Does a wise man answer with empty counselIn the context of the Book of Job, this phrase is part of Eliphaz's second speech to Job. Eliphaz challenges Job's wisdom, suggesting that a truly wise person would not speak with "empty counsel." This reflects the cultural value placed on wisdom in ancient Near Eastern societies, where wisdom was associated with practical knowledge and moral integrity. The term "empty counsel" implies advice or words lacking substance or truth, which Eliphaz accuses Job of providing. This accusation is significant in the broader biblical narrative, as wisdom is a central theme in books like Proverbs and Ecclesiastes, where true wisdom is often linked to the fear of the Lord (
Proverbs 9:10).
or fill his belly with the hot east wind?
The "hot east wind" is a metaphor for something destructive and useless. In the geographical context of the ancient Near East, the east wind, known as the sirocco, was a dry, scorching wind that could devastate crops and landscapes. This imagery is used elsewhere in Scripture to denote judgment or desolation (e.g., Jeremiah 18:17, Hosea 13:15). Eliphaz uses this metaphor to suggest that Job's words are not only empty but also potentially harmful and destructive. Theologically, this can be seen as a critique of speaking without divine insight or understanding, contrasting with the wisdom that comes from God, which is life-giving and sustaining.
Persons / Places / Events
1.
Eliphaz the TemaniteOne of Job's three friends who comes to comfort him. In this chapter, Eliphaz is speaking, offering his perspective on Job's suffering and perceived folly.
2.
JobThe central figure of the Book of Job, a man of great faith and integrity who undergoes severe trials and suffering.
3.
TemanA region in Edom, known for its wise men. Eliphaz, being a Temanite, is presumed to be wise and knowledgeable.
4.
The East WindIn the ancient Near East, the east wind was often associated with destruction and desolation, symbolizing something harsh and unproductive.
5.
The DialogueThis verse is part of the larger dialogue between Job and his friends, where they debate the reasons for Job's suffering and the nature of wisdom.
Teaching Points
The Nature of True WisdomTrue wisdom is not just about speaking but about speaking with purpose and truth. Eliphaz challenges Job to consider whether his words are truly wise or just empty rhetoric.
The Dangers of Empty WordsWords have power and can either build up or tear down. Like the east wind, empty words can be destructive and unproductive.
Discernment in CounselWhen offering advice or counsel, it is crucial to ensure that it is grounded in truth and love, rather than assumptions or personal biases.
The Role of Suffering in UnderstandingSuffering can be a teacher, but it requires humility and openness to learn from it. Eliphaz's critique suggests that Job's suffering should lead to introspection and growth.
The Importance of ListeningIn conversations, especially those involving suffering, listening is as important as speaking. Eliphaz's approach reminds us to listen carefully before responding.
Bible Study Questions and Answers
1. What is the meaning of Job 15:2?
2. How does Job 15:2 challenge us to seek wisdom over empty words?
3. What does Job 15:2 reveal about the importance of godly speech?
4. How can Job 15:2 guide us in discerning wise counsel from foolishness?
5. In what ways does Job 15:2 connect with James 3 on controlling the tongue?
6. How can we apply the lesson of Job 15:2 in daily conversations?
7. What does Job 15:2 reveal about human wisdom versus divine wisdom?
8. How does Job 15:2 challenge the value of human reasoning?
9. Why does Eliphaz criticize Job's words in Job 15:2?
10. What are the top 10 Lessons from Job 15?
11. When is it time to be silent or speak?
12. Are you truly listening to God's guidance?
13. What does the Bible say about global warming?
14. What advice do the ungodly offer?What Does Job 15:2 Mean
Does a wise man answer with empty counsel• Eliphaz challenges Job’s claim to wisdom by pointing out that truly wise speech carries substance, not hollowness. Proverbs 15:2 says, “The tongue of the wise commends knowledge, but the mouth of the fool spouts folly”, underscoring that wisdom and emptiness cannot coexist.
• “Empty counsel” exposes words that lack grounding in God’s truth. Proverbs 10:19 warns, “When words are many, transgression is unavoidable, but he who restrains his lips is wise”. Eliphaz implies that Job’s lengthy defenses have drifted into unprofitable territory.
• For the believer, wisdom is anchored in fearing the Lord (Proverbs 9:10) and aligning words with His revealed will (2 Timothy 3:16–17). Anything else—no matter how heartfelt—rings hollow.
or fill his belly with the hot east wind?• The “east wind” in Scripture is a scorching desert blast that withers crops and topples ships (Genesis 41:6; Jonah 4:8). Eliphaz uses the image to paint Job’s words as destructive gusts rather than refreshing truth. Hosea 12:1 draws a similar picture: “Ephraim feeds on the wind and pursues the east wind all day”.
• “Fill his belly” implies internalizing and being satisfied by his own bluster. Ecclesiastes 1:14 observes, “all is vanity, a chasing after the wind”. Eliphaz accuses Job of nourishing himself on vanity instead of God’s wisdom.
• Scripture contrasts this emptiness with the satisfying fare of God’s Word: “Your words were found, and I ate them, and Your words became to me a joy” (Jeremiah 15:16). Speech that lacks that nourishment is little more than hot air.
summaryJob 15:2 confronts the difference between words filled with God-given wisdom and words that are empty, self-satisfying gusts of hot wind. Eliphaz wrongly concludes that Job’s arguments fall into the latter category, yet the principle is timeless: wisdom speaks with substance, humility, and reverence for God, while folly multiplies words that neither edify others nor honor the Lord.
(2)
Should a wise man utter vain knowledge . . .--Job therefore is not wise, and his words have been vain and windy.
Parallel Commentaries ...
Hebrew
“Does a wiseהֶֽחָכָ֗ם (he·ḥā·ḵām)Article | Adjective - masculine singular
Strong's 2450: Wiseman answerיַעֲנֶ֥ה (ya·‘ă·neh)Verb - Qal - Imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 6030: To answer, respondwith emptyר֑וּחַ (rū·aḥ)Noun - common singular
Strong's 7307: Wind, breath, exhalation, life, anger, unsubstantiality, a region of the sky, spiritcounselדַֽעַת־ (ḏa·‘aṯ-)Noun - feminine singular construct
Strong's 1847: Knowledgeor fillוִֽימַלֵּ֖א (wî·mal·lê)Conjunctive waw | Verb - Piel - Conjunctive imperfect - third person masculine singular
Strong's 4390: To fill, be full ofhis bellyבִּטְנֽוֹ׃ (biṭ·nōw)Noun - feminine singular construct | third person masculine singular
Strong's 990: The belly, the womb, the bosom, body of anythingwith the hot east wind?קָדִ֣ים (qā·ḏîm)Noun - masculine singular
Strong's 6921: The fore, front part, the East
Links
Job 15:2 NIVJob 15:2 NLTJob 15:2 ESVJob 15:2 NASBJob 15:2 KJV
Job 15:2 BibleApps.comJob 15:2 Biblia ParalelaJob 15:2 Chinese BibleJob 15:2 French BibleJob 15:2 Catholic Bible
OT Poetry: Job 15:2 Should a wise man answer with vain (Jb)