240.9(which)-250.9(the)-250.9(predicate)-250.9(applies)-250.9(to)-250.9(the)-250.9(subject.)-311.2(In)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(N)30.1(As,)-240.9(the)-240.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(applies)-240.9(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(anchor)-250.9(in)-240.9(roughly)-240.9(the)-250.9(same)-250.9(w)10(a)0(y)60.2(.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 156.66 Tm [(5.3)-995.4(Comma)-242.6(intonation)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 134.1 Tm [(A)-250.9(central)-261(feature)-261(of)-261(Grice�)50.2(s)-261(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 12.1822 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-240.9(of)-261(CIs)-261(is)-250.9(that)-250.9(the)10(y)-250.9(are)-271(part)-250.9(of)-261(le)10(xical)-250.9(mean-)]TJ -12.7383 -1.2045 TD [(ings.)-291.1(It�)50.2(s)-220.8(not)-210.8(immediately)-210.8(ob)10(vious)-210.8(ho)20.1(w)-210.8(t)0(o)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 16.6889 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(t)-230.9(N)30.1(As)-210.8(into)-220.8(this)-210.8(picture.)-301.1(I)-230.9(a)0(r)20.1(gue)-230.9(that)-210.8(we)]TJ -1.4963 -2.4993 TD (23)Tj ET endstream endobj 88 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 90 0 obj << /Length 9420 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(should)-200.7(tak)10(e)-220.8(a)-210.8(cue)-220.8(from)-210.8(the)-220.8(f)10(act)-210.8(that)-210.8(comma)-210.8(intonation)-200.7(is)-210.8(often)-210.8(the)-210.8(only)-210.8(perceptible)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(dif)20.1(ference)-210.8(between)-200.8(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-180.7(and)-210.8(their)-200.8(inte)10(grated)-190.7(counterparts.)-291.1(The)-210.8(guiding)-190.7(idea)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(is)-291.1(that)-281.1(it)-291.1(is)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 165.438 625.26 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 208.7591 625.26 Tm 0 Tc [(that)-291.1(enables)-291.1(N)30.1(A)0(s)-281(t)0(o)-291.1(meet)-291.1(the)-291.1(speci)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.0355 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cation)-291.1(in)-291.1(Grice�)50.2(s)-291.1(\(1975\))]TJ -22.7788 -1.2045 TD (de)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 0.9438 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-250.9(that)-250.9(CIs)-261(be)-261(le)10(xical.)-321.2(The)-261(shift)-250.9(from)-250.9(at-issue)-250.9(to)-261(CI)-261(content)-250.9(is)-250.9(achie)20.1(v)10(e)0(d)-250.9(b)0(y)]TJ -1.5 -1.2045 TD [(the)-240.9(semantic)-250.9(re)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.0446 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(e)10(x)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(syntactic)-240.9(feature)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 316.3121 596.46 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 355.6732 596.46 Tm 0 Tc (.)Tj -19.0105 -1.2145 TD [(F)10(o)0(r)-230.9(basic)-230.9(N)30.1(As,)-220.8(we)-240.9(need)-230.9(the)-230.9(meaning)-220.8(of)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 318.438 581.9401 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 361.0391 581.9401 Tm 0 Tc [(to)-220.8(tak)10(e)]TJ /F1 1 Tf 2.885 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 405.84 586.26 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 410.88 581.9401 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 419.52 586.26 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 424.32 581.9401 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6223 0 TD [(e)10(xpressions)-210.8(to)]TJ /F1 1 Tf -26.8403 -1.2045 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 120.84 571.86 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 125.76 567.54 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 134.4 571.86 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 138.72 567.54 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6424 0 TD (results:)Tj -2.9711 -2.0476 TD (\(38\))Tj 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 147.7175 543.0601 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj /F7 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 190.0786 543.0601 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 204.7183 543.0601 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 214.5197 543.0601 Tm (f)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 219.5212 543.0601 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 227.5225 543.0601 Tm (x)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (.)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.542 0 TD (f)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4184 0 TD (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6223 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4886 0 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.7829 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 282.48 547.5 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 287.52 543.0601 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 296.16 547.5 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 300.96 543.0601 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 320.28 547.5 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 325.08 543.0601 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 333.72 547.5 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 338.04 543.0601 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -19.001 -2.0376 TD 0 Tc [(I)-271(henceforth)-281.1(write)-271(this)-261(meaning)-261(as)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 14.0003 0 TD (comma)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.1099 0 TD [(.)-381.4(I)0(t)-271(w)10(orks)-271(in)-271(conjunction)-261(with)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 12.2884 0 TD [(featur)20.1(e)]TJ -29.3986 -1.2045 TD (semantics)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.166 0 TD [(,)-250.9(\(27\),)-240.9(to)-250.9(license)-240.9(subtrees)-250.9(of)-250.9(the)-240.9(form)-250.9(in)-240.9(\(39\),)-250.9(a)-250.9(part)-250.9(of)-250.9(\(5\).)]TJ -4.166 -2.0476 TD (\(39\))Tj /TT4 1 Tf 3.0612 0 TD (comma)Tj /F4 1 Tf 3.0998 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (cyclist)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.6655 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6123 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4886 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 244.32 484.14 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 249.36 479.82 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 258 484.14 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 262.32 479.82 Tm ()Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 206.988 476.928 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 170.4 453.9 Tm (cyclist)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.8864 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD ()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (e)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 220.92 458.22 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 225.84 453.9 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 234.48 458.22 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 239.28 453.9 Tm ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf -10.7401 -1.8469 TD [(In)-281.1(order)-281(to)-281.1(allo)20.1(w)-271(for)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 212.6621 431.82 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 255.7432 431.82 Tm 0 Tc [(to)-281(play)-281(a)-281(role)-281(in)-281(isolated)-271(CI)-291.1(e)10(xamples)-271(lik)10(e)-281.1(those)-271(in)]TJ -12.1172 -1.2045 TD [(\(33\),)-250.9(we)-250.9(need)-250.9(a)-250.9(slightly)-230.9(more)-240.9(general)-250.9(meaning)-240.9(for)]TJ 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 353.0782 417.42 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 392.4393 417.42 Tm 0 Tc (:)Tj -23.5513 -2.0476 TD (\(40\))Tj 9.5641 0 0 9.5641 147.7175 392.94 Tm 0.0502 Tc (COMMA)Tj /F7 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 190.0786 392.94 Tm 0 Tc (
