Talk:Carrot

I want to point out that there might be something wrong with the amount of items a full grown crop drops when broken. It says it is 1-5 but that doesn't make any sense because the wiki about fortune states that when no fortune is used there are three attempts with a 57% chance of success. It also says that carrots and potatoes add a fixed amount to that. Potatoes add 2 and I guess carrots add 1 because that would explain why the minimum is 1, also the same wiki page in dutch states 1-4 so I think there has been made a mistake. So I'm asking to change it to 1-4. –Preceding unsigned comment was added by Kwikenkwak (talk • contribs) at 11:17, 26 September 2020‎ (UTC). Please sign your posts with ~~~~

@Kwikenkwak: The change from 4 to 5 carrots was made by an anonymous IP address without explanation in this edit over a year ago, and nobody caught it. I've corrected it. I've harvested a lot of carrots and don't recall ever getting 5 carrots from a crop. ~ Amatulic (talk) 20:24, 26 September 2020 (UTC)

Why is 12w34a duplicated? I think there is a typo. Ioallse-oldccvedcewd 21:17, 28 May 2022 (UTC)

The wiki states that carrots have 8 states, which is not wrong, but it is a bit misleading. If someone is waiting for `age:8` in the debug menu, it will never happen because the states are numbered 0-7. Maybe the article text (for all growable foods) should be updated to be less ambiguous. Maybe say "go through 8 stages of growth (ages 0-7)" or "go through 8 stages of growth, and are ready to harvest at age 7" or similar? – Unsigned comment added by 97.113.247.179 (talk) at 04:02, 29 November 2025 (UTC). Please sign comments with ~~~~

I don't think its misleading. It never implies that the stages start at 1. It just says there are 8 stages. When you go to § Data values it says clearly the age values are 0–7. So you will only go wrong if you make an assumption that doesn't follow from the article content (that IDs are guessable, which is a weird assumption to make).  Nixinova  T ⁄ C  04:08, 29 November 2025 (UTC)