Dungeons II talk:Mob

Hi @User:Drour1234, I noticed you undid all my deletion requests for mobs like MCD2:Enchantsmith or MCD2:Calico Cat that were only briefly shown in the cinematic trailer. I really do not think we should have these pages for the following reasons:

1. Mobs revealed in a cinematic trailer are not garunteed to come to the game. They can just as well be using certain Dungeons I/vanilla mobs to set the scene to transition into the story of Dungeons II. Having these pages, even if marked as them being only appearing in the trailer, will easily mislead people into believing that these are confirmed features that will appear by virtue of having a dedicated page to itself.
2. There is not enough substance to warrant any of these having their own page, as the contents of the articles are soley mentioning they appeared in a cinematic trailer with a couple of screenshots. If barring point 1 they are kept, then we will have a bunch of articles with likely only a few sentences of information. It is much better suited to have these in the Dungeons II:Mob page (which I had kept) with the note that they appear in a cinematic trailer, and/or in the the Dungeons II:Announce Trailer article itself

Please let me know what you, as well as anyone else reading this, thinks. Thanks! TheCaptainYaya (talk) 02:41, 31 May 2026 (UTC)

After looking into things, I retract my position for all of the current mobs and think we should keep these ones at least. Though all my reasoning in general for the above points still stands. TheCaptainYaya (talk) 14:28, 31 May 2026 (UTC)

The Dungeons II namespace encompasses more than the game itself, including the prequel book and the trailers. However, I could support making such pages into redirects (but not deleting them) to the pages for what they appear in.Drour1234 (talk) 01:14, 1 June 2026 (UTC)

During the Bobicraft gameplay video, after they defeat the Twisted Warden, the game tells them to check on the trapped echo golem. Should we have a area on this page for mentioned mobs? BlueTuxedo64 (talk) 21:51, 22 June 2026 (UTC)