)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 204.7183 392.94 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 212.7197 392.94 Tm (X)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 221.2224 392.94 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 229.2237 392.94 Tm (x)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (.)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (X)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.7112 0 TD (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /F4 1 Tf 0.4438 0 TD (\))Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.6022 0 TD (:)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.4987 0 TD 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 280.2201 392.94 Tm 0 Tc <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 288.96 397.38 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 293.76 392.94 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 302.4 397.38 Tm (a)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 307.2 392.94 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (,)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD ()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 321.2398 392.94 Tm <006d>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 329.76 397.38 Tm (a)Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 334.68 392.94 Tm (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3714 0 TD (t)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 343.32 397.38 Tm (c)Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 347.64 392.94 Tm 0.0026 Tc ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.0238 0 TD 0 Tc [(,)-250.9(where)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 398.0735 392.94 Tm <006d>Tj /F1 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 409.2429 392.94 Tm 0.2166 Tc ({)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 1.3852 0 TD 0 Tc (e)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.4338 0 TD (,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (s)Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.3892 0 TD (})Tj /TT4 1 Tf 14.3462 0 0 14.3462 110.88 357.54 Tm [(5.4)-995.4(Ther)16.7(e)-250.9(a)0(r)16.7(e)-250.9(no)-250.9(in)41.8(v)8.4(erted)-259.3(cases)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 335.1 Tm [(It)-271(seems)-281.1(at)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.5994 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(rst)-281(as)-271(though)-271(e)10(xamples)-261(lik)10(e)-281(\(41a\))-271(are)-291.1(best)-271(analyzed)-281(as)-271(in)40.1(v)10(erted)-271(v)20.1(ari-)]TJ -5.1556 -1.2145 TD [(ants)-240.9(of)-250.9(\(41b\).)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(41\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(A)-291.1(former)-301.1(linguist,)-281(Edw)10(ard)-291.1(W)40.1(itten,)-301.1(is)-281.1(no)20.1(w)-291.1(the)-291.1(top-dog)-281.1(in)-291.1(string)-281.1(the-)]TJ 5.2095 -1.2145 TD [(ory)60.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.616 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Edw)10(ard)-210.8(W)40.1(itten,)-210.8(a)-210.8(former)-220.8(linguist,)-190.7(is)-210.8(no)20.1(w)-200.8(the)-210.8(top-dog)-200.7(in)-210.8(string)-200.7(theory)60.2(.)]TJ -3.0614 -2.0476 TD [(On)-250.9(an)-261(in)40.2(v)10(erted)-250.9(analysis,)-250.9(the)-261(semantic)-250.9(parsetrees)-261(for)-261(the)-261(subjects)-240.9(in)-261(\(41\))-261(w)10(ould)-250.9(be)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(identical)-331.2(to)-341.3(each)-351.3(other)-331.2(\(recall)-351.3(that)-341.3(the)-341.3(lea)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-331.2(o)0(f)-351.3(the)-331.2(parsetrees)-351.3(are)-351.3(not)-331.2(ordered\).)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(The)-250.9(dif)20.1(ferences)-250.9(w)10(ould)-240.9(reside)-240.9(entirely)-250.9(in)-240.9(the)-250.9(syntactic)-240.9(structures.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(But)-230.9(all)-220.8(the)-220.8(e)20.1(vidence)-220.8(kno)20.1(wn)-220.8(to)-220.8(me)-220.8(suggests)-210.8(that)-220.8(this)-220.8(is)-220.8(incorrect.)-301.1(W)80.3(e)-230.9(must)-210.8(state)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(that)-341.3(N)30.1(A)0(s)-351.3(a)0(l)10(w)10(ays)-341.3(in)40.1(v)20.1(olv)10(e)-341.3(right-adjunction)-331.2(of)-351.3(the)-351.3(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-331.2(to)-341.3(the)-351.3(anchor)-351.3(in)-351.3(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(syntax,)-361.3(and)-341.3(moreo)10(v)10(e)0(r)-341.3(that)-341.3(this)-341.3(right-adjoined)-331.2(item)-341.3(is)-341.3(al)10(w)10(ays)-341.3(the)-351.3(functor)50.2(.)-592.2(Clear)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(e)20.1(vidence)-311.2(for)-311.2(this)-311.2(analysis)-301.1(deri)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-301.1(from)-311.2(e)10(xistential)-301.1(constructions.)-481.8(Consider)40.1(,)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 30.6312 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD (rst,)Tj -31.1874 -1.2145 TD [(the)-240.9(e)10(xistential-)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 5.8954 0 TD [(ther)40.2(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.2554 0 TD [(en)40.1(vironment)-230.9(in)-250.9(\(42\).)]TJ 7.598 -3.9247 TD (24)Tj ET endstream endobj 91 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /F7 92 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 94 0 obj << /Length 6690 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(\(42\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(There)-250.9(w)10(a)0(s)-250.9(a)-250.9(former)-250.9(linguist)-230.9(at)-250.9(the)-250.9(party)60.2(.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.5759 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(There)-250.9(w)10(a)0(s)-250.9(a)-250.9(former)-250.9(linguist,)-230.9(Ed)-250.9(W)40.1(itten,)-240.9(at)-250.9(the)-240.9(party)60.2(.)]TJ T* (c.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 620.8201 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 616.5 Tm [(There)-250.9(w)10(a)0(s)-250.9(E)0(d)-250.9(W)40.1(itten)-240.9(at)-250.9(the)-240.9(party)60.2(.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5759 TD (d.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 601.98 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 597.66 Tm [(There)-250.9(w)10(a)0(s)-250.9(E)0(d)-250.9(W)40.1(itten,)-240.9(a)-250.9(former)-250.9(linguist,)-230.9(at)-250.9(the)-240.9(party)60.2(.)]TJ -5.2095 -1.9071 TD [(W)80.3(e)-381.4(see)-381.4(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 4.2909 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(niteness)-381.4(ef)20.1(fects)-381.4(only)-371.4(when)-381.4(the)-381.4(lefthand)-371.4(nominal)-371.4(is)-381.4(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 22.2175 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nite.)-702.6(These)]TJ -27.6208 -1.2045 TD [(f)10(acts)-371.4(suggest)-371.4(that)-371.4(the)-371.4(anchor)-381.4(�)-371.4(the)-371.4(at-issue)-371.4(meaning)-371.4(contrib)20.1(utor)-361.4(that)-371.4(interacts)]TJ T* [(with)-271(the)-281.1(meaning)-271(of)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.38 0 TD [(ther)40.1(e)-291.1(b)0(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.5305 0 TD [(�)-271(i)0(s)-281(a)0(l)10(w)10(ays)-281(on)-281(the)-281(left.)-401.5(That)-281(claim)-271(is)-281.1(bolstered)-271(by)]TJ -11.9105 -1.2145 TD [(another)-261(e)10(xistential)-240.9(construction,)-250.9(the)-261(one)-261(determined)-261(by)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 22.252 0 TD (have)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.1487 0 TD [(\(P)10(artee,)-271(1999\).)-351.3(This)]TJ -24.4007 -1.2045 TD [(en)40.2(vironment)-361.3(imposes)-351.3(some)20.1(what)-361.4(dif)20.1(ferent)-361.3(restrictions)-361.3(than)-371.4(e)10(xistential-)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 28.5148 0 TD [(ther)40.1(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.0145 0 TD 0.3814 Tc [(,b)401.5(u)381.4(t)]TJ -30.5293 -1.2145 TD 0 Tc [(the)-351.3(prohibition)-341.3(on)-351.3(referential)-361.3(e)10(xpressions)-341.3(is)-351.3(constant)-341.3(across)-361.3(both)-341.3(constructions.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(An)-361.3(in)40.1(v)10(erted)-351.3(analysis)-351.3(of)-361.3(the)-351.3(complements)-351.3(to)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 18.3138 0 TD (have)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.249 0 TD [(in)-361.4(\(43\))-361.3(wrongly)-351.3(predicts)-351.3(that)]TJ -20.5629 -1.2045 TD [(\(43d\))-240.9(is)-250.9(semantically)-230.9(identical)-240.9(to)-250.9(\(43b\).)]TJ 0 -1.9071 TD [(\(43\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Ray)-261(had)-240.9(a)-261(student.)]TJ 3.0614 -1.5759 TD [(b)40.1(.)-1435.4(Ray)-261(had)-240.9(a)-261(student,)-230.9(Ed)-250.9(W)40.1(itten.)]TJ T* (c.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 417.66 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 413.34 Tm [(Ray)-261(had)-240.9(Ed)-250.9(W)40.1(itten.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5759 TD (d.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 398.82 Tm (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 394.5 Tm [(Ray)-261(had)-240.9(Ed)-250.9(W)40.1(itten,)-240.9(a)-250.9(student.)]TJ -3.744 -1.8971 TD [(Finally)60.2(,)-301.1(I)-291.1(of)20.1(fer)-301.1(some)-291.1(support)-291.1(from)-291.1(a)-301.1(slightly)-271(dif)20.1(ferent)-291.1(domain:)-391.5(the)-301.1(tw)10(o)-291.1(kinds)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(of)-250.9(N)30.1(A)-240.9(beha)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(dif)20.1(ferently)-230.9(with)-240.9(re)10(gard)-250.9(to)-240.9(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 16.9984 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nite)-250.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(es,)-220.8(as)-250.9(seen)-250.9(in)-240.9(\(44\).)]TJ -17.5545 -1.8971 TD [(\(44\))-1395.2(a.)-1455.4(Lance)-371.4(Armstrong,)-381.4(the)-361.3(c)10(yclist,)-371.4(is)-361.3(from)-361.3(T)70.3(e)10(xas,)-381.4(where)-371.4(he)-361.4(sometimes)]TJ 5.2095 -1.2045 TD [(trains)-250.9(with)-240.9(fello)20.1(w)-240.9(c)10(yclists.)]TJ -2.148 -1.5859 TD -0.0401 Tc (b.)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 167.04 305.7 Tm 0 Tc (#)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 173.16 301.26 Tm [(The)-331.2(c)10(yclist,)-331.2(Lance)-341.3(Armstrong,)-331.2(is)-321.2(from)-331.2(T)70.3(e)10(xas,)-341.3(where)-341.3(he)-321.2(sometimes)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(trains)-250.9(with)-240.9(fello)20.1(w)-240.9(c)10(yclists.)]TJ -5.2095 -1.8971 TD [(In)-341.3(general,)-361.4(speak)10(ers)-341.3(use)-341.3(a)-341.3(d)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 11.9054 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nite)-331.2(article)-341.3(in)-341.3(the)-331.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-321.2(part)-341.3(of)-341.3(an)-341.3(N)30.1(A)-331.2(when)]TJ -12.4615 -1.2145 TD [(the)-381.4(N)30.1(A)-381.4(e)10(xpresses)-381.4(an)-381.4(essential)-381.4(or)-381.4(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.9105 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(ning)-381.4(property)-381.4(of)-391.5(the)-381.4(anchor�)50.2(s)-381.4(denotation.)]TJ -15.4667 -1.2045 TD [(\(This)-281.1(property)-291.1(might)-281(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-281(little)-281(to)-291.1(do)-291.1(with)-281.1(furthering)-291.1(the)-291.1(ar)20.1(gument)-281(or)-291.1(narrati)20.1(v)10(e.\))]TJ T* [(Speak)10(ers)-341.3(use)-341.3(an)-331.2(inde)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 8.6121 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nite)-341.3(article)-331.2(in)-331.2(the)-341.3(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-311.2(part)-341.3(of)-331.2(an)-341.3(N)30.1(A)-331.2(when)-341.3(the)-331.2(N)30.1(A)]TJ -9.1683 -1.2145 TD [(e)10(xpresses)-331.2(a)-341.3(proposition)-311.2(that)-331.2(is)-331.2(essential)-331.2(to)-331.2(furthering)-331.2(the)-341.3(ar)20.1(gument)-331.2(or)-341.3(narrati)20.1(v)10(e)0(.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(\(The)-230.9(information)-220.8(might)-220.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(little)-220.8(to)-230.9(do)-230.9(with)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 17.9954 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(xing)-230.9(or)-240.9(understanding)-210.8(the)-240.9(meaning)]TJ -18.5515 -1.2145 TD [(of)-190.7(the)-190.7(anchor)50.2(.\))-281.1(There)-200.8(is)-190.7(not)-180.7(space)-190.7(to)-190.7(e)10(xplore)-190.7(the)-180.7(nature)-200.8(of)-190.7(these)-190.7(generalizations,)-190.7(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(free-v)20.1(ariation)-250.9(the)10(y)-250.9(predict)-250.9(when)-250.9(the)-261(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-230.9(is)-250.9(essential)-250.9(both)-250.9(to)-250.9(the)-250.9(anchor)-261(and)]TJ T* [(the)-301.1(narrati)20.1(v)10(e)0(,)-321.2(o)0(r)-311.2(the)-311.2(question)-291.1(of)-311.2(why)-301.1(the)-311.2(options)-291.1(are)-321.2(not)-301.1(a)20.1(v)20.1(ailable)-301.1(for)-311.2(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(relati)20.1(v)10(es.)-481.8(I)-321.2(note)-311.2(only)-301.1(that)-311.2(we)-311.2(are)-321.2(left)-311.2(helpless)-311.2(e)20.1(v)10(en)-301.1(to)-311.2(describe)-311.2(these)-311.2(f)10(acts)-321.2(if)-311.2(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(e)10(xamples)-230.9(in)-250.9(\(44\))-250.9(are)-250.9(vie)20.1(wed)-240.9(as)-250.9(semantically)-240.9(identical.)]TJ 15.7488 -2.4993 TD (25)Tj ET endstream endobj 95 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 97 0 obj << /Length 9233 >> stream BT /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(6)-996.8(A)-244(scope-shifting)-230(alter)13.9(nati)7(v)7(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 627.42 Tm [(Gi)20.1(v)10(e)0(n)-190.7(a)-210.8(rich)-210.8(and)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 6.6792 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(e)10(xible)-200.8(enough)-200.8(theory)-210.8(of)-210.8(intensionality)60.2(,)-180.7(i)0(t)-200.8(i)0(s)-210.8(possible)-190.7(to)-210.8(pro)10(vide)-190.7(a)]TJ -7.2353 -1.2145 TD [(semantics)-190.7(for)-200.8(N)30.1(A)0(s)-190.7(that)-190.7(meets)-200.8(the)-190.7(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 14.0747 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-190.7(in)-200.8(\(1\).)-291.1(Though)-190.7(such)-200.8(an)-200.7(account)-200.8(has)-190.7(not)]TJ -14.6308 -1.2045 TD [(to)-230.9(my)-230.9(kno)20.1(wledge)-220.8(been)-240.9(formulated)-230.9(yet,)-230.9(one)-240.9(can)-230.9(see)-240.9(ho)20.1(w)-230.9(i)0(t)-230.9(might)-220.8(go.)-301.1(The)-240.9(essential)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(step)-341.3(is)-341.3(the)-341.3(stipulation)-331.2(that)-341.3(N)30.1(A)0(s)-331.2(are)-361.4(al)10(w)10(ays)-341.3(e)20.1(v)20.1(aluated)-331.2(as)-351.3(though)-331.2(the)10(y)-341.3(were)-351.3(root-)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(le)20.1(v)10(e)0(l)-210.8(clauses.)-291.1(That)-220.8(is,)-220.8(we)-220.8(saturate)-220.8(their)-210.8(intensional)-210.8(ar)20.1(gument)-210.8(with)-210.8(the)-220.8(actual)-220.8(w)10(orld)]TJ T* [(\(or)-271(w)10(orld�time)-250.9(pair)40.1(,)-271(etc.\).)-371.4(The)-271(account)-271(requires)-261(a)-271(m)0(o)10(v)10(ement)-250.9(operation)-261(or)-271(a)-271(type-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(shifting)-321.2(equi)20.1(v)20.1(alent,)-341.3(for)-341.3(the)-341.3(simple)-321.2(reason)-341.3(that)-341.3(N)30.1(A)0(s)-331.2(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-331.2(both)-331.2(propositional)-321.2(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(indi)20.1(vidual)-250.9(components)-271(of)-281(meaning.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 14.5985 0 TD [(Chuc)20.1(k,)-291.1(a)-281(psyc)10(hopath)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.6624 0 TD [(denotes)-281(both)-271(the)-281.1(entity)]TJ -23.2609 -1.2045 TD [(Chuck)-391.5(and)-401.5(the)-391.5(proposition)-371.4(that)-391.5(Chuck)-391.5(is)-391.5(a)-401.5(psychopath.)-732.7(In)-391.5(a)-401.5(one-dimensional)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(theory)60.2(,)-261(multiple)-261(components)-250.9(of)-271(meaning)-261(can,)-281(to)-271(a)-271(limited)-261(e)10(xtent,)-261(be)-271(modelled)-261(by)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(mo)10(ving)-281(them,)-311.2(resulting)-291.1(in)-301.1(a)-301.1(kind)-301.1(of)-301.1(discontinuous)-281(constituent.)-451.7(In)-311.2(\(45\)�\(46\),)-311.2(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(proposition-denoting)-220.8(N)30.1(A)-240.9(is)-250.9(adjoined)-240.9(at)-250.9(the)-250.9(root)-250.9(le)20.1(v)10(e)0(l)-230.9(and)-250.9(syntactically)-240.9(associated)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(with)-240.9(an)-250.9(indi)20.1(vidual-denoting)-210.8(trace.)]TJ 0 -2.0376 TD [(\(45\))-1395.2(Sheila)-250.9(said)-240.9(that)-240.9(Chuck,)-250.9(a)-250.9(psychopath,)-240.9(is)-240.9(a)-261(suitable)-230.9(sitter)50.2(.)]TJ 0 -3.754 TD [(\(46\))-13410.1(S)]TJ /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 238.32 370.38 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 246.3213 370.38 Tm (w)Tj /F5 1 Tf 0.5967 0 TD (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (psycho)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 293.28 367.5 Tm (w)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 299.76 370.38 Tm (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (chuck)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.5662 0 TD (\))Tj /F1 1 Tf 0.6324 0 TD ()Tj /TT4 1 Tf -12.3126 -1.2145 TD (say)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 212.16 352.98 Tm (w)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 218.64 355.86 Tm (\()Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 223.3199 355.86 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 231.3213 355.86 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 239.28 360.18 Tm 0.0061 Tc ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 244.68 355.86 Tm 0 Tc (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (suitable-sitter)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 319.68 353.58 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 6.9738 0 0 6.9738 325.68 356.22 Tm 0.0003 Tc ()Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 330.48 355.86 Tm 0 Tc (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 340.44 353.94 Tm (1)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 345.48 355.86 Tm 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (sheila)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.4248 0 TD (\))Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 294.36 349.86 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.7588 -0.1205 TD ( )Tj -8.7567 1.2888 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.7468 -0.1205 TD (\012)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 197.04 323.1 Tm (DP)Tj 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 212.28 321.18 Tm (1)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 153.36 308.58 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 161.3613 308.58 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 169.32 313.02 Tm ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 172.44 308.58 Tm (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (psycho)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 212.28 305.7 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 6.9738 0 0 6.9738 218.28 308.34 Tm ()Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 221.16 308.58 Tm (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (chuck)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.5662 0 TD (\))Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 207.24 300.3 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.9516 -0.3854 TD (
)Tj -2.951 0.7829 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.9636 -0.3854 TD ()Tj /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 170.04 278.34 Tm (DP)Tj ET q 0.48 0 0 -12 177.468 272.448 cm /Im1 Do Q BT 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 162.12 246.54 Tm (Chuck)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 228.96 278.34 Tm (NP)Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 236.64 268.38 Tm (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.9997 -0.3975 TD (
)Tj 0.1566 -0.0602 TD (
)Tj -3.1558 0.8552 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.9997 -0.3975 TD ()Tj -0.1445 -0.0602 TD ()Tj ET q 62.76 0 0 -0.48 205.308 260.088 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 205.32 246.54 Tm [(a)-250.9(psychopath)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 378.24 323.1 Tm (S)Tj /TT10 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 285.96 308.58 Tm <0068>Tj /TT8 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 293.9613 308.58 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 301.92 313.02 Tm 0.0061 Tc ()Tj /F5 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 307.44 308.58 Tm 0 Tc (.)Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (say)Tj /F4 1 Tf 1.3791 0 TD (\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (suitable-sitter)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 403.68 306.3 Tm (w)Tj /F1 1 Tf 6.9738 0 0 6.9738 409.68 308.94 Tm 0.0003 Tc ()Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 414.48 308.58 Tm 0 Tc (\()Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.3915 0 TD (x)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 424.44 306.78 Tm (1)Tj /F4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 429.36 308.58 Tm 0.0026 Tc (\)\)\()Tj /TT4 1 Tf 1.1744 0 TD 0 Tc (sheila)Tj /F4 1 Tf 2.4348 0 TD (\))Tj /F2 1 Tf 9.9626 0 0 9.9626 381.6 302.58 Tm ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1566 TD ( )Tj 0.9997 -0.1686 TD ( )Tj 0.7709 -0.1325 TD ( )Tj -9.7685 1.4574 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1566 TD (\012)Tj -0.9997 -0.1686 TD (\012)Tj -0.7709 -0.1325 TD (\012)Tj ET q 194.64 0 0 -0.48 284.268 288.2881 cm /Im1 Do Q BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 284.28 274.14 Tm [(Sheila)-250.9(said)-240.9(that)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 360.2269 274.14 Tm (t)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 8.9664 0 0 8.9664 364.32 272.22 Tm (1)Tj 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 372.24 274.14 Tm [(is)-250.9(a)-250.9(suitable)-240.9(babysitter)]TJ 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 221.46 Tm [(In)-291.1(order)-301.1(to)-281.1(arri)20.1(v)10(e)-291.1(at)-291.1(this)-291.1(structure,)-291.1(we)-301.1(must)-281.1(appeal)-291.1(to)-291.1(a)-301.1(number)-281(of)-301.1(e)10(xtra)-291.1(assump-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(tions.)-602.3(First,)-381.4(the)-341.3(raised)-361.3(N)30.1(A)0(,)-341.3(though)-341.3(proposition-denoting,)-341.3(must)-341.3(lea)20.1(v)10(e)-351.3(behind)-351.3(an)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(indi)20.1(vidual-denoting)-331.2(trace)-381.4(that)-371.4(it)-361.4(does)-371.4(not)-361.4(bind)-371.4(in)-361.4(the)-371.4(semantic)-361.4(sense.)-682.6(A)-371.4(meta-)]TJ T* [(logical)-291.1(condition)-291.1(on)-301.1(admissible)-291.1(assignment)-291.1(functions)-291.1(must)-291.1(ensure)-311.2(that)-301.1(this)-291.1(trace)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(denotes)-240.9(the)-250.9(same)-240.9(indi)20.1(vidual)-230.9(that)-240.9(the)-250.9(anchor)-250.9(in)-240.9(the)-250.9(raised)-250.9(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-220.8(denotes.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD [(A)-200.8(second)-200.7(requirement:)-271(we)-210.8(must)-180.7(stipulate)-190.7(that)-200.8(the)-190.7(N)30.1(A)-200.8(al)10(w)10(ays)-200.7(raises)-190.7(to)-200.7(adjoin)-190.7(to)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(the)-220.8(root.)-301.1(As)-220.8(we�)50.2(v)10(e)-230.9(seen,)-230.9(N)30.1(A)0(s)-220.8(n)0(e)20.1(v)10(er)-220.8(appear)-230.9(in)-230.9(the)-220.8(scope)-230.9(of)-230.9(an)10(y)-220.8(other)-220.8(operator)50.2(.)-301.1(The)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(CI)-271(approach)-281(achie)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-261(this)-261(by)-261(ensuring)-261(that)-271(an)-271(N)30.1(A)110.4(�)50.2(s)-261(content)-261(cannot)-271(form)-261(\(part)-271(of\))]TJ 15.7488 -2.5495 TD (26)Tj ET endstream endobj 98 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 4 0 R /F2 23 0 R /F4 25 0 R /F5 26 0 R /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT10 65 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 10 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 100 0 obj << /Length 6397 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(the)-230.9(ar)20.1(gument)-220.8(to)-230.9(an)10(ything.)-281.1(On)-230.9(this)-220.8(scope-shifting)-210.8(alternati)20.1(v)10(e)0(,)-220.8(w)0(e)-240.9(must)-210.8(cash)-240.9(out)-220.8(the)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(f)10(acts)-311.2(in)-301.1(terms)-301.1(of)-311.2(obligatory)-291.1(widest-scope.)-471.8(The)-311.2(condition)-291.1(can)-311.2(be)-311.2(formulated)-301.1(as)-301.1(a)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(statement)-240.9(that)-250.9(an)10(y)-240.9(N)30.1(A)-250.9(appears)-250.9(as)-250.9(daughter)-250.9(to)-250.9(the)-250.9(root)-250.9(node)-240.9(syntactically)60.2(,)-240.9(roughly)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(as)-331.2(in)-331.2(the)-331.2(supplement-relation)-321.2(account)-331.2(rejected)-341.3(in)-321.2(section)-331.2(2.)-562.1(But)-341.3(this)-321.2(essentially)]TJ T* [(remo)10(v)10(e)0(s)-301.1(a)0(n)10(y)-311.2(genuine)-321.2(parallel)-311.2(between)-321.2(N)30.1(A)-321.2(interpretations)-301.1(and)-321.2(other)-311.2(e)10(xpressions)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(held)-250.9(to)-250.9(under)20.1(go)-250.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 9.0086 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-250.9(raising)-250.9(or)-250.9(an)-261(equi)20.1(v)20.1(alent.)-301.1(The)-261(closest)-240.9(e)10(xample)-250.9(is)-250.9(that)-250.9(of)]TJ -9.5648 -1.2045 TD (inde)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.7217 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nites,)-301.1(which)-301.1(can)-311.2(tak)10(e)-301.1(widest)-291.1(scope)-301.1(e)20.1(v)10(en)-291.1(when)-301.1(deeply)-301.1(embedded.)-461.7(But)-311.2(the)10(y)]TJ -2.2778 -1.2145 TD [(can)-210.8(also)-200.7(tak)10(e)-200.7(narro)20.1(w)-210.8(and)-200.8(intermediate)-200.8(scopes)-200.8(\(F)10(arkas,)-210.8(1981;)-190.7(Reinhart,)-210.8(1997\).)-291.1(This)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(v)20.1(ariability)-230.9(is)-240.9(precisely)-250.9(what)-240.9(moti)20.1(v)20.1(ates)-230.9(a)-250.9(scope-shifting)-230.9(account)-250.9(of)-250.9(them.)]TJ 1.4655 -1.2045 TD (My)Tj /TT6 1 Tf 1.6401 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nal)-250.9(objection)-250.9(is)-240.9(fundamental:)-311.2(\(46\))-250.9(denotes)-250.9(just)-240.9(one)-261(proposition)-230.9(\(a)-261(single)]TJ -3.6617 -1.2145 TD [(truth)-220.8(v)20.1(alue)-220.8(in)-220.8(a)-230.9(g)0(i)20.1(v)10(en)-210.8(w)10(orld\).)-301.1(But)-230.9(\(13\))-230.9(sho)20.1(ws)-210.8(that)-220.8(N)30.1(A)-220.8(content)-230.9(and)-220.8(at-issue)-220.8(content)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(can)-371.4(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-371.4(dif)20.1(ferent)-361.3(v)20.1(alues)-361.3(e)20.1(v)10(en)-361.4(in)-371.4(a)-371.4(single)-361.3(situation)-351.3(and)-371.4(utterance:)-542(the)-371.4(N)30.1(A)-361.3(can)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(be)-331.2(f)10(alse,)-341.3(the)-331.2(at-issue)-321.2(content)-321.2(true,)-351.3(or)-331.2(the)-321.2(re)20.1(v)10(erse.)-542(The)-331.2(analysis)-321.2(in)-321.2(\(46\))-331.2(is)-321.2(not)-321.2(so)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(e)10(xible.)-301.1(If)-250.9(either)-250.9(conjunct)-240.9(is)-240.9(f)10(alse,)-250.9(so)-250.9(is)-240.9(the)-250.9(whole.)]TJ 0.9093 -1.2045 TD [(W)80.3(e)-261(should)-250.9(ask)-261(what)-250.9(is)-261(right)-250.9(about)-250.9(the)-261(scope-shifting)-240.9(solution.)-321.2(Stepping)-261(back,)]TJ -1.4655 -1.2145 TD [(we)-321.2(see)-331.2(that)-321.2(some)-311.2(essential)-321.2(ingredients)-311.2(are)-331.2(here,)-341.3(b)20.1(u)0(t)-321.2(obscured)-321.2(by)-321.2(the)-321.2(formalism.)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(The)-190.7(special)-190.7(conditions)-170.6(we)-200.8(ha)20.1(v)10(e)-180.7(to)-190.7(place)-200.7(on)-180.7(ho)20.1(w)-190.7(N)30.1(As)-180.7(mo)10(v)10(e)-180.7(and)-190.7(what)-190.7(the)10(y)-180.7(associate)]TJ T* [(with)-301.1(are)-321.2(v)10(ersions)-291.1(of)-311.2(the)-311.2(le)10(xical)-301.1(marking)-301.1(that)-311.2(is)-301.1(achie)20.1(v)10(e)0(d)-301.1(i)0(n)-311.2(a)-311.2(single)-301.1(strok)10(e)-311.2(\(type)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(assignment\))-281(within)-291.1(the)-301.1(CI)-301.1(analysis.)-451.7(In)-301.1(order)-311.2(to)-291.1(bring)-291.1(the)-301.1(scope-shifting)-291.1(analysis)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(in)-341.3(line)-351.3(with)-341.3(the)-341.3(multidimensional)-321.2(insight)-331.2(\(1\))-351.3(e)10(xpresses,)-371.4(we)-351.3(must)-341.3(allo)20.1(w)-341.3(that)-341.3(the)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(propositional)-291.1(denotations)-311.2(of)-311.2(the)-321.2(root)-311.2(node�)50.2(s)-311.2(daughters)-311.2(remain)-321.2(separate.)-521.9(That)-311.2(is,)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(the)-311.2(structure)-311.2(itself)-311.2(should)-301.1(denote)-311.2(a)-321.2(pair)-321.2(of)-311.2(meanings.)-501.9(This)-301.1(is)-311.2(precisely)-321.2(what)-311.2(the)]TJ T* [(interpretation)-230.9(rule)-250.9(\(28\))-250.9(achie)20.1(v)10(es.)]TJ /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 295.62 Tm [(7)-996.8(Conclusion)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 268.86 Tm [(Until)-311.2(recently)60.2(,)-351.3(con)40.2(v)10(entional)-311.2(implicatures)-311.2(appeared)-331.2(in)-331.2(danger)-331.2(of)-331.2(getting)-311.2(dropped)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(entirely)-341.3(from)-341.3(semantic)-341.3(theory)60.2(,)-361.4(o)0(r)-351.3(else)-341.3(sw)10(allo)20.1(wed)-341.3(up)-341.3(\(via)-351.3(shifts)-331.2(in)-341.3(terminology\))]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(by)-291.1(other)-291.1(mechanisms.)-431.6(But)-291.1(when)-301.1(we)-291.1(return)-301.1(to)-291.1(Grice�)50.2(s)-291.1(\(1975\))-291.1(de)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 25.7645 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nition)-281.1(and)-301.1(con-)]TJ -26.3206 -1.2145 TD [(sider)-331.2(its)-331.2(entailments)-321.2(closely)60.2(,)-351.3(w)0(e)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 13.3631 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(nd)-341.3(that)-331.2(CIs)-341.3(are)-351.3(both)-331.2(irreducibly)-331.2(distinct)-321.2(from)]TJ -13.9193 -1.2045 TD [(other)-271(meanings)-271(and)-271(widely)-271(attested)-271(in)-271(natural)-271(language.)-391.5(What�)50.2(s)-271(more,)-281(the)-271(multi-)]TJ T* [(dimensional)-190.7(approach)-220.8(that)-210.8(Karttunen)-210.8(and)-220.8(Peters)-220.8(\(1979\))-210.8(introduced)-200.7(into)-210.8(linguistics)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(pro)10(vides)-250.9(the)-261(basis)-261(for)-261(a)-271(satisf)10(actory)-250.9(formalization.)-341.3(By)-271(separating)-261(the)-261(at-issue)-261(and)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(CI)-200.7(dimensions,)-180.7(we)-200.8(achie)20.1(v)10(e)-190.7(the)-190.7(needed)-200.8(independence)-190.7(of)-200.8(the)-190.7(tw)10(o)-190.7(classes)-190.7(of)-200.7(meaning)]TJ T* [(without)-230.9(further)-250.9(stipulation.)]TJ 15.7488 -5.3098 TD (27)Tj ET endstream endobj 101 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 103 0 obj << /Length 4795 >> stream BT /TT4 1 Tf 17.2154 0 0 17.2154 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(Refer)20.9(ences)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 627.42 Tm [(Aoun,)-230.9(Joseph)-230.9(and)-240.9(Lina)-230.9(Choueiri.)-240.9(2000.)-321.2(Epithets.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.8144 0 TD [(Natur)10(al)-230.9(Langua)10(g)10(e)-230.9(and)-230.9(Linguis-)]TJ -18.8407 -1.2145 TD [(tic)-250.9(Theory)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.3344 0 TD (18\(1\):1�39.)Tj -5.308 -2.0376 TD [(Aoun,)-291.1(Joseph,)-291.1(Lina)-291.1(Choueiri,)-301.1(and)-291.1(Norbert)-281(Hornstein.)-281(2001.)-491.8(Resumption,)-281.1(mo)10(v)10(e)0(-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(ment,)-240.9(and)-250.9(deri)20.1(v)20.1(ational)-230.9(economy)60.2(.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 13.3584 0 TD [(Linguistic)-230.9(Inquiry)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.4161 0 TD (32\(3\):371�403.)Tj -21.7481 -2.0376 TD [(Bach,)-250.9(K)20.1(ent.)-230.9(1999.)-341.3(The)-240.9(myth)-230.9(of)-240.9(con)40.1(v)10(entional)-220.8(implicature.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 23.1882 0 TD [(Linguistics)-220.8(and)-240.9(Philos-)]TJ -22.2146 -1.2045 TD (ophy)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.1948 0 TD (22\(4\):367�421.)Tj -3.1684 -2.0476 TD [(Barwise,)-341.3(Jon)-311.2(and)-321.2(John)-311.2(Perry)60.2(.)-321.2(1983.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 15.033 0 TD [(Situations)-301.1(and)-311.2(Attitudes)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.668 0 TD [(.)-562.1(Cambridge,)-331.2(MA:)]TJ -23.7273 -1.2045 TD [(MIT)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.2(,)-351.3(Da)20.1(vid)-331.2(Ian.)-331.2(1997.)-612.3(Presupposition.)-602.2(In)-331.2(Johan)-321.2(v)20.1(a)0(n)-321.2(Benthem)-331.2(and)-331.2(Alice)-331.2(ter)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2045 TD [(Meulen,)-321.2(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 5.7901 0 TD [(Handbook)-301.1(of)-311.2(Lo)10(gic)-311.2(and)-311.2(Langua)10(g)10(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 13.9262 0 TD [(,)-321.2(939�1008.)-301.1(Cambridge,)-321.2(MA)]TJ -19.7163 -1.2045 TD [(and)-250.9(Amsterdam:)-301.1(MIT)-240.9(Press)-250.9(and)-250.9(North-Holland.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Bea)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)40.2(,)-361.4(Da)20.1(vid)-321.2(Ian.)-331.2(2001.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.848 0 TD [(Pr)40.1(esupposition)-301.1(and)-331.2(Assertion)-311.2(in)-331.2(Dynamic)-331.2(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 21.3417 0 TD (.)Tj -31.2161 -1.2045 TD [(Stanford,)-250.9(MA:)-240.9(CSLI.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Bo)-60.2(�)]TJ 1.1688 0 TD [(er)40.2(,)-281.1(Ste)20.1(v)10(e)0(n)-261(E)0(.)-271(and)-271(W)40.1(illiam)-250.9(G.)-271(L)50.2(ycan.)-261(1976.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.4287 0 TD [(The)-271(Myth)-271(of)-271(Semantic)-261(Pr)40.1(esupposi-)]TJ -17.6239 -1.2045 TD (tion)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.5557 0 TD [(.)-351.3(Bloomington,)-230.9(IN:)-250.9(Indiana)-240.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(Linguistics)-230.9(Club)40.2(.)]TJ -2.5293 -2.0376 TD [(Chierchia,)-250.9(Gennaro.)-250.9(2004.)-351.3(Scalar)-261(implicatures,)-230.9(polarity)-240.9(phenomena,)-250.9(and)-240.9(the)-250.9(syn-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(tax/pragmatics)-281.1(interf)10(ace.)-501.9(In)-291.1(Adriana)-291.1(Belletti,)-291.1(ed.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 20.2725 0 TD [(Structur)40.1(es)-281.1(and)-291.1(Be)30.1(yond)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.1113 0 TD [(.)-291.1(Ox-)]TJ -29.3837 -1.2045 TD [(ford:)-311.2(Oxford)-250.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-220.8(Press.)-361.3([The)-250.9(manuscript)-240.9(be)10(gan)-240.9(circulating)-240.9(in)-240.9(2001].)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Chierchia,)-311.2(Gennaro)-301.1(and)-301.1(Sally)-291.1(McConnell-Ginet.)-291.1(1990.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 22.6413 0 TD [(Meaning)-291.1(and)-291.1(Gr)10(ammar)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 9.5716 0 TD (.)Tj -31.2393 -1.2145 TD [(Cambridge,)-250.9(MA:)-240.9(MIT)-250.9(Press.)-361.3(P)10(age)-250.9(references)-261(to)-240.9(the)-250.9(2)-250.9(ed.,)-240.9(2000,)-240.9(MIT)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Cooper)40.2(,)-230.9(Robin.)-210.8(1983.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 8.8212 0 TD (Quanti)Tj /TT9 1 Tf 2.7778 0 TD (�)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5 0 TD [(cation)-200.8(and)-210.8(Syntactic)-210.8(Theory)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.1199 0 TD [(.)-301.1(Dordrecht:)-291.1(D.)-220.8(Reidel.)]TJ -23.2189 -2.0477 TD [(Culico)10(v)10(e)0(r)40.1(,)-240.9(Peter)-261(W)90.3(.)-250.9(1992.)-361.4(English)-230.9(tag)-250.9(questions)-240.9(and)-250.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersal)-230.9(Grammar)50.2(.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 29.6093 0 TD (Lingua)Tj /TT2 1 Tf -28.6357 -1.2045 TD (88\(1\):21�54.)Tj -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Dekk)10(er)40.1(,)-281(P)10(aul.)-271(2002.)-582.2(A)-271(proper)-281(architecture)-271(for)-281.1(presupposition)-250.9(and)-271(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 29.2196 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5561 0 TD (cation,)Tj -28.8021 -1.2145 TD [(Ms.,)-240.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(of)-250.9(Amsterdam.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Durrell,)-311.2(Martin.)-291.1(1995.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.4836 0 TD [(Hammer�)40.1(s)-301.1(German)-301.1(Gr)10(ammar)-281(and)-301.1(Usa)10(g)10(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 16.6132 0 TD [(.)-522(Lincolnw)10(ood,)]TJ -25.1231 -1.2145 TD [(IL:)-250.9(NTC)-250.9(Publishing)-230.9(Compan)10(y)60.2(,)-240.9(2)-240.9(ed.)]TJ 14.7752 -3.5432 TD (28)Tj ET endstream endobj 104 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT4 6 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT9 19 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 106 0 obj << /Length 4724 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(Elbourne,)-351.3(P)10(aul.)-341.3(2001.)-642.4(E-type)-341.3(anaphora)-341.3(as)-341.3(NP-deletion.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 23.4301 0 TD [(Natur)10(al)-331.2(Langua)10(g)10(e)-331.2(Se-)]TJ -22.4565 -1.2045 TD (mantics)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.3517 0 TD (9\(3\):241�288.)Tj -4.3254 -2.0476 TD [(Emonds,)-261(Joseph)-261(E.)-271(1976.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.5754 0 TD [(A)-271(T)50.2(r)10(ansformational)-230.9(Appr)40.1(oac)10(h)-250.9(t)0(o)-271(English)-261(Syntax)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 19.2852 0 TD 0.4216 Tc [(.N)421.6(e)441.7(w)]TJ -28.887 -1.2045 TD 0 Tc [(Y)110.4(ork:)-311.2(Academic)-240.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Emonds,)-401.5(Joseph)-381.4(E.)-381.4(1979.)-793(Appositi)20.1(v)10(e)-361.4(relati)20.1(v)10(e)0(s)-371.4(h)0(a)20.1(v)10(e)-381.4(n)0(o)-381.4(properties.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 28.4285 0 TD (Linguistic)Tj -27.4548 -1.2045 TD (Inquiry)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.1948 0 TD (10\(2\):211�243.)Tj -4.1684 -2.0376 TD [(F)10(arkas,)-381.4(Donka)-351.3(F)80.3(.)-361.3(1981.)-692.6(Quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 13.0562 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-351.3(scope)-351.3(and)-361.4(syntactic)-341.3(islands.)-682.5(In)-361.3(Roberta)-361.3(A.)]TJ -12.6387 -1.2145 TD [(Hendrick,)-291.1(Carrie)-281(S.)-291.1(Masek,)-281(and)-281(Mary)-271(Frances)-291.1(Miller)40.1(,)-281(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 24.003 0 TD [(Pr)40.2(oceedings)-261(of)-281.1(the)]TJ -24.003 -1.2045 TD [(17th)-240.9(Chica)10(go)-250.9(Linguistics)-230.9(Society)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 13.156 0 TD [(,)-250.9(59�66.)-240.9(Chicago:)-301.1(CLS.)]TJ -14.1297 -2.0376 TD [(Gamut,)-421.6(L.)-401.5(T)70.3(.)-391.5(F)80.3(.)-401.5(1991.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.0381 0 TD -0.0009 Tc [(Logic,)-442.6(Langu)]TJ 5.5156 0 TD -0.0057 Tc [(age,)-427.3(and)]TJ 3.9868 0 TD 0 Tc (Meaning)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.5547 0 TD [(,)-421.6(V)130.5(olume)-391.5(1.)-833.1(Chicago:)]TJ -22.1215 -1.2145 TD [(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(of)-250.9(Chicago)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Green,)-351.3(Mitchell)-311.2(S.)-341.3(2000.)-602.3(Illocutionary)-321.2(force)-331.2(and)-331.2(semantic)-321.2(content.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 28.0605 0 TD (Linguistics)Tj -27.0869 -1.2145 TD [(and)-250.9(Philosophy)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 6.4813 0 TD (23\(5\):435�473.)Tj -7.4549 -2.0376 TD [(Grice,)-311.2(H.)-301.1(P)10(aul.)-301.1(1975.)-521.9(Logic)-301.1(and)-301.1(con)40.1(v)10(ersation.)-511.9(In)-301.1(Peter)-311.2(Cole)-301.1(and)-301.1(Jerry)-311.2(Mor)20.1(gan,)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2045 TD (eds.,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 2.1442 0 TD [(Syntax)-301.1(and)-301.1(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.8225 0 TD [(,)-301.1(V)130.5(olume)-291.1(3:)-411.5(Speech)-311.2(Acts,)-311.2(43�58.)-291.1(Ne)20.1(w)-301.1(Y)110.4(ork:)-411.5(Aca-)]TJ -10.9666 -1.2145 TD [(demic)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Halv)20.1(orsen,)-411.5(Per)20.1(-Kristian)-381.4(and)-381.4(W)40.1(illiam)-371.4(A.)-381.4(Ladusa)10(w)60.2(.)-361.3(1979.)-782.9(Montague�)50.2(s)-371.4(�Uni)20.1(v)10(e)0(r)20.1(-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(sal)-381.4(grammar�:)-572.1(An)-381.4(introduction)-361.4(for)-391.5(the)-381.4(linguist.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 20.3117 0 TD [(Linguistics)-371.4(and)-371.4(Philosophy)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf -20.3117 -1.2045 TD (3\(2\):185�223.)Tj -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Heim,)-331.2(Irene.)-341.3(1983.)-592.2(On)-321.2(the)-321.2(projection)-321.2(problem)-311.2(for)-331.2(presuppositions.)-582.2(In)-321.2(Michael)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(Barlo)20.1(w)60.2(,)-250.9(Daniel)-250.9(P)110.4(.)-261(Flickinger)40.1(,)-250.9(and)-261(Michael)-250.9(T)70.3(.)-250.9(W)80.3(escoat,)-250.9(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 24.0395 0 TD [(Pr)40.1(oceedings)-240.9(of)-250.9(the)]TJ -24.0395 -1.2045 TD [(2nd)-371.4(W)90.3(est)-361.3(Coast)-371.4(Confer)40.1(ence)-371.4(on)-371.4(F)100.4(ormal)-351.3(Linguistics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 20.7442 0 TD [(,)-381.4(114�125.)-361.4(Stanford,)-391.5(MA:)]TJ -20.7442 -1.2145 TD [(Stanford)-250.9(Linguistics)-230.9(Association.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Heim,)-240.9(Irene.)-261(1992.)-351.3(Presupposition)-240.9(projection)-240.9(and)-250.9(the)-240.9(semantics)-240.9(of)-250.9(attitude)-240.9(v)10(erbs.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 0.9736 -1.2045 TD [(J)20.1(ournal)-240.9(of)-240.9(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.646 0 TD (9\(2\):183�221.)Tj -9.6196 -2.0476 TD [(Heim,)-421.6(Irene)-391.5(and)-391.5(Angelika)-381.4(Kratzer)50.2(.)-391.5(1998.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.8726 0 TD [(Semantics)-381.4(in)-381.4(Gener)10(ative)-381.4(Gr)10(ammar)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 14.3439 0 TD (.)Tj -31.2429 -1.2045 TD [(Oxford:)-311.2(Blackwell)-250.9(Publishers.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Herzber)20.1(ger)40.1(,)-291.1(Hans)-271(G.)-281(1973.)-431.6(Dimensions)-250.9(of)-281.1(truth.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.9516 0 TD [(J)20.1(ournal)-261(of)-271(Philosophical)-250.9(Lo)10(gic)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf -18.9779 -1.2145 TD (2\(4\):535�556.)Tj 14.7752 -4.2057 TD (29)Tj ET endstream endobj 107 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 109 0 obj << /Length 4930 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(Horn,)-511.9(Laurence)-471.8(R.)-471.8(1991.)-1043.9(When)-461.7(ne)20.1(w)-461.7(content)-451.7(isn�)20.1(t.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 23.0945 0 TD [(J)20.1(ournal)-451.7(of)-461.7(Pr)10(a)10(gmatics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf -22.1209 -1.2045 TD (15\(4\):313�336.)Tj -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Huddleston,)-220.8(Rodne)10(y)-230.9(and)-240.9(Geof)20.1(fre)10(y)-230.9(K)0(.)-230.9(Pullum.)-230.9(2002.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 21.0525 0 TD [(The)-240.9(Cambridg)10(e)-230.9(G)0(r)10(ammar)-220.8(of)]TJ -20.0788 -1.2045 TD [(the)-250.9(English)-230.9(Langua)10(g)10(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.7391 0 TD [(.)-361.3(Cambridge:)-301.1(Cambridge)-250.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-220.8(Press.)]TJ -9.7127 -2.0476 TD [(Karttunen,)-401.5(Lauri.)-381.4(1973.)-772.9(Presuppositions)-361.3(and)-381.4(compound)-371.4(sentences.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 28.438 0 TD (Linguistic)Tj -27.4643 -1.2045 TD (Inquiry)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.1948 0 TD (4\(2\):169�193.)Tj -4.1684 -2.0376 TD [(Karttunen,)-261(Lauri.)-261(1976.)-391.5(Discourse)-261(referents.)-411.5(In)-261(James)-261(D.)-261(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-250.9(ed.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 29.8017 0 TD (Syntax)Tj -28.8281 -1.2145 TD [(and)-311.2(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 5.8659 0 TD [(,)-321.2(V)130.5(olume)-301.1(7:)-431.6(Notes)-311.2(from)-311.2(the)-311.2(Linguistic)-291.1(Under)20.1(ground,)-321.2(363�385.)]TJ -5.8659 -1.2045 TD [(Ne)20.1(w)-250.9(Y)110.4(ork:)-301.1(Academic)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Karttunen,)-261(Lauri)-271(and)-271(Stanle)10(y)-261(Peters.)-271(1979.)-421.6(Con)40.1(v)10(entional)-250.9(implicature.)-411.5(In)-271(Choon-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(K)20.1(y)0(u)-301.1(O)0(h)-291.1(and)-301.1(Da)20.1(vid)-301.1(A.)-301.1(Dinneen,)-311.2(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 15.3527 0 TD [(Syntax)-301.1(and)-291.1(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.8124 0 TD [(,)-311.2(V)130.5(olume)-291.1(11:)-411.5(Pre-)]TJ -24.1651 -1.2045 TD [(supposition,)-230.9(1�56.)-240.9(Ne)20.1(w)-240.9(Y)110.4(ork:)-311.2(Academic)-240.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Klein,)-381.4(Ew)10(an)-371.4(and)-361.3(Iv)20.1(an)-361.4(A.)-361.3(Sag.)-371.4(1985.)-712.7(T)80.3(ype-dri)20.1(v)10(e)0(n)-351.3(translation.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 26.1993 0 TD [(Linguistics)-351.3(and)]TJ -25.2257 -1.2045 TD (Philosophy)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 4.7404 0 TD (8\(2\):163�201.)Tj -5.7141 -2.0376 TD [(Krahmer)40.2(,)-250.9(Emiel.)-240.9(1998.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 9.4949 0 TD [(Pr)40.1(esupposition)-220.8(and)-240.9(Anaphor)10(a)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.9672 0 TD [(.)-341.3(Stanford,)-250.9(MA:)-240.9(CSLI.)]TJ -21.4621 -2.0476 TD [(Kratzer)40.1(,)-913.4(Angelika.)-772.9(1999.)-2037.6(Be)10(yond)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 16.9705 0 TD [(ouc)10(h)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.7067 0 TD (and)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 2.2268 0 TD (oops)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 1.8892 0 TD [(:)-1355.1(H)0(o)20.1(w)-762.8(descripti)20.1(v)10(e)]TJ -22.8195 -1.2045 TD [(and)-722.7(e)10(xpressi)20.1(v)10(e)-712.7(meaning)-712.7(interact.)-722.7(A)-722.7(comment)-712.7(on)-712.7(Da)20.1(vid)-722.7(Kaplan�)50.2(s)-712.7(pa-)]TJ 0 -1.2145 TD [(per)-642.4(Cornell)-632.4(Conference)-642.4(on)-632.4(Theories)-632.4(of)-632.4(Conte)10(xt)-622.3(Dependenc)10(y)60.2(.)-2529.4(URL)]TJ /TT12 1 Tf 0 -1.2045 TD [(http://semanticsarchive.net/Arc)10(hive)10(/WEwN)10(GUyO)10(/)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 26.9642 0 TD (.)Tj -27.9379 -2.0376 TD [(Le)20.1(vinson,)-421.6(Stephen)-401.5(C.)-411.5(1983.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 12.418 0 TD [(Pr)10(a)10(gmatics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 4.5908 0 TD [(.)-833.1(Cambridge:)-612.3(Cambridge)-401.5(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)]TJ -16.0352 -1.2145 TD (Press.)Tj -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-210.8(James)-220.8(D.)-220.8(1982.)-291.1(P)10(arentheticals)-220.8(and)-220.8(discontinuous)-200.7(structure.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 28.4473 0 TD (Linguistic)Tj -27.4737 -1.2145 TD (Inquiry)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.1948 0 TD (13\(1\):91�106.)Tj -4.1684 -2.0376 TD [(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-240.9(James)-240.9(D.)-250.9(1987.)-361.4(Some)-250.9(additional)-230.9(e)20.1(vidence)-250.9(for)-250.9(discontinuity)60.2(.)-331.2(I)0(n)-250.9(Geof-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2045 TD [(fre)10(y)-261(J)0(.)-261(Huck)-261(and)-261(Almerindo)-250.9(E.)-261(Ojeda,)-271(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.6007 0 TD [(Syntax)-261(and)-250.9(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 8.7321 0 TD [(,)-261(V)130.5(olume)-250.9(20:)]TJ -26.3328 -1.2145 TD [(Discontinuous)-230.9(Constituenc)10(y)60.2(,)-230.9(185�200.)-230.9(Orlando,)-240.9(FL:)-250.9(Academic)-250.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-461.7(James)-421.6(D.)-421.6(1989.)-933.5(Indi)20.1(viduation)-401.5(in)-421.6(and)-431.6(of)-421.6(syntactic)-421.6(structures.)-933.5(In)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2045 TD [(Mark)-240.9(R.)-240.9(Baltin)-240.9(and)-230.9(Anthon)10(y)-220.8(S)0(.)-240.9(Kroch,)-240.9(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.7464 0 TD [(Alternative)-230.9(Conceptions)-230.9(of)-230.9(Phr)10(ase)]TJ -17.7464 -1.2145 TD [(Structur)40.2(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 3.6815 0 TD [(,)-240.9(117�138.)-240.9(Chicago:)-301.1(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(of)-250.9(Chicago)-250.9(Press.)]TJ 11.0937 -4.2057 TD (30)Tj ET endstream endobj 110 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT8 9 0 R /TT12 111 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 113 0 obj << /Length 5532 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(McCa)10(wle)10(y)60.2(,)-441.7(James)-401.5(D.)-421.6(1998.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 12.3614 0 TD [(The)-421.6(Syntactic)-401.5(Phenomena)-411.5(of)-401.5(English)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 15.3554 0 TD [(.)-873.3(Chicago:)]TJ -26.7431 -1.2045 TD [(Chicago)-250.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(Press,)-250.9(2)-250.9(ed.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Montague,)-291.1(Richard.)-301.1(1970.)-511.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersal)-281(grammar)50.2(.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 19.524 0 TD (Theoria)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 3.4581 0 TD [(36:373�398.)-491.8(Reprinted)]TJ -22.0085 -1.2045 TD [(in)-250.9(Montague)-240.9(\(1974\),)-240.9(222�246.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Montague,)-240.9(Richard.)-250.9(1973.)-361.3(The)-250.9(proper)-261(treatment)-240.9(of)-250.9(quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 23.1001 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(cation)-240.9(in)-250.9(ordinary)-250.9(En-)]TJ -22.6826 -1.2045 TD [(glish.)-572.1(In)-321.2(Jaakk)10(o)-321.2(Hintikka,)-321.2(Julius)-311.2(Matthe)20.1(w)-301.1(Emil)-311.2(Mora)20.1(vcisk,)-331.2(and)-321.2(P)10(atrick)-311.2(Sup-)]TJ T* [(pes,)-371.4(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 4.1588 0 TD [(Appr)40.1(oac)10(hes)-331.2(to)-341.3(Natur)10(al)-331.2(Langua)10(g)10(e)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 13.59 0 TD [(,)-371.4(221�242.)-331.2(Dordrecht:)-501.9(D.)-351.3(Reidel.)]TJ -17.7487 -1.2145 TD [(Reprinted)-250.9(in)-250.9(Montague)-230.9(\(1974\),)-250.9(247�270.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(Montague,)-261(Richard.)-261(1974.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.8937 0 TD [(F)100.4(ormal)-250.9(Philosophy:)-331.2(Selected)-261(P)80.3(aper)10(s)-261(o)0(f)-261(Ric)10(har)40.1(d)-250.9(Mon-)]TJ -9.92 -1.2045 TD [(ta)10(gue)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 2.2116 0 TD [(.)-341.3(N)0(e)20.1(w)-240.9(Ha)20.1(v)10(en,)-230.9(CT)50.2(:)-240.9(Y)100.4(ale)-250.9(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-210.8(Press.)-351.3(Edited)-230.9(and)-240.9(with)-230.9(an)-250.9(introduction)]TJ -2.2116 -1.2145 TD [(by)-250.9(Richmond)-240.9(H.)-250.9(Thomason.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0376 TD [(P)10(artee,)-381.4(Barbara)-361.4(H.)-351.3(1999.)-672.5(W)80.3(eak)-351.3(NP�)50.2(s)-351.3(i)0(n)-351.3(H)0(A)130.5(V)0(E)-341.3(sentences.)-682.5(In)-351.3(Jelle)-341.3(Gerbrandy)60.2(,)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD [(Maarten)-361.4(de)-361.3(Rijk)10(e,)-381.4(and)-361.4(Yde)-361.4(V)110.4(enema,)-381.4(eds.,)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 17.6956 0 TD [(JF)110.4(AK:)-361.4(Essays)-351.3(dedicated)-351.3(to)-351.3(Johan)]TJ -17.6956 -1.2045 TD [(van)-331.2(Bentham)-311.2(on)-331.2(the)-321.2(Occasion)-321.2(of)-321.2(his)-321.2(50th)-311.2(Birthday)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 20.7888 0 TD [(.)-311.2(V)130.5(ossiuspers:)-451.7(Amsterdam)]TJ -20.7888 -1.2045 TD [(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-230.9(Press.)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0476 TD [(Potts,)-652.4(Christopher)50.2(.)-562.1(2002a.)-1395.2(The)-582.2(le)10(xical)-562.1(semantics)-572.1(of)-572.1(parenthetical-)]TJ 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 460.5359 387.66 Tm (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 481.622 387.66 Tm (and)Tj -30.0374 -1.2045 TD [(appositi)20.1(v)10(e)0(-)]TJ 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 175.2811 373.26 Tm (Which)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 207.1479 373.26 Tm (.)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 0.5812 0 TD (Syntax)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 2.9165 0 TD (5\(1\):55�88.)Tj -11.5501 -2.0476 TD [(Potts,)-250.9(Christopher)50.2(.)-250.9(2002b.)-371.4(The)-261(syntax)-250.9(and)-261(semantics)-250.9(of)]TJ 11.9552 0 1.9965 11.9552 379.3481 348.78 Tm (As)Tj 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 393.5942 348.78 Tm (-parentheticals.)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 6.5172 0 TD (Natu-)Tj -29.1914 -1.2045 TD [(r)10(a)0(l)-240.9(Langua)10(g)10(e)-240.9(and)-250.9(Linguistic)-230.9(Theory)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 14.6849 0 TD (20\(3\):623�689.)Tj -15.6586 -2.0376 TD [(Potts,)-210.8(Christopher)50.2(.)-210.8(2005.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.1151 0 TD [(The)-220.8(Lo)10(gic)-210.8(of)-210.8(Con)40.1(ventional)-210.8(Implicatur)40.2(es)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 15.7614 0 TD [(.)-271(Oxford)-210.8(Studies)]TJ -24.9028 -1.2145 TD [(in)-200.8(Theoretical)-200.7(Linguistics.)-180.7(Oxford:)-281.1(Oxford)-200.8(Uni)20.1(v)10(ersity)-180.7(Press.)-271([Re)20.1(vised)-200.8(2003)-190.7(UC)]TJ 0 -1.2045 TD [(Santa)-261(Cruz)-250.9(PhD)-250.9(thesis].)]TJ -0.9736 -2.0477 TD [(Reinhart,)-301.1(T)80.3(a)0(n)10(ya.)-281(1997.)-481.8(Quanti)]TJ /TT6 1 Tf 12.3872 0 TD (�)Tj /TT2 1 Tf 0.5562 0 TD [(er)-291.1(scope:)-391.5(Ho)20.1(w)-281(labor)-291.1(is)-281(di)20.1(vided)-271(between)-291.1(QR)-301.1(and)]TJ -11.9697 -1.2045 TD [(choice)-250.9(functions.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 7.1833 0 TD [(Linguistics)-230.9(and)-240.9(Philosophy)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.1018 0 TD (20\(4\):335�397.)Tj -19.2588 -2.0376 TD [(v)20.1(a)0(n)-240.9(der)-250.9(Sandt,)-250.9(Rob)40.1(.)-250.9(1988.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 10.7003 0 TD [(Conte)20.1(xt)-250.9(and)-240.9(Pr)40.1(esupposition)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 11.0976 0 TD [(.)-331.2(London:)-301.1(Croom)-250.9(Helm.)]TJ -21.798 -2.0476 TD [(v)20.1(a)0(n)-200.7(der)-220.8(Sandt,)-220.8(Rob)40.1(.)-210.8(1992.)-271(Presupposition)-200.7(projection)-200.8(as)-210.8(anaphora)-220.8(resolution.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 30.3197 0 TD [(J)20.1(our)20.1(-)]TJ -29.3461 -1.2045 TD [(nal)-250.9(of)-240.9(Semantics)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 6.8431 0 TD (9\(4\):333�377.)Tj -7.8167 -2.0376 TD [(Soames,)-311.2(Scott.)-291.1(1989.)-511.9(Presupposition.)-501.9(In)-301.1(Do)10(v)-291.1(M)0(.)-291.1(Gabbay)-301.1(and)-301.1(Franz)-301.1(Guenthner)40.1(,)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2145 TD (eds.,)Tj /TT8 1 Tf 2.1642 0 TD [(Handbook)-301.1(of)-311.2(Philosophical)-291.1(Lo)10(gic)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 13.6702 0 TD [(,)-331.2(V)130.5(olume)-301.1(IV)70.3(:)-311.2(T)80.3(opics)-311.2(in)-311.2(the)-311.2(Philosophy)]TJ -15.8344 -1.2045 TD [(of)-250.9(Language,)-250.9(553�616.)-230.9(Dordrecht:)-311.2(Kluwer)50.2(.)]TJ 14.7752 -3.0012 TD (31)Tj ET endstream endobj 114 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT6 8 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 117 0 obj << /Length 639 >> stream BT /TT2 1 Tf 11.9552 0 0 11.9552 110.88 654.1801 Tm 0 g /GS1 gs 0 Tc 0 Tw [(Steedman,)-371.4(Mark.)-351.3(2000.)-672.5(Information)-341.3(structure)-341.3(and)-351.3(the)-351.3(syntax�phonology)-321.2(inter)20.1(-)]TJ 0.9736 -1.2045 TD [(f)10(ace.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 2.2759 0 TD [(Linguistic)-230.9(Inquiry)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf 7.4261 0 TD (31\(4\):649�689.)Tj -10.6757 -2.0476 TD [(Thorne,)-261(James)-261(Peter)50.2(.)-271(1972.)-401.5(On)-271(nonrestricti)20.1(v)10(e)-240.9(relati)20.1(v)10(e)-250.9(clauses.)]TJ /TT8 1 Tf 25.2506 0 TD [(Linguistic)-250.9(Inquiry)]TJ /TT2 1 Tf -24.277 -1.2045 TD (3\(4\):552�556.)Tj 14.7752 -42.7497 TD (32)Tj ET endstream endobj 118 0 obj << /ProcSet [/PDF /Text ] /Font << /TT2 5 0 R /TT8 9 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 11 0 R >> >> endobj 10 0 obj << /Type /XObject /Subtype /Image /Width 1 /Height 1 /BitsPerComponent 1 /ImageMask true /Length 2 >> stream endstream endobj 11 0 obj << /Type /ExtGState /SA false /SM 0.02 /OP false /op false /OPM 1 /BG2 /Default /UCR2 /Default /HT /Default /TR2 /Default >> endobj 119 0 obj << /Type /FontDescriptor /Ascent 0 /CapHeight 0 /Descent 0 /Flags 68 /FontBBox [-29 -960 1116 775] /FontName /MMGDFO+CMSY10 /ItalicAngle -14.035 /StemV 85 /StemH 40 /CharSet (/asteriskmath/bullet/angbracketleft/angbracketright/logicalor/logicalnot/logicaland/element/braceleft/braceright/negationslash/prime/periodcentered/universal/arrowright) /FontFile3 120 0 R >> endobj 120 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 1476 /Subtype /Type1C >> stream H�TS}le�[wm�Q&��\�]A&�J6X� D%���B����V�ڭ-ck���^۷׮_�1�1>� ,� �8M�@!��D3>$!����6@1�?�{�����=�s8VX��8���YT���w45�֕����JqaR!u}�dSQ��V�Ƨ���&`�x�u1<�z��zV���&��Y6O�l���q�Ū3�-ۚ��F��l�i�74Z���&�Πk��F]�֪7-��q�Q�Cg�h S��Nk���X��ZcC�Y[�Mg5�����"jLͭ������y��6��uZ��F�։F`ԫLuz��u�z���^9�E�Rgљw趼�13��f�p_!����m������d���ٕU�7n�oh�cŢeX!6�n�U� �T /��nHޕ�.\R����}ų�'Ε�u��%p5+s�>��b1�,�\__�R��d2�Öo$����c-ǚ�[�T�=�J��N6a�Ѩ��z��GR�n�ۖ���@��Bf�H�̪6���2�Anq;�Uv�֖��YNY��,"\,�i#�x&ႝI N�Æ�����3�� ��h��L���g�Ia�(�ќS^9{��f���z@)�ɗ�p��2���p����[�:HW�/� E#!�����=%OEC��ԧ�W��ޖ�Y?�P�;|��/�����$���`���E+��ɬД�s�&���E��y��k�sm���_LX��K:�;Cࣔ�n�y�ߏON�r�� ��lt�}),I�1w`� VH��Gs��MC �͇SQ1�K��W��H����$C+���!�x��-������T0Kۜ��k�b�� �Y���h4% {��B�j{V(����$���iJ.� ��3v��d�Jd!��ҹ��H{}q���t9���14�<)%�\�ūґx2B�r�\ �KQ ŭ,�������̱#�o��v���<-lGk���5�
=]�B�ru$�A ��e��&�*��k��(�?/�>�w%c��=1 2B2�C����Ҫd<���'E��$�Ίv�P�L��w���BL>�����q���r9|�� ����L��1���mC�P�'�E{ %�pNy����zz����s�H$*����j�Z*{���(���y+w�Ng$� �Ў�$Z/[
���SM'.t|�Ju�d��Az
W�uL�K��QΔ��e�i�-I9s�r�|.�1+�/�\S�G>�r��Ʒ���s�߼�� ��I4S�ֆ�T��[�r��=�6�h�L�[�Tk���+�X�C: q���������(�?x���<&������%�������)�f �6��e�D����!���Z��o�/�PP��L0\�ɏ��7E�j���������5 i��D��K�Fs���� �HEF�(v�w��^)*�dTVӊ�ϊ^34v������Z_��(�W�#�`�� endstream endobj 121 0 obj << /Type /FontDescriptor /Ascent 0 /CapHeight 0 /Descent 0 /Flags 4 /FontBBox [-23 -1667 1720 881] /FontName /MMGIPF+wasy10 /ItalicAngle 0 /StemV 25 /StemH 22 /CharSet (/leadsto) /FontFile3 122 0 R >> endobj 122 0 obj << /Length 281 /Subtype /Type1C >> stream



MMGIPF+wasy10


"�
��t�}��� � ����

%+1leadstoCopyright 1998 Taco HoekwaterNormalwasy10
�
;

}���|� �ӳӴ
��������a� =�%M[��Y�]O�87OIU]��������������Ľ���ɻ[R�U��I�� ����^chYuR�����ѮE�U�o�m�R�Y�c���Cy
� � ������� endstream endobj 123 0 obj << /Type /FontDescriptor /Ascent 0 /CapHeight 733 /Descent 0 /Flags 96 /FontBBox [-2 -300 1240 728] /FontName /MMGIBK+rsfs10 /ItalicAngle -12 /StemV 22 /StemH 22 /CharSet (/T/M) /FontFile3 124 0 R >> endobj 124 0 obj << /Length 857 /Subtype /Type1C >> stream



MMGIBK+rsfs10


!�
�������l�����

9?Copyright (c) Taco Hoekwater, 1998. All rights reserved.rsfs10.5

~�����g���w�|��Mw�w���sy��~����������������{�xzw�~������~y�{~f�w��"��S��������5� (� 7� gW{Z�_�}o�n���;�Y��������������L*R)F*k^~_e�����h��m���������������������������������rhjgcm�tliyr���������������������� �'��������������������=�+������

---