Picking the Right Candidate: Evidence-Based Selection
Keep adding new skills with 10,000+ programs for $239 (usually $399). Save now.
Picking the Right Candidate: Evidence-Based Selection
This course is part of Recruiting & Onboarding for Today’s Workforce Specialization
Instructor: Evan Kimbrell
Included with
Ask Coursera
Recommended experience
Recommended experience
What you'll learn
Define a hiring bar and build a structured evaluation framework for any role
Run interviews and exercises that collect real evidence instead of vague impressions
Make fairer, more consistent hiring decisions and document them clearly for handoff
Details to know
April 2026
8 assignments
See how employees at top companies are mastering in-demand skills
Build your subject-matter expertise
- Learn new concepts from industry experts
- Gain a foundational understanding of a subject or tool
- Develop job-relevant skills with hands-on projects
- Earn a shareable career certificate
There are 4 modules in this course
In this course, you will learn how to define a clear hiring bar, turn success profiles into weighted competencies, run structured interviews, capture evidence instead of impressions, and make stronger hiring decisions with more fairness and consistency. You will also learn how to compare close candidates, manage hiring risks, shape roles thoughtfully, and document decisions in a way that supports onboarding and long-term success.
What makes this course unique is its focus on the full selection system, not just interview tactics in isolation. Instead of treating hiring as a series of gut calls, it shows how hiring bar setting, competency design, structured questions, scorecards, bias checks, decision models, reference checks, and decision memos all work together. The approach is practical, modern, and designed for real workplace constraints. Whether you are a hiring manager, recruiter, or HR partner, this course will help you make more evidence-based decisions, improve consistency across interviewers, and choose candidates with greater confidence.
What's included
3 videos9 readings2 assignments
3 videos•Total 20 minutes
- What Is a “Hiring Bar” and Why It Matters•7 minutes
- From Success Profile to Weighted Competencies•7 minutes
- Designing a Simple Evaluation Framework•6 minutes
9 readings•Total 245 minutes
- Must-Haves vs. Trainables vs. Nice-to-Haves•30 minutes
- Hiring Bar Builder Worksheet•30 minutes
- Deepening your understanding of hiring bars and structured selection•40 minutes
- Common Competency Categories and What They Actually Mean•10 minutes
- Worksheet: Success Profile → Competency Translator•30 minutes
- Translating success profiles into competencies that actually matter•40 minutes
- Behavioral Anchors That Actually Improve Ratings•10 minutes
- How to Run a 15-Minute Pre-Brief•10 minutes
- Building a stronger interview framework before the interviews start•45 minutes
2 assignments•Total 90 minutes
- Module 1 Knowledge Check•30 minutes
- Define the Hiring Bar and Build the Evaluation Framework•60 minutes
What's included
3 videos6 readings2 assignments
3 videos•Total 20 minutes
- Turning Competencies into Questions & Exercises•7 minutes
- Structured Note-Taking & Evidence, Not Vibes•7 minutes
- Fairness & Bias Checks During Evidence Collection•6 minutes
6 readings•Total 190 minutes
- Worksheet: Competency-to-Question Builder + Exercise Design Template•30 minutes
- Strengthening interview questions and job-relevant exercises•40 minutes
- Worksheet: Interview Evidence Capture Practice•30 minutes
- Making interview evidence clearer, stronger, and more comparable•45 minutes
- Examples List: Biased Comments vs. Evidence-Based Comments•10 minutes
- Strengthening fairness during interviews and evidence collection•35 minutes
2 assignments•Total 90 minutes
- Module 2 Knowledge Check•30 minutes
- Applying Evidence-Based Interview Design and Evaluation•60 minutes
What's included
3 videos6 readings2 assignments
3 videos•Total 20 minutes
- Decision Models & Evidence Synthesis•7 minutes
- Tie-Break Rules & Portfolio Thinking•7 minutes
- Bias & Fairness Checks at Decision Time•5 minutes
6 readings•Total 170 minutes
- Examples List: What Different Candidate Profile Patterns Usually Mean•15 minutes
- Moving from interview feedback to a clear hiring decision•40 minutes
- Worksheet: Tie-Break Decision Matrix + No-Hire Test•30 minutes
- Handling close calls: tie-breaks, team mix, and no-hire discipline•40 minutes
- How “Culture Fit” Becomes a Bias Shortcut•10 minutes
- Keeping final hiring decisions fair, evidence-based, and bias-aware•35 minutes
2 assignments•Total 90 minutes
- Module 3 Knowledge Check•30 minutes
- Choosing Between Two Strong Finalists•60 minutes
What's included
3 videos6 readings2 assignments
3 videos•Total 23 minutes
- Team Coverage, Portfolio Fit & Role Shaping/Leveling•8 minutes
- Risk Registers & Reference Checks•8 minutes
- Decision Documentation & Handoff (Decision Memo)•8 minutes
6 readings•Total 170 minutes
- Examples List: When Role Shaping Makes Sense vs. When It Creates Chaos•10 minutes
- Mapping team gaps, role shape, and level more strategically•50 minutes
- Mini Case Study: Choosing Between the “Impressive” Candidate and the Lower-Risk Candidate•20 minutes
- Managing hiring risk with better reference checks and mitigation plans•40 minutes
- Examples: Weak Decision Memo Statements vs. Strong Ones•10 minutes
- Documenting the rationale behind a hire and handing it forward•40 minutes
2 assignments•Total 90 minutes
- Module 4 Knowledge Check•30 minutes
- Final Hiring Decision: Role Shape, Risk, and Decision Memo•60 minutes
Earn a career certificate
Add this credential to your LinkedIn profile, resume, or CV. Share it on social media and in your performance review.
Instructor
Offered by
Explore more from Leadership and Management
- Status: Free Trial
Course
- Status: Free TrialS
SkillUp
Course
- Status: Free Trial
Course
Why people choose Coursera for their career
Frequently asked questions
To access the course materials, assignments and to earn a Certificate, you will need to purchase the Certificate experience when you enroll in a course. You can try a Free Trial instead, or apply for Financial Aid. The course may offer 'Full Course, No Certificate' instead. This option lets you see all course materials, submit required assessments, and get a final grade. This also means that you will not be able to purchase a Certificate experience.
When you enroll in the course, you get access to all of the courses in the Specialization, and you earn a certificate when you complete the work. Your electronic Certificate will be added to your Accomplishments page - from there, you can print your Certificate or add it to your LinkedIn profile.
Yes. In select learning programs, you can apply for financial aid or a scholarship if you can’t afford the enrollment fee. If fin aid or scholarship is available for your learning program selection, you’ll find a link to apply on the description page.
More questions
Financial aid available